Time Marches Yawn

Those who remember the past are doomed to sit through dated and dull Tintypes

As a result of having recently witnessed Phoenix Theatre's production of Tintypes, I am much too ill to write a theater review this week. Instead, I am submitting the notes I made while watching this program, a musical revue about turn-of-the-19th-century America, which should (despite several lively performances by some of our better musical comedy stars) be avoided at all costs.

Things I'd Rather Be Doing Right Now: Sleeping; having my gallbladder removed; giving birth to shattered china; anything that doesn't involve watching local talent squandered; anything that doesn't involve 47 musical numbers about the plight of the working class in pre-World War I America.

What I'm Wondering While I Watch These Actors Embarrass Themselves: What possessed playwright Mary Kyte to create a musical revue about 1890s social injustice, immigration, politics and vaudeville? When was the last time anyone asked to hear "Ta-Ra-Ra Boom-De-Ay!"? If this show sucks when presented by clever performers like Stephen Goodfriend and Katherine Todd, what must it be like with a less talented cast? Do the players resent having to appear in dreck in order to keep their Equity cards? Does Phoenix Theatre have a death wish? If actors were paid to write commentaries about theater critics, what would they say?

Yore history: Amy Jo Arrington and Stephen Goodfriend in Tintypes.
Yore history: Amy Jo Arrington and Stephen Goodfriend in Tintypes.

Minorities That Are Misrepresented in Tintypes: African Americans; the wealthy; vaudevillians; Italian immigrants; politicians; socialists; the poor; choreographers and lighting designers with talent.

Tricks to Avoid If I Am Ever Stupid Enough to Write a Musical: Production numbers that end in a kick line; all forms of pantomime; musical numbers that employ intricate choreography involving a tambourine; audience participation; a medley that includes "You're a Grand Old Flag" and "Bill Bailey, Won't You Please Come Home?"; the assumption that audiences will enjoy the notion of Teddy Roosevelt as a cuddly song-and-dance man.

Things to Compare This Production To If I Decide to Review It: An appendectomy, sans anesthesia; every one of the cheesy floor shows at Disneyland; an addle-brained commercial for patriotism; a conspiracy designed to destroy the careers of several of our more talented local singer/actors; an unpleasant form of torture.

A Role Better Suited to Musical Theater Actresses Who've Recently Left a Road Company of The Phantom of the Opera: Doorstop.

Theories About the Wig Michelle Gardner Wears in This Show: It's meant to inspire sympathy; it's on backward; costumer Stephen M. Miller is jealous of the glowing reviews Gardner has received this season (while his work goes largely unnoticed), and he's punishing her by making her wear a turd on her head.

Good Things That Happened at Tintypes: Katherine Todd sang "Nobody"; Michelle Gardner sang "Jonah Man"; I met Shauna Rabinowitz's sister at intermission; nobody sang "Danny Boy"; Amy Jo Arrington occasionally left the stage; I was able at last to experience outspoken socialist leader Emma Goldman as a musical-comedy star; the curtain eventually came down.

Warnings I Should Have Heeded: Every one of the people I invited to see this show declined my invitation; when the first number (a long, long medley that included a galling rendition of "Come Take a Trip in My Airship") ended, no one applauded; when I told my friend Veronica that I was going to see Tintypes, she said, "Gee, that's too bad."

Possible Other Uses for Tintypes: As a replacement for rat poison; as a tool for parents who want to keep their children from studying theater arts; as a means of making death seem more attractive. Phoenix Theatre's production of Tintypes continues through Sunday, February 27, on the company's mainstage, 100 East McDowell.

My Voice Nation Help
Phoenix Concert Tickets