Staying after their visas expire automatically also makes them illegal — so I'd like to see a commercial of John McCain going after them at airports and work sites.

I hope 1070 weeds out all of these immigrants so we can all have a more secure home.
J. Figueroa, Phoenix

Fearing the "reconquista": "Reconquista" has been under way for quite some time. Now, it is taking place in the form of murdering innocents.

Oh, and also in the form of "cultural studies" in the Tucson Unified School District. Hey, America, wake the fuck up!
Benson Willcox, near the border

Liberals won't let solution emerge: I think the problem on our southern border is much like the oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico. If you don't stop the leak, you will never be able to clean up the mess.

The border could be secured in a very short time if we get tough enough on enforcement. I do not believe the bleeding-heart liberals will ever let this happen, though. Our best chance would be to let British Petroleum take over.
David Burke, city unavailable

"Dang wall" is not the answer: I think this article resonated with a lot of people. The stands were empty, and I took the last newspaper!

I tend to be conservative, and your paper leans left. However, your piece was well thought-out and seemed to carry a little of both sides.

The "dang wall" is not the answer. I used to think it was. The answer? We need to do something to reduce the reason for them to come here! There are lots of ways to accomplish this, but as long as there is work here and an economic reason to be here, they will come.

We can work on the economy down there, some. We can restrict who hires "illegal" aliens. Period. I am an immigrant myself. This is not a racial issue.

I noticed you didn't hit much on the terrorists coming across. There is the real problem.
L.E. Shantz, city unavailable

Eliminate the incentive: Nice article. This is an important topic that requires a lot more coverage in the press — especially about those on the front lines (the actual residents of these areas).

My two cents: The only way to stop illegals from crossing our borders is to eliminate the amnesty they receive if successful; eliminate the incentive. If people from other countries know that they can come to the United States, receive free medical care, housing, and education — in addition to all the other programs and support available — they will continue to do whatever it takes to get here.

This is not rocket science, and that point should be at the forefront of every conversation regarding our borders and their security.

Let church organizations, businesses, and the private citizens assist those in need, if they so choose, both here and abroad. It's not the federal government's responsibility.
Scott Helmer, city unavailable

Take a look at the real problem: My heart goes out to the Krentz family. I think we can all take a lesson from this death and not hold every Mexican responsible — just the twisted bastard who did this dirty deed.

As much as we don't want to think that any part of this is the fault of the American people, we are at least 50 percent responsible. The sole reason that so many people cross the border illegally is that there is work for them here. Until big business, which is the engine drawing these people, is made to stop employing them, the incentive will exist.

Unfortunately, no matter what laws we enact or what fences we build or how heavily we patrol, desperate people will be drawn to the incentives they see.
Name withheld

Please do not hurt or steal: A lot of people don't fully understand the outrage of Arizonans. These people feel we have something against the Mexican people — these people are simple-minded and arrogant.

Of course there are those who will [use immigration arguments] to hide their racism. But everybody needs to understand that the immigration problem isn't the fault of the Mexican people; it's the fault of people who purposely come here to commit crimes.

I have no problem with people coming here to better their lives. I would, too, if faced with the problems they have. But do it with kindness in your heart. Do not hurt or steal from people.
Name withheld

« Previous Page
My Voice Nation Help

"Let's try to figure out a way to welcome immigrants into our country — that is, people who are willing to work and support their families — and make them legal residents and a part of our productive economy."

Ms Gatz,

You are full of sh*t. I have been married to a Canadian for nearly 2 years now. It took us 15 months and 1000's of dollars to get her "green card". Now with her "provisional" 2-year green card about to expire, we have to come up with another $600 filing fee for her "regular" 10-year card. And she she came in through the front door.

So don't advocating for making invaders legal. Do you actually think they have the financial resources to pay the huge fees? I seriously doubt it. So will they get free or reduced cost green cards? That is just not right.


When was the last time that the MCSO had a raid at the Polish Catholic Church in Phoenix or for that matter at any of the other religious institutions that identify themselves with a foreign nationality first and then faith second.

Shurf wouldn't have to go into the churches, he would just have to set up a command post outside.

But you won't see this happen. You will only see his sweeps involving sweeping up brown skinned people and then sifting them out to see who's here past their visa expiration.

For all of you who are defending this stupid bill, and telling us to read the fine print in it that there is to be no racial profiling.

Well, actions speak louder than words.

And until an "action" is taken that does not involve hispanics but targets another place where illegals could be trying to blend in then yes, the bill is all about racial profiling.

Just because it is written into the law, that doesn't mean that MCSO is going to follow it. As evidenced by their ACTIONS before and since.

All of you want to blah blah blah but I've heard your blah blah blahs before. When you were all screaming for bin Laden's head and your government lied to you and didn't and has thrown an already unstable middle east into chaos. bin Laden was never a serious target at all.

Why didn't you scream for the prez to go after the country that supplied most of the terrorists on 9/11? Saudi Arabia. You know, our "ally" that murders women if their heads aren't covered. You were all easily duped into what Bushco wanted you to believe. But, please, do not think that everyone can be duped as easily as you. By placing that 'no racial profiling' into the SB, feel free to be duped again. But I ain't drinking the koolaid.


The United States shoul lock up all borders from north Canada to South Mexico. Yes we had terrorist coming in from Canada and Mexico. There are a lot of Asians coming into the US from Canada and alot of them are illigal and they too pay coyote big$$$$$ but you never hear about that. There are a lot of Russians in Hollywoo ca living off the Gov. but no one knows about that I do because I worked a transported their children to schools. A lot of Iranian RUDE MEN who treated me a woman with no respect because they thought they were better than me but they were on welfare and their children were on the system. But that was OK. It just makes no sense how you can condemn one race and turn a blind eye to others. If you turned in the Asians your spouses would choke you because they couldn't wear sandel with crusty feet. Think about it


Oh people you will talk till you are blue in the face and guess what the will of God is what is going to happen here, not the Neo Nazies nor the hard core repulicans (1st in that line that lady Govenor)nor anyone who is hiding under this is my country and we do not want those people here will come out the victor here. The power and faith of real Christians is working here and that law will never come to be , it is in the hands of the most powerful of all , he is the King of Kings and he rules all nations and he is greater then anyone on this earth and even beyond. He will come to our rescue and the oppressed shall be set free and the rich and hateful will not win this one niether.


I have heard all the talk, balk, and crying going on over this new law going into effect. People, please try to look outside the box on this issue. Arizona did not create a law that is being enforced to get rid of the Hispanic population as many have said. There are many nationalities crossing the border from Mexico, and this law enforces ALL ILLEGAL immigration to Arizona. It is not a law that allows profiling as people have said. If ANYONE is stopped by the police and cannot identify themselves with a legal government issued ID, Work Visa, or some form of Federally issued immigration paperwork, they will be prosecuted for being here illegally. End of story. This law that 70% of the Arizona population voted already a Federal Law, just not an enforced law. Think about this, Arizona had 70% of it's population vote yes on this law. 70%! The majority of Arizona's population is not White Americans. All of the people that voted for this law, have one thing in common and that is to enforce a Federal Law that already exists. People cannot come to this country to live, or work without proper citizanship, work visa's, or identification. Our border passages are unsecure, and that's the bottom line. Our borders are being used for drug trafficking, murder, violent attacks, trash dumps, and the list goes on. The only reason other states have not implemented the enforcement of this Federal law that has existed for many years is that they don't have the problem with immigration like we do. Another thing to think about, very few immigrants coming across the AZ/Mexico border move to the Northern, Eastern, Southern, or the plains states. This law is not enacted to be cruel to anyone. It is meant to help Arizona's legal residents, and economy continue to survive in the labor, life, and economic manner in which we are entitled to as legal citizens of the United States. If people want to be here, then do it the legal and right way.


It is astounding how ignorant some people are of the issues that have been going on in our society.

People keep complaining about illegal immigrants getting handouts from the government, when the truth is, most government programs do not extend help to illegal immigrants. There are few programs which illegals are eligible for.

Also, they complain about illegals not paying taxes. I am a young Mexican-American man. I am a citizen, but much of my family is not. Some of my direct family members came to this country illegaly. However, for the majority of the time they have been here, they have all payed taxes just like everybody else. The only times that anyone in my family that is residing in this country has not payed taxes was when they were unemployed.

And the statement that gets under my skin the most is that illegal immigrants are a plague to the United States. It angers me when they say that 'Mexicans' contribute nothing to this society and that all they do is lower the quality of life for the citizens of the country. As I said before, much of my immediate family came to the United States illegaly. I cannot say that they were right in doing so. But I can say this; I am a soldier in the United States Army. I am currently deployed to Iraq fighting for the freedom of the 99% of the United States population that has never served in the Armed Forces.

What have YOU done to better the quality of life for anyone other than YOURSELF? What have you done to protect the freedoms and rights that were established by this country's founding fathers?

I am a citizen, but only for the simple fact that my mother was already in the United States when I was conceived. Three people in my platoon alone came to the U.S. illegaly, and have since become naturalized citizens. There are more who's parents were also illegal, but happened to have been born in the United States. Considering the fact that some 'wetbacks' are more willing to fight for the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA than the majority of people who 'belong there', why is it that we are treated as though we do not deserve to be in this great nation?

R Boone
R Boone

It's time for the United States of America to take care of itself instead of everyone else. Lock up our borders and pull back our troops, let the rest of the world work out their problems for awhile on their own.They will come begging for US again

Phoenix Concert Tickets