By Melissa Fossum
By Lauren Wise
By New Times
By Amanda Savage
By Jason P. Woodbury
By Troy Farah
By New Times
Mostly, the music isn't quite as unique as the titles, but mostly, that doesn't matter. Dillinger Four, currently being hyped as the new hope for punk resurgence, is actually a very inventive band, with fair and proper influences. In the traded high-and-low, melodic growling of its two lead singers, there's a hint of the kind of vocal contrast Mick Jones and Joe Strummer used to excellent effect, though Dillinger Four's musical heritage seems to suggest Superchunk more than the Clash. The 13 songs on the very brief Versus God are, by and large, interesting and well-executed, the title-to-lyrics disparity noted above notwithstanding.
Dillinger Four's strong suit is, in fact, its lyrical ambiguity, which allows for hearing Versus God as both a melodic-core punk album and something slightly more thoughtful. "Maximum Piss & Vinegar" works equally well whether you hear its lyrics as general venting or as a slam on insular punk snobbery à la MRR: "I'm one step quicker than the last motherfucker/That you thought you got over on . . . /You let your comfort get the best of you/You'll never see it coming, out of the blue/Like it was nothing, but you will know your situation/Because the end was your creation."
The most genuine rave-up on the album, "Define 'Learning Disorder,'" layers its observations on educational authority with references to lock-step mentality of all stripes: "Listen up, sit straight/That's the only way you'll get a break/Sitting still ain't such a bitter pill/For goodness sake."
Even lines like, "The weight of the world nearly broke their wrists/And now those wrists are slit" are delivered quickly and un-self-consciously enough that they don't come off maudlin, even if Dillinger Four clearly has a beef with the notion of conformity (as evidenced by the disc's title) vast enough that it eventually creeps into every song, thus blunting the message somewhat.
Musically, Dillinger Four won't satisfy the hard-core crowd, but the hook-heavy tunes on Versus God work to good effect, particularly when they complement the band's wide vocal range. Dillinger Four's upbeat and crafty music belies the pain and urgency of the lyrics; it's worth a repeated listen.