Only sheriff's guards had contact with Crenshaw in his cell, but Arpaio still maintains that Crenshaw sustained his life-ending injuries by falling out of his bed.
In 2003, attorneys for Crenshaw's family requested copies of the video surveillance that would have shown the initial fight with guards. The MCSO withheld the footage for three years. After a court order, the sheriff produced a grainy and denigrated analog copy of the digital footage. It proved to be useless, the attorneys said.
"Defendants have already admitted that they destroyed Brian's classification files, as well as the digital video data referenced in your September 26, 2006 order," one court filing from the case reads.
Crenshaw's family was represented by attorney Mike Manning, who also represented the family of Scott Norberg. Manning was not a wrongful-death litigator until the death of Norberg, a family friend. Since then, he has represented the families of six deceased inmates in lawsuits against Arpaio. (Manning also represents New Times in current litigation against Arpaio and Maricopa County Attorney Andrew Thomas.)
"They wanted to ensure that the jury, judge, and public couldn't see what happened. If Crenshaw really started the fight, they wouldn't destroy the evidence," Manning says.
"In every case of incriminating video, they copy and copy the footage until it's indecipherable. We always tell them not to touch the evidence. They always do."
CHARLES AGSTER
The MCSO has not only withheld evidence of suspicious deaths, its employees have tampered with evidence, according to the testimony of one former employee.
Charles Agster was a mildly retarded 33-year-old. His parents asked police to pick him up when he wouldn't leave a convenience store.
Agster died after eight jail guards roughed him up and slammed him into a restraint chair (In 2006, a jury awarded his family $9 million after a wrongful-death verdict.).
During the Agster trial, lawyers revealed that jail employees created a fake booking ID so they could alter the answers to Agster's intake questions.
Jail staff also changed records so they could claim Agster was suicidal, banging his head against the floor, and acting intoxicated. During the 2006 trial, it was revealed that those records had been created after Agster died.
Nurse Betty Lewis testified that she was instructed by jail healthcare staff to alter Agster's records — so that his death wouldn't look as suspicious.
As with the other deaths mentioned in this story, the guards involved in Agster's death were never disciplined by the sheriff — even after they were found liable for inmates' deaths.
"Eight of the eight detention officers were found liable. Zero were disciplined. Six have been promoted," Manning says.
Clint Yarborough died in Arpaio's jail in December 2005, after a group of officers beat him, according to another inmate.
In April 2007, the county paid $1 million to settle Yarborough's case.
During an interview with KPHO-TV Channel 5, another inmate, Nathaniel Gatlin, described the frenzy that took place when guards started beating Yarborough.
"That's when I was like, 'What are you guys doing? You're beating him to death. You're hurting him.' And he's telling me, they're telling me, 'Shut up. Mind your own business.' I'm like, 'Well, how can I mind my own business when you're sitting there in front of me, beating the hell out of somebody!?'" Gatlin said.
Until video of Farias' final moments surfaces — if it ever does — the guard's written accounts will serve as the only record of his death. One thing is clear about those accounts: All the guards agree about what happened in the jail that night.
They really agree. In fact, some of them wrote the exact same thing, word for word, comma for comma.
Officer Trueman (B0940) wrote that "Mendoza became very agitated and resistant he was not complying with any of our verbal commands."
So did Officer Kush (A8737). Trueman and Kush's accounts of Farias' death are exact duplicates. Every single word, punctuation mark, and grammatical error is identical. The only difference is their names.
Other officers were subtler in making sure that their stories about Farias' death lined up.
Sergeant Owsley (A5025) and Officer M. Horton (A9866) didn't copy their entire accounts, as Kush and Trueman did, but their reports share a handful of identical sentences.
"Inmate was combative and resistive the entire route; kicking at the Officers and resisting being in the wheelchair," wrote Owsley. So did Horton.
The two also share the exact same wording in the crucial paragraph about the moment when Farias stopped breathing.
"Right wrist was removed from hand cuff and Inmate turned on to his side, at which time we discovered inmate was bleeding, it appeared to be from his nose and mouth . . .," wrote both the guards.
The remaining seven reports tell the same tidy tale, but not word for word. None of the accounts is more than a page.
All the officers say that Farias was "combative" and/or "resisting." They all say that they moved him to a psychiatric cell, and then he just stopped breathing.
Without the video, there's no way to know whether the story is true.
When an inmate dies in Arpaio's jail, it's not the Phoenix Police or any other department that investigates the death. It's the sheriff's own Internal Affairs unit.
As usual Sheriff Arpaio will deny any wrong doing on behalf of the Deputies. He will further deny any knowledge of anything, at any time, about everything in his Sheriff's department. His words of "I know nothing" is getting old. Can he really think the voters in Maricopa County are that stupid?
If you don't believe he is a poor example for a Sheriff I can provide you with about 99.5 million other reasons.
Sheriff Joe, be a man (LMFAO) and RESIGN!
Marijuana is easy to grow and simple to tend. Many of those who choose to grow their own plants say that at least this gives them the assurance of knowing that they are using only marijuana, with nothing added to it without their knowledge.Marijuana Addiction
There is another group of marijuana users; those who suffer from illnesses and have a subscription of medical cannabis. In some cases, medicated forms of cannabis can bring relief in symptoms for those undergoing chemotherapy, are suffering from AIDS and it can be very effective when used in a properly supervised environment, as an analgesic.Marijuana Addiction
If you'll remember: Jefferson Davis McGee who was picked up Maricopa County sheriff�s detectives in 2001 for questioning in the rape and murder of 8-year-old Elizabeth Byrd. Arpaio thought he had his man. And it seems that the sheriff might have gone to great lengths in an attempt to get a confession out of this high-profile suspect.
The problem the sheriff�s office faced was that, after many hours of interrogation, McGee hadn�t confessed to the murder. So sheriff�s personnel decided to book McGee into the jail on an unrelated charge. There was an outstanding warrant against him on an old petty theft beef (turned out McGee wasn�t guilty of that crime, either). Then a strange thing happened. Against departmental policy regarding accused child molesters or child killers, McGee was placed in the jail�s general population of maximum-security inmates. It�s the most dangerous place in the jail. And it�s common knowledge that child molesters, or �chomos� as they�re called by inmates, are in the most danger of all.
Of course, once he was moved, the inevitable happened. Fellow inmates found out what everybody else knew from local TV � that McGee was the key suspect in the girl�s murder. They then spent more than 10 minutes taking turns beating him in his bunk.
The sheriff�s office�s line is that guards didn�t see any train of inmates going in and out of McGee�s cell. But in jail videotapes surrounding the incident obtained by New Times, one guard, Michael Crane, is seen entering the maximum-security pod during the beating, walking to within 10 feet of McGee�s door, talking with two inmates and then leaving. After the guard departs, the beating continues.
McGee barely survived the assault. If he hadn�t been taken to the county hospital for emergency surgery, he would have bled to death. Doctors had to cut open his chest from sternum to pubic bone to save him. Amazingly, he survived with only the loss of his spleen and a grotesque scar.
it looks to me like this drunken bum did this to him self.at least he won't be driving drunk any more and endangering other people.
-----Original Message-----From: Jim Cozzolino Sent: Monday, September 22, 2008 12:15 PMTo: 'phoenix@ic.fbi.gov'Subject: Mugshot Reveals Inmate in Joe Arpaio's Jail Had No Facial Bruises Before His Death
How many people is Arpaio and his Monkey's allowed to kill before someone steps in and stops the maddness ?Can anyone answer that honestly ?Jim Cozzolino
Mugshot Reveals Inmate in Joe Arpaio's Jail Had No Facial Bruises Before His Death Mon Sep 22, 2008 at 07:41:47 AM By John Dickerson Phoenix New Times
http://blogs.phoenixnewtimes.c...
Juan Mendoza Farias appeared to be in good health -- or at least his face was -- in a booking photo taken four days before his bruised body arrived at the county morgue.
Farais, 40, a legal U.S. resident with a valid social security number, died after a violent altercation with Sheriff Joe Arpaio's guards in the Maricopa County Jail. New Times recently wrote about his death, noting that the Sheriff's Office refuses to hand over video footage that could show exactly how much force the guards used.
Since then, the MCSO mailed this booking photo to New Times, as well as a legal statement, asserting that the MCSO will continue to withhold the video. The mugshot shows Farias' face when he was arrested December 2, 2007 on a warrant for violating his probation following a DUI. Around midnight on December 4, 2007, Farias stopped breathing and began bleeding from his nose and mouth while 11 guards reportedly restrained him. He was pronounced dead shortly thereafter. The following photos were taken on December 7, 2007.
Farias' body was beaten and bruised, according to photos and an autopsy report produced by the county Medical Examiner's Office. Welts from "pepper-ball" shots (normally used for crowd control) and from electronic Taser devices are evident on the body.
Since July 25, 2007, the MCSO has refused to produce any records about Farias' death -- with the exception now of this lone booking photo (which the MCSO charged New Times $10.50 to produce).
In its most recent correspondence, the MCSO's legal liaison claims that releasing the video footage of Farais' final moments would compromise its own investigation of the death.
"Investigations can be compromised by the disclosure of certain documents or recordings. For example, if a witness were to view a videotape of the incident or have information relayed...by someone who viewed the videotape, it is possible that the witness' memory what occurred will be altered to conform to what they believe they are seeing or what they have been told," Legal Liaison Pam Woody wrote.
As reported in the September 11 story about Farias, two of the guards' written accounts describing Farias' death match word-for-word. Two additional accounts shared duplicate sentences.
Joe Arapaio is a National Hero. I only wish Sheriff Joe would have run for President. Now there's a man who can kick butt and take names. Too bad the prisoner died but he should have behaved himself. I'd say he "fought the law and the law won" which is the way we want all those encounters to go.
Hats off to Sheriff Joe for protecting Maricopa County residents and setting an example for Law Enforcement nation wide.
There will never be any justice within or around MCSO as long as Bozo Joke Arpaio is in charge and his Monkey followers like BigBadDO to do his dirty work and continue to cover up and lie for everything that happens within MCSO.
It's time Bozo Joe gets booted from office and those that have done is dirty work go to jail.
No More Arpaio in 2008.
"Big Bad D.O." is right when he says that the video is merely being withheld as a result of policy. The same policy that unlawfully refuses to release public records; the same policy that unlawfully refuses to comply with discovery requests in legal cases; the same policy that unlawfully refuses to comply with court orders; the same policy that unlawfully tampers with evidence and obstructs justice.
Yeah, that policy.
It's so easy to show up here and bad-mouth a dead man and claim that you wish the video had been released, but in fact it wasn't and the MCSO is doing everything they possibly can, as usual whenever they are responsible for gross physical abuse of prisoners, to temporize, obfuscate, deny, and escape culpability, instead of complying with the law, admitting culpability, and instituting the kind of changes necessary to insure that it doesn't happen again, while bringing those responsible to justice.
towife of mcso officer:
i have not walked in their shoes, but i know plenty of cops who a: know what the word restraint is, and the difference between compliance and revengeb: AND THIS IS THE IMPORTANT ONE, HAVENT KILLED ANYONE IN THEIR CUSTODY, EVEN IF THEY RAN AND/OR ATTACKED THEM..im sick of hearing excuses and reasons that make their actions somehow ok..its time for accountability, and if the cops under him cant make that distinction, then they are just as culpable in the deaths for not standing up for A: THE LAWB: WHATS RIGHT
but more importantly, ask yourself how would you feel if that was someone you knew, or a loved one? again, time for the excuses and cover ups to end, and for cops to be held accountable for their misdeads..(oh, and the " their cops so they should get away with it" excuse is dead too. WE AS CITIZENS ARE ACCOUNTABLE, SO SHOULD COPS!!)
ps i thank your husband for his dedication to protecting the public (and me), but it means nothing if its the cops breaking the law and the rest just turn a blind eye!
That man is running a Soviet era Gulag. There is no difference. In the name of trying to stop drugs, and immigration, he has become as barbaric as the soviets. Those who hurt others in jail face no penalties, they are rewarded for protecting their friends and the jail, they cover up their crimes, and apparently in a brazen way.
Damn, you caught me. Nothing gets by you... We picked that guy out of the 10,000 in custody and said "Yeah, thats the one, lets kill him.." Oh boy I hope that doesnt get out.. ...oops.. too late.
Please do not lump every officer into this. I know plenty of MSCO officers who take their jobs very seriously. I would say, you can't criticize until you have walked a mile in their shoes. They deal with rapist, murderers, drug addicts and the like and their lives are in danger every single shift. Think of what you would do if you would in their situations.
if any people want to know more about mr sheriff joes jail on the inside please contact me. i was resently arested for a minor trafic violation and was not treated like a human y i was there in acordance with loosing my job over a trafic ticket wen they were realesing people that were actualy in jail for felony crimes like robery ecsetera..
I invite anyone to come take a tour of LBJ, or any of our jails for that matter. What you see on the news, or read in new times for that matter (which has a known bias against MCSO), is utter bullshit. I PROMISE that the full facts of this case have not been released. As far as not releasing video... its policy, not hiding. I honestly WISH the video of this man's actions towards officers and staff WERE released. He was not only going through alcohol withdraws, he was also on about every known street drug under the sun. Alcohol withdraws are a bitch, and they kill... a lot, if they are bad enough. This mans actions warranted the exact level of force that he received. He was not 'beaten', I assure you. He was however, restrained.... aggressively. The bruises you see are from altercations from other inmates who threattened to kill him. The two officers that used the exact same report, were probably doing so out of fear.. at any rate, its obvious that which ever officer wrote it, cant write reports for shit. I hope they are punished for their actions (the report copying). Im sure the insurance company will pay out..again... and it wont go to trail (again..), which is a shame. Seriously folks, come on down and have a look. I REALLY wish people didnt believe everything they heard, but then again.. I dont know why I'd expect more from sheep. I hope to GOD someone leaks the video footage on this one... LBJ has ~800 cameras... its ALL there.
Ahhh yes, more sanctioned killing in Maricopa County Jails by Arpaio and his Monkey's.
Another civil suit that's going to cost us, the tax payers millions of dollars.
Where does it end ?
Patricia, if the "people" who work in "law enforcement" were given psychological evaluations, I guarantee that there would be no one left to work in "law enforcement".
The Jail Guards Did their Jobs well, and if You come to our Jail we can show you the same Hospitality as the Last poor Sucker. That guy Needed to DIE. He was a Danger to himself and others. WE ARE THE LAW, You Have No Rights, Except Those WE GIVE YOU, so Get Used to it, and Do as Your Told, and Maybe You will Live to See Tomorrow.
I am constantly sickened to my stomache over the reported treatment of inmates in the MCSO. Why does it seem that the people that work for MCSO get away with so much abuse? Those people the are abusive ought to have the same thing done to them as they do to inmates. The jail system seems to be brutal! Also, do they do psycological reports on the stability of the people they hire? Seems like alot of people have skeletons in their closets.....
I only hope that the family and friends of this man deal with the deputies who killed him on a "personal" level. I can assure you if this were my friend or family member, the legal system would be the least of these punk wannabe cops concerns!
First-rate work by Mr. Dickerson. That includes not only all of the new information developed, but also probably the best summary of related cases I have ever seen published by New Times, as well as the seamless tie-in. Mr. Dickerson didn't take anything for granted and didn't permit the The Usual Suspects to get away with their habitual lies, misleading omissions, mischaracterizations, equivocation, and other obfuscatory nonsense.
I note that the written testimonies of the guards Kush and Trueman are identical even down to typographic errors.
For example, both wrote "After his legs (sic) chains..." -- nor could this indicate habitual deviant usage by MCSO personnel because in the previous sentence both used the correct term "leg chains".
So, it was a spelling error that snuck into a master draft and the genius who cut and paste the text into the "independent" testimonies either didn't catch it or couldn't be bothered to correct it.
Bruce:so do you work for MCSO, or are you just another racist POS? Because any right minded, sane person would never say that because someone violated their probation and drank they deserved to die. Your just saying that because hes mexican. just admit it....your a scumbag..
this man brought this on himself with his criminal behavior i believe that the police acted according standard procedure.all this fool had to do was obey orders and act like a civilized human and act like a man.he chose to act like an animal and got what he deserved now we have one less criminal on the lose.
sorry, i deleted part of it on accident...but the part when i said "gee i wonder" referred to "i wonder why thomas and arpaio tried to get all of the judges removed..now any sane person can see why"..
Mikey:that would be a good solution, but someone has to have it put in place, and no one seems to want to hold them accountable...maybe the judge in hart vs arpaio hopefully will though, because the judges seem to be the only ones recognizing the madness and not taking part....gee, i wonder Im just disgusted to be an American when i read that cops and jail staff are continously in the middle of inmate deaths and breaking the law, and nothing happens to them. Sounds more like Zimbabwe than Arizona..maybe we should start calling it AZ/Zimbabwe Confidential.??
Nice job Arpaio. Another death due to inadequate training of your jail guards and the response. How many millions will this one cost? If I can help the family financially in anyway with legal expenses to go after your ass, I will. I wonder if your guards fondled him before he died?
Arpaio You Suck!
The solution is simple: Don't keep the recording equipment in the jails. Don't let MCSO have any access at all to the cameras, computers, or disks. Have this housed somewhere that would have whatever jurisdiction and security classification to handle the devices. If you have the people who may be guilty able to access the evidence showing if they are guilty, you're gonna have this kind of BS happen all the time.
SO let me get this straight, 8 guards have been proven to have beaten inmates and nothing has happened. HELLO, EARTH TO FBI..TIME TO DO YOUR F'N JOBS ALREADY, OR ARE YOU WAITING UNTIL MCSO STARTS LYNCHING INMATES PUBLICLY IN FRONT OF THE JAIL? i mean come one already, how far does it have to go until someone stops whats amounting to county sponsored murder? The internal joke dept over at MCSO has never found anyone responsible/guilty for their actions, not even one thats caught speeding more than 45mph over the speed limit on a surface street. Its time someone stepped up and proved that cops arent above the law, without reprocussion for their actions. Without cops you have anarchy, but with cops and detention officers continuing to break the law without reprocussion you have INSANITY! I find it totally amusing also that Thomas recently accused opponent Nelson of taking donations by defense attorneys so they can get better deals. Hey Andy, try PROSECUTING ONE OF THE MANY MURDERS BY DO'S BEFORE YOU START THAT BS.
Morning Poll: Did ICE Help Kill Phoenix Officer Daryl Raetz, as Senator John McCain Asserts?
Jodi Arias Jury Done -- No Decision on Death Penalty; Mistrial of Penalty Phase Declared; State Wants to Retry
Greg Patterson, AZ Board of Regents Member, Restarts Controversial "Espresso Pundit" Blog; Says He Won't Cover University Issues
Find everything you're looking for in your city
Find the best happy hour deals in your city
Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%
Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city
