Loan Sharks

The governor's chosen loan authority is determined to keep its monopoly

AHELA is making some progress. John Naimetz, financial aid director at the University of Arizona, says typically he won't recommend lenders to students unless the lender reaches a certain volume by finding students on its own.

But Naimetz made a special exception for AHELA after seeing how good its prices were: Thanks to low interest rates and no origination fee, students who sign with AHELA for $38,000 in loans would owe $4,000 less than if they went with some of the other lenders on Naimetz's list.

But, as Naimetz admits, the student loan market is crowded with competitors, desperate for a piece of the business. AHELA is still handling just 4 percent of the business at the UofA.

The governor claims she didn't know that allies like Billy Shields were running the loan company AHELA.
Giulio Sciorio
The governor claims she didn't know that allies like Billy Shields were running the loan company AHELA.

Even with all those tax-free bonds to subsidize them, as it turns out, AHELA's loans are still just comparable to the in-house loans offered by the university. And those have an added benefit to students, Naimetz says, because the University of Arizona takes all its loan profits and channels them back into scholarships for its students.

"For every $10 million we do in business, we generate about $150,000 for student grants," Naimetz says. "We take what we need to run the program — but that's just about nothing."

Rose defends AHELA in part by saying its nonprofit status gives it a similar structure: Rather than enrich shareholders, AHELA will use its profits to provide ever better rates, not to mention scholarships.

Incredibly, two years and $236 million in tax-free bonds later, AHELA has yet to issue a single scholarship. But Rose says it has plans to do so, and not just the one-year, $2,500 Arizona 9/11 Memorial Scholarship currently advertised on the company's Web site.

"We'll have a Barry Goldwater Scholarship, a Mo Udall Scholarship," Rose says, referring to the late senator and late congressman. "The bottom line is that money from these loans is not being shipped off to shareholders. It's being plowed back into scholarships."

But the question remains of just how long AHELA can keep its monopoly. After all, the governor has asked the commerce department to investigate AHELA's formation and performance. She's also denied that she knew Cantelme and his cronies were involved with the group, saying her staff had contact with them, but she didn't.

(It should be noted that Napolitano's protests, while possibly accurate, seem fairly disingenuous. Cantelme's name is all over the group's articles of incorporation, as well as the documents asking for bond allocations — each of which the governor ultimately signed off on.)

And at least one group is vying to get some of the work for itself. Cology, the Scottsdale-based financial aid company, once handled the marketing work for AHELA, and even lost its employee, Murphy, who became AHELA's director. Now the company has hired a lobbyist, Larry Pike.

Pike confirms that he's been meeting with legislators to discuss the idea of allowing competition for the bond work.

Rose says he's convinced that Cology is behind AHELA's recent spat of negative publicity. However, this reporter, for one, had never heard of the company prior to Rose's bringing it to New Times' attention. (Thanks for the tip, Jason.)

Cology's CEO, Paul Rehnberg, says he hasn't been driving the press coverage in any way. He has nothing against AHELA, he says. He's just questioning whether Arizona has chosen the best system.

Like Arizona, the nonprofit bond seller in Washington state was sold to a for-profit company two years ago and pulled out of the business. But unlike Arizona, Washington's governor didn't choose an untested entity to jump-start a new process. Instead, the state sent out formal "requests for information" to more than a dozen groups, asking them for their thoughts and proposals on how to set up a new plan and oversee it.

Rehnberg says Cology was asked to submit a proposal — something the company was happy to do. But now Rehnberg wonders if Arizona would consider opening the door to companies other than AHELA. Yes, his company is a for-profit, which appears to be strictly forbidden when it comes to tax-exempt bonds. But Rehnberg says he's exploring his options.

"There really isn't anything about what we're doing that's directed at or intended to cause any harm or ill will to AHELA," he insists.

Then again, with a $91 million revenue stream up for grabs, and the governor running for cover, it's easy to understand why Jason Rose might be feeling paranoid.

Stay tuned . . .

« Previous Page
My Voice Nation Help

Yes, great story about loan sharks! To be honest to say that I have read out this entire article and understood everything clearly.  So at the end I just wanna to say that if anybody or any company takes loan then need to use that properly and need to build up the ability to repay the loan on time. Otherwise the loan will be huge burden rather than getting any benefit. So just safe loan will be here....


Many lenders like payday lenders are accused of being loan sharks. However, if you understand the concept of a loan you can avoid getting stuck in a huge amount of debt. If you repay your loan on time, you will make the best use of the loan without paying too much interest.


There really many loan companies. Every tries to offer you taking loan at their firm. If you really want to take fast online loans in US you should find trusted lender. You must be sure that the rates won’t rise and that this company is really good. People who take short term loans know exactly what companies you can turn to and which the best is.


Phoenix Concert Tickets