By Aaron Cutler
By Amy Nicholson
By Simon Abrams
By Chris Klimek
By Nick Schager
By Stephanie Zacharek
By Stephanie Zacharek
By Alan Scherstuhl
The opening credit sequence of Windtalkers a montage of Monument Valley instantly invokes memories of the opening of John Woo's immediately previous film, Mission: Impossible 2, in which Tom Cruise was dangling off a rock. It is the last moment of similarity between the two.
Windtalkers is a World War II epic, based on a fascinating and relatively obscure story from that war: In order to frustrate Japanese codebreakers, the U.S. Marines recruited 29 Navajo Indians to develop a code based on their language a tongue the Japanese were unlikely to identify, let alone have experts in. (Other Native American languages had been similarly used in World War I, though apparently to a lesser extent.) Eventually hundreds of Navajo "codetalkers" were employed as the backbone of communication in the Pacific war effort. It wasn't until 1968 that the code was declassified and the story emerged.
After a very brief introduction to codetalkers-to-be Ben Yahzee (Adam Beach) and Charlie Whitehorse (Roger Willie), we meet the movie's real protagonist, Sergeant Joe Enders (Nicolas Cage), in the midst of a frightening and chilling battle, during which his strict adherence to orders gets everyone under his command killed. Despite being haunted by this failure or, perhaps, because of it Enders is eager to get back into action, as though he will be able to atone next time around. But he's setting himself up for an even worse situation: The superior officers love the fact that Enders insisted on enforcing military discipline, even when it was the wrong move. So they assign him as Ben Yahzee's babysitter, charged with protecting the code first and Yahzee second. That is, Enders' boss makes it clear that, if capture seems imminent, Enders should kill Yahzee rather than risk him being tortured and giving up the code. Sergeant "Ox" Henderson (Christian Slater), Charlie Whitehorse's escort, is given the same orders. (Would such orders be given so blithely if the codetalkers were white? The film never really approaches this issue.)
Historically, there doesn't seem to be any evidence that such a policy existed, but it sets up the perfect emotional/moral conflict for the already tormented Enders. Last time Enders followed orders, all his friends got killed. This time he's being asked to commit a more active sin of commission, even though the notion of killing another Marine is anathema to him. To avoid bonding with Yahzee, Enders does his best to be even more of a cold son of a bitch than might be his nature, but Yahzee is too likable a guy for Enders to hold out forever.
Always a brilliant technician, Woo has, in Windtalkers, applied his skills to a handsome production, with several battle scenes of nearly unbearable tension. Yet in many ways, Windtalkers feels like he's playing against his strengths. For a start, fans of the sort of beautifully choreographed and edited action sequences that catapulted Woo to fame will find very little of that here. War films, as a genre, are less conducive to aesthetically pleasing, slo-mo shootouts and stunts than are urban gangster movies. The director is more constrained here by realism. In fact, it might have seemed downright offensive to use his dynamic, multiple-speed action montage style here.
Woo's best films also are marked by unabashed earnestness and melodrama. This one has both in spades. Unfortunately, in a World War II setting, we've seen it too many times before Windtalkers reprises all the old standards, like the guy with his wife's picture in his hat, who might as well have a big "kill me" sign painted on his back in fluorescent orange. The over-the-top sincerity that is so rewarding in Face/Off (1998), Woo's best American film, feels too clichéd in this more conventional context.
However, the movie does develop a real wallop by the end, driven largely by Cage's performance. As usual, Cage seems possessed in his role. (Slater, no stranger to excess himself, plays it straight, functioning as a more approachable figure, as he did in Broken Arrow.) The rest of the cast is reasonably effective, although, as Enders' commander, the usually wonderful Peter Stormare sports an accent that is both distracting and, at times, nearly incomprehensible.
Par for the course, it seems as though a major studio couldn't quite bring itself to tell this sort of story strictly from the Native American point of view, rather than making it mostly about the white guy. As strong as Enders' thematic material is, there is a second story going on here the feelings of the Navajos, who are painfully aware of their second-class status, even as they bend over backwards and get themselves killed trying to prove just what good citizens they are. We get some of that story, and at moments Beach and Cage seem almost to be given equal emotional weight. But only at moments.
Join My Voice Nation for free stuff, film info & more!