Sidebar: Mexican Macroeconomics

In 2007, the U.S. Senate debated the doomed McCain-Kennedy "comprehensive immigration reform" bill that aimed to secure borders, enforce workplaces, modernize the visa system, and allow non-criminal undocumented immigrants already in the country to pay a fine and stand in line for legal residency. (Under the proposed law, an immigrant would be denied public benefits until five years after his green card was issued.)

At the time of the debate, the Heritage Foundation issued a policy paper with an alarming headline: "Amnesty Will Cost U.S. Taxpayers at Least $2.6 Trillion."

The Heritage Foundation, a think tank that shares funders and a hard-line immigration stance with FAIR and its sister organizations, reported that migrants already living illegally in the United States, if given amnesty, would cost the country trillions in Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security costs as they aged.

Details

See the Featured story:

A year after the Heritage report was released, then-Maricopa County Attorney Andrew Thomas paid Harvard economist George Borjas a reported $625 an hour for a study that suggested illegal immigrants drove down wages and cost Arizona $1.4 billion in lost wages in 2005.

John Tanton's groups, which include FAIR, also reported that undocumented immigrants take jobs from low-skilled American workers. Taken together, the reports sent a clear message: Illegal aliens drive down wages and burden taxpayers.

If illegal immigrants returned to Mexico, the argument goes, American workers would step right into their jobs, pay taxes, and shore up the economy.

It is an argument that resonates with American voters.

Even though it's not necessarily true.

In 2007, Edward Lazear, chairman of the George W. Bush White House Council of Economic Advisors, conducted an extensive review of reports on the effects of all immigration, legal and illegal, on the economy. Lazear concluded: "Our review of economic research finds immigrants not only help fuel the nation's economic growth, but also have an overall positive effect on the income of native-born workers."

It's harder to tell just how illegal immigration affects the economy, though.

At the very worst, the effect of undocumented immigrants on the American economy is negligible, economist Gordon Hanson, of the University of California-San Diego, reported in 2009. Using data from the National Bureau of Economic Research, Hanson, commissioned by the pro-immigrant Migration Policy Institute, wrote: "If we account for the small fiscal burden that unauthorized immigrants impose, the overall economic benefit is close enough to zero to be essentially a wash."

A wash.

Not $113 billion a year, as the FAIR report contends. And certainly not trillions of dollars, as the Heritage report contends.

Hanson concluded that those hurt by illegal immigration are low-skilled workers who compete directly with the undocumented workers. He reported that individual economic losses were offset by advantages to businesses that employ the low-wage immigrants.

But here's the clincher: Many of the workers displaced by undocumented immigrants are also immigrants.

The difference is that the displaced workers arrived earlier. In February, the progressive Economic Policy Institute, in a report called "Immigration and Wages," wrote that newly arrived low-skilled immigrants with less than high school degrees displaced other immigrants of the same skill level — and fewer American-born workers.

Immigrants take a bigger financial hit than native-born workers when the economy tanks, and they are among the first to get jobs when the economy recovers, an October report by the Pew Hispanic Center says.

In many cases, Americans either don't want low-skilled jobs, can't physically perform them, or don't know they're available.

About half of farm workers are unauthorized immigrants, the U.S. Department of Labor estimated more than a decade ago.

This probably hasn't changed much. In September, the Associated Press reported that native-born workers weren't seeking advertised farm labor jobs: "Since January, California farmers have posted ads for 1,160 farm-worker positions open to U.S. citizens and legal residents. Only 233 people applied after being linked with the jobs through unemployment offices in California, Texas, Nevada, and Arizona."

Many economists say that by filling low-skilled jobs, immigrants improve business profits, which in turn create more jobs for higher-skilled American workers. University of California economist Giovanni Peri, for example, wrote in a recent Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco Economic Letter that immigrants expand the economy, which in turn expands job opportunities for non-immigrants.

And he's not alone.

The Brookings Institution reports that "economists have found that immigrants raise average wages for the United States as a whole."

Also, many economists say economic growth in the United States is impossible without population expansion, and since the native-born American population is older and declining in numbers, immigrants expand the population, which in turn stimulates economic growth.

This puts the United States at a "competitive advantage" compared with other developed countries that don't have enough workers to expand the economy, says Marc Rosenblum, of the Migration Policy Institute.

 
My Voice Nation Help
9 comments
linaimai
linaimai

Dear customers, thank you for your support of our company.Here, there's good news to tell you: The company recentlylaunched a number of new fashion items! ! Fashionableand welcome everyone to come buy. If necessary,welcome to :===== www. soozone.com ========T-shirts (Polo ,ed hardy,lacoste) $14New era cap $10

Air jordan(1-24)shoes $30

Handbags(Coach,ed hardy,lv,d&g) $35

Jean(True Religion,ed hardy,coogi) $35

Sunglasses(Oakey,coach,gucci,Armaini)$14

Jim
Jim

105 comments as of this morning and now only 3? Who is censoring the comments? No free speech, NO RAG NEWSPAPER!!!!

linaimai
linaimai

Wholesale all kinds of world brand shoes,jeans,t-shirts,bikini,beach

pants,handbags,wallets,sunglasses,belt,caps,watches etc..▍ ★∴    ....▍▍....█▍ ☆ ★∵ …./    ◥█▅▅██▅▅██▅▅▅▅▅███◤    .◥███████████████◤  ~~~~◥█████████████◤~~~~

??? http://soozone.com ???

AnIowan
AnIowan

FAIR's reports mentioned in the article above are coming from several subtle anti-immigration groups founded by the same person (John Tanton). They do not seem to hold water in comparrison to hundreds of studies done in our states nationwide. When FAIR came to my state with "facts and figures" they did not at all match up with several studies done locally. According to my state's studies of documented and undocumented immigrants, our immigrant workers and their families are a boon to our flagging economy and our dying main streets. John Tanton's intentions would really hurt my state.

linaimai
linaimai

??? http://soozone.com ???Wholesale all kinds of world brand shoes,jeans,t-shirts,bikini,beach

pants,handbags,wallets,sunglasses,belt,caps,watches etc..

` ╰—┘ 。 ┅★`_、│\__╭╭╭╭╭__/│   │ │            │           │ │  ●       ● │ │≡    o    ≡││           │ ╰——┬O◤▽◥O┬——╯   |  o  |   |╭---╮| ┌┬┬┬┐ ╞╧╧╧╧══╧╧╧╧╧╧╧╧╡

thman
thman

Whoops....so according to most studies the new immigration laws SP1070in Arizona will likely have zero affect on unemployment or business. Darn...somany wanted to believe that immigrants were part of the problem. I guess we foundthe enemy, and it is us staring in the mirror.

Benevolentdictator
Benevolentdictator

Controlled Immigration Policy

Assuming the economic equation is correct that the unauthorized immigrants have no net affect on our economics we may want to consider the social/cultural impact. The Bosnian war was the cultural confluence of 2 incompatible groups; each culture had a value system that prioritized differently. This is disruptive to a harmonious society because the values are not the same; so different that one culture sees the other as a threat to their values and anxiety sets in. Xenophobia is a concern and a justified fear if the host's values their culture, especially to the host culture that is being over run by the immigrant culture if the change occurs too quickly; more than 20% in a generation. By having a controlled immigration policy the host culture has the time to have the immigrants assimilated into the host's value system; the more similar the values of a society the more harmonious the people as a whole.Axiom; your household is our country and your way of running that household is our culture and you have autonomy as to who comes into your house as our country decides who comes into our country. Suppose the people you bought the house from decide to visit your house and enter without your consent. Then they say they want to make some changes as to how your household is run. This would be a violation of your sovereignty and chaos would ensue; harmony would be lost.In the US we have the US Constitution that enforces natural law; property rights, liberty and life; free will can be performed as long as it does not encroach upon the rights of other citizens. We have a free-market economy or at least believe we do/should. These are some of the values we want to protect and maintain in our culture. If immigrants come into our country we want them to value and maintain these cultural elements; we want to homogenize their thinking to ours to promote harmony/peace and security otherwise we have people in our house who may unwittingly invoke the values of a culture they are fleeing from. If we do not have a controlled immigration policy then what do we do when 40% of the population becomes Islamic as it did in Serbia/Bosnia and is occurring in France, England, Netherlands, Germany, Sweden and Norway within one generation? There is much disharmony in these countries as the Islamic culture comes into conflict with the host culture. There will be anxiety and violence because the change is occurring too quickly and more time is needed for peer-pressure assimilation into the host's culture.

I bet the Native American Indian community wished they had a controlled immigration policy 400 years ago.

linaimai
linaimai

Dear customers, thank you for your support of our company.Here, there's good news to tell you: The company recentlylaunched a number of new fashion items! ! Fashionableand welcome everyone to come buy. If necessary,welcome to :===== www. soozone.com ========T-shirts (Polo ,ed hardy,lacoste) $14New era cap $10

Air jordan(1-24)shoes $30

Handbags(Coach,ed hardy,lv,d&g) $35

Jean(True Religion,ed hardy,coogi) $35

Sunglasses(Oakey,coach,gucci,Armaini)$14

Bikini (Ed hardy,polo) $18

linaimai
linaimai

Dear customers, thank you for your support of our company.Here, there's good news to tell you: The company recentlylaunched a number of new fashion items! ! Fashionableand welcome everyone to come buy. If necessary,welcome to :===== www. soozone.com ========

 
Phoenix Concert Tickets
Loading...