By Stephanie Zacharek
By Robrt L. Pela
By Aaron Cutler
By Amy Nicholson
By Simon Abrams
By Chris Klimek
By Nick Schager
By Stephanie Zacharek
DreamWorks is so eager to have you believe in its latest family movie that the words "Inspired by a True Story" are actually part of the title. Yep, Dreamer: Inspired by a True Story is the proper name, and publicists have been well-coached to say and write out the whole thing every time.
A close look at the end credits, however, reveals the following disclaimer: "All of the characters have been invented and the specific events are entirely fictitious." Whuh? By that standard, couldn't one make the case that every screenplay is inspired by a true story? Odd thing is, the deception is pointless: True stories aren't exactly box-office gold anyway -- if they were, documentaries would be the top-grossing movies, not the small change they normally are.
The only thing that really matters is whether the movie's any good, and the answer here is a qualified "no." Qualified in the sense that if you're a little girl in the Lisa Simpson mold, for whom the greatest wish-fulfillment in the world would be to have your own pony, then Dreamerjust might be for you. Dakota Fanning is actually starting to bear an uncanny resemblance to Homer's daughter, come to think of it.
Dreamer is the story of a horse named . . . Soñador. That's Spanish for "Dreamer," and also a less marketable title. And since they invented the horse's name for the movie, why not make it an English one to begin with? Don't ask. Soñador, nicknamed "Sonya," is but one of many horses in the stable of rich, racist Mr. Palmer (David Morse), who insists on running her even when trainer Ben Crane (Kurt Russell), who apparently speaks Equestrian, knows for sure that Sonya just told him she doesn't want to race. Sonya proceeds to break a leg, but Ben won't kill her like Palmer insists he should. Instead, he quits his job and takes the horse as his own, much to the delight of daughter Cale (Fanning) and the disgust of Ben's crusty old Pop (Kris Kristofferson).
A bunch of stuff happens that's too annoying and too obvious to bother mentioning . . . the short version is that eventually Cale ends up being Sonya's owner, and Sonya gets to race again. Not exactly the deepest of tales, yet first-time director John Gatins feels compelled to mention 9/11 as the reason he made this movie, because, being the son of a police officer, he got very emotional and patriotic and decided "to explore a world steeped in Americana, which I think horse racing really is." Ooookay. Maybe that also explains the presence of two Middle Eastern princes (Oded Fehr and Antonio Albadran), forever locked in a pointless rivalry over horses.
It's tempting to suggest that the "true story" that inspired Gatins is the story of a summer day when he entered a darkened movie theater and watched Seabiscuit. The same platitudes are on offer here about how healing an injured horse ultimately heals an entire family. Choice lines of dialogue include: "You saved her life -- she's just returning the favor"; "Since she's been in that barn, we have a family for the first time in years"; "She wasn't just some horse, she was our horse!"; and this gem, delivered by Fanning: "Please don't treat me like a little kid" (honey, look in the mirror).
Speaking of Fanning, who seems pretty smart for her age, you have to wonder if she's familiar with the term "overexposure." Yeah, she's got acting skills, but being in every movie made about little girls tends to wear out one's welcome. Other little girls need work, too; howzabout spreading the wealth a bit more, huh?
There's nothing in Dreamer: Inspired by a True Story that's surprising in the least, unless you count the presence of Luis Guzmán in a movie that's otherwise entirely populated by good-looking people. He's primarily there so that David Morse can keep using the term "Mexican" derisively; any stronger kind of racial slur would presumably not be acceptable in a kids' movie. Guzmán has done some of his best acting ever recently in his high-profile, fake public feud with Waiting . . .director Rob McKittrick, but any coolness points he gained from punking the public are more or less lost by being associated with this "pet horsey" movie.
If you have a little daughter, and she insists you take her, try to fall asleep quickly -- the true story of your very own dreaming is bound to be an improvement over what's on-screen.
Join My Voice Nation for free stuff, film info & more!