Top

arts

Stories

 

Be a Girly Girl

The modern woman can be a real moron.

Jamie Peachey

Details

• To learn how to be an über-traditional lady, check out the deliciously outdated book The Total Woman by Marabel Morgan.
• For relevant and timely advice on developing a successful and happy relationship, read the brilliant book His Needs, Her Needs: Building An Affair-Proof Marriage by Willard F. Harley Jr.
• And for advice from a successful couple who is obnoxiously, constantly in love, read The Man of Her Dreams, The Woman of His! by Joel and Kathy Davisson.

Related Content

More About

Like this Story?

Sign up for the Arts and Theater Newsletter: Weekly information keeping you in the know when it comes to the Phoenix art and theater scene. Find out about upcoming performances, exhibitions, openings and special events.

Privacy Policy

And when it comes to relationships, I've definitely been one.

I've spent the past 12 years getting myself into (and out of) serious relationships. And by "serious," I mean I dated men I cared deeply about and I made a real effort to have a healthy, happy relationship.

But until recently, I was never able to get there.

Four years ago, I abruptly left my live-in boyfriend turned fiancé. Feeling like a failure, my goal was to stay out of a relationship for at least one year to take time to reflect on my methods. I was ready to admit that I was doing something wrong.

Before I knew it, two years had passed and I was a desperately lonely 27-year-old with zero romantic prospects. As miserable as I was, it was this agonizing time period that set me straight. Facing my career, student loans, credit card debt, and my marriage-less, baby-less future alone, I realized for the first time how valuable a romantic relationship could be.

And I realized what a true moron I had been.

Here was my problem: I was a misguided feminist. I thought I could do everything just as well as a man could. Actually, I thought I could do everything better.

In the past, I raced to the door first so Boyfriend couldn't open it for me. If we were moving, I snatched the heaviest boxes before he could get to them. I dragged huge bags of garbage across the lawn and scoffed at his offers to help. When it came to car problems, I would take the busted thing into the mechanic without asking for Boyfriend's opinion first. And I was the queen (or should I say king?) of going Dutch.

In the beginning of each of my relationships, poor Boyfriend would try to help with the gender-specific tasks. I'd always refuse with a nasty tone — outraged by the implication that I couldn't manage these simple responsibilities. Looking back, I realize I was on a rampage. I'm ashamed to admit that even when I'd actually let Boyfriend complete a chore, I'd criticize his performance.

At the time, I thought I was merely displaying my independence and versatility. And I foolishly believed that Boyfriend would admire me for being so strong.

Because that's what a modern woman should be, right?

Unfortunately, my independent behavior was sending a damaging message to Boyfriend, over and over again. And the message was this: "You're freakin' useless."

So, after many refusals of assistance, his offers would stop completely. And then, predictably, I'd wail and cry about how Boyfriend wasn't emotionally aware enough to meet my needs.

Like I said, I was a moron. And worse, I was a miserable moron.

Even the experts say this behavior is very bad. (See sidebar.)

Shortly after I realized the error of my ways, I met an amazing man. This time, I decided to let him stay that way. And, after a year and a half, he's still an amazing man (emphasis on the man part).

I let him open doors for me and carry all the heavy stuff. I let him drive my car. I ask him to make small repairs around the apartment we share. I let him open doors, pay for dinner, move the furniture, and handle anything that has to do with a computer. I even left my car in the driveway for a day so that, when he got off work, he could change the dead battery himself.

I never thought I'd be this woman. I've succumbed to traditional gender roles.

I used to think this kind of behavior would make me weak. Actually, taking a step back and (gasp!) trusting my partner was one of the bravest things I ever did.

And one of the smartest.

My man has never, not once, disappointed me. Now that I've stopped being such a misguided feminist freak, I can see that he moves the furniture better than I can. He hammers nails faster and more efficiently. He easily hauls the trash and doesn't get angry if garbage juice drips on him. And, from start to finish, he had that car battery taken care of in 45 minutes flat.

It's wonderful. And, for the first time in my life, I'm actually happy in my relationship.

So to all modern women, I say this: Be like me and resolve to stop trying to be so much like a man. You'll find he's much better at it.

 
  • Joel and Kathy Davisson 12/25/2010 5:55:00 AM

    Joel and Kathy Davisson are at www.GodSaveMyMarriage.com

  • Joel and Kathy Davisson 12/25/2010 5:54:00 AM

    Very nice article. Sheesh.. the comments below are like so serious. This is a light-hearted article by a young lady who decided to allow her boyfriend open the car door for her. Lighten up, folks! Life is FUN. Relax. ENJOY! He came to give us LIFE and LIFE more abundantly - JOY! Joel and Kathy Davisson.

  • Confused 01/24/2010 11:05:00 PM

    Congrats on what you see as your personal growth. I guess I just don't understand why this is an article in this publication? What is the relevance to your readers? Without trying to be hurtful, this reads like a private journal entry that fails to acknowledge or intelligently explore the deeper topics of gender in our society. It sounds like a person who (good for her) has found happiness and wants to share that....but who hasn't placed those thoughts in an appropriate forum. This article naively assumes that PNT readers are interested in the author's personal life, which we are not. If minimal personal examples were used within a well-researched context of relevant subject matter, then maybe this would work. I ask these questions especially given the irony of the author's imperative to us to "be like her," someone who "lets" her man be amazing, as if he needs you to "let" him be anything. Am I the only one who noticed this?

  • Ruth A Lindsay 01/23/2010 9:58:00 PM

    Yes, you were certainly a misguided feminist. As someone who has enough audacity to proclaim herself a well-guided, intelligent feminist, I also think you in fact ARE STILL a moron. Talk about missing the point of feminist liberation, which is not to take you out of one box to put you in another, or to create isolated monads incapable of loving and sharing, but to challenge you to see beyond prescriptive norms and live out a life of respect and growth with other women and men. As you have discovered, there is nothing wrong with identifying with "traditional" gender roles (although that's not a very helpful term when you realize how fluid these roles are through time), but extrapolating from your experience that women who make other choices, who appear to enjoy "masculine" activities are fooling themselves, is astoundingly small-minded. However you find fulfillment and however you are able to cultivate love and respect between yourself and others is fantastic. The point of feminisms (yes - I insist on the plural) is to demand equal respect and dignity for women, their life-choices, and the work that they do. Our choices may or may not include things like motherhood, cooking, and care-taking. They may include repairing cars, re-furbishing houses, or working as an executive. For most of us, they entail a mixture of these kinds of activities. I myself fall more in line with "feminine" interests (though I can change a tire quickly and parallel park better than my boyfriend). If you find you fit "perfectly" into the gender binary and you're happy with that, then go for it, but don't expect other women to do the same. And really, you should pay for dinner every once and a while. Ruth Lindsay Tempe, AZ

  • Nija Phelps 01/23/2010 8:16:00 PM

    Dear Editor(s)-- Wow, I had to calm myself down after reading that article. This woman makes me so angry! She sounds like she was a shrew of a girlfriend! She's right, she was behaving like a moron! Not for being a feminist, because she was not being a feminist at all, she was being a misandrist! Feminism isn't about "doing manly things". All the things that she was doing were fine as individual actions, it's her reason behind doing those things that were totally wrong.� She wanted to do them just to prove a point, to who?� She didn't actually care about nor take pride in doing any of those things, she regretted doing those things. then she'd complain that her boyfriends weren't there for her (because she pushed them away from doing anything for her) and be doubly miserable. She needs to make that distinction between her actions and her motivations. By not doing so, she is totally slanting this article and using her bad experience (resulted from her own mistakes) to step back into the 50's and unfortunately could pull some other women back there with her.� She clearly is the kind of person that wants to be taken care of, but that's not the same thing as being feminine. It surprises me that she's lived with people before yet still considers it to be one or the other that pays for dinner... my fianc�nd I each have our own bank account, but we also have a joint one, and that is the one that most of our major purchases come out of, including dinner... I take care of car stuff better than my fianc�oes, but he handles cooking more often (and better) than I do.� He's stronger and carries heavy things more easily, but I am better at being in charge when it comes to packing/unpacking/ and organizing a move. It doesn't make either of us less or more feminine nor less or more masculine.� I agree that if a task has become too much of a challenge for you, or if learning a new skill isn't something you really want to do, then you shouldn't do it because it doesn't work for you, not because it's against your gender role to attempt to master something new. --From a woman that is very fem, yet knows what she needs and what she needs to do, to make her relationships be the best for her and her partner, and will work at that, Nija Phelps

 
for free stuff, theater info & more!

Find A Coupon

Popular Coupons

  • Thumbnail

    FREE Shisha

    The Headquarters
    219 W. University
    Tempe, AZ 85281
  • Thumbnail

    30% Off!

    Beads Galore
    3320 South Priest Drive, #3
    Tempe, AZ 85282
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy