Late 2005 to October 2007 was not a good time to be raped or molested in El Mirage.

During that time, the town had signed a contract to pay the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office $3.6 million for police services. But Sheriff Joe Arpaio didn't use the money to bolster his sex-crimes unit. Instead, the publicity-hungry sheriff's focus, as always, was on political witch hunts and pet projects that got his name in lights.

Victims of sex crimes — mostly children — in the town and throughout the county still are paying for Arpaio's misguided policies. Rapists and child molesters got away with their crimes.

At a December news conference, Joe Arpaio listens to questions about botched sex-crimes investigations under his watch.
At a December news conference, Joe Arpaio listens to questions about botched sex-crimes investigations under his watch.
Levalya Beyart of El Mirage says that after her daughter reported being raped in 2007, the Sheriff's Office told her, "This [is] not a priority."
Jamie Peachey
Levalya Beyart of El Mirage says that after her daughter reported being raped in 2007, the Sheriff's Office told her, "This [is] not a priority."
Mary Ward, a former member of Arpaio's Special Victims Unit, is getting scapegoated for problems arising from the sheriff's failure to put sufficient resources toward sex-crimes investigations.
Mary Ward, a former member of Arpaio's Special Victims Unit, is getting scapegoated for problems arising from the sheriff's failure to put sufficient resources toward sex-crimes investigations.
James Weege, a former member of Arpaio's Special Victims Unit, is getting scapegoated for problems arising from the sheriff's failure to put sufficient resources toward sex-crimes investigations.
James Weege, a former member of Arpaio's Special Victims Unit, is getting scapegoated for problems arising from the sheriff's failure to put sufficient resources toward sex-crimes investigations.

On August 23, 2006, for example, Francisca Vasquez called El Mirage police to report that her 26-year-old cousin had impregnated her 13-year-old daughter. The police agency had retained some of its own police officers even as the Sheriff's Office provided detectives, deputies, and an administrative staff for the town — and one of these municipal officers rolled out to the family's home at 13810 North Alto Street.

Vasquez and a male friend stood in the front yard, hugging a crying girl. The girl, who was 12 when she'd had sex with the older man, said she hadn't mentioned the encounter earlier because she was afraid of her mom's cousin.

The suspect recently had moved to Tennessee to work, and the family was confident they'd be able to help track him down.

The El Mirage officer recorded interviews with the family and impounded them into evidence. The routine at that time, because of the MCSO contract, was to turn over such a case to Arpaio's Special Victims Unit, also called the sex-crimes unit.

You'd think such a case would be easily solved with a paternity test.

But the case wasn't worked by Arpaio's officers and was returned to El Mirage after the town ended its contract with the MCSO in October 2007.

El Mirage Detective Hector Encinas, one of the officers assigned to review dozens of similar cases, went to the address in April 2008 but found that the family had moved. Neighbors didn't know where they were. The case was closed.

On March 1, 2007, an 11-year-old girl at El Mirage Elementary School told friends that her grandmother's live-in boyfriend had sexually assaulted her two years earlier, when she was 9.

Her horrified friends spilled the story to a tutor, who told the principal. A school counselor interviewed the girl before calling police.

The girl recalled awakening one night to find her grandmother's boyfriend standing next to her, dressed only in boxer shorts. He walked out of the room, then came back fully naked "and attempted to put his penis in her mouth," according to the police report.

An additional summary report compiled by El Mirage police in December 2008 states that on different occasions, "other sex crimes [against the girl by the same man] may have occurred."

The case was assigned to the MCSO sex-crimes unit, where it languished. It was put on permanent hold by El Mirage in 2008 after police couldn't find the family. Had the numerous leads been followed quickly, the assailant might well be behind bars now.

Such cases aren't always clear-cut. Victims sometimes don't tell the truth. But serious allegations of violent crimes must be investigated, for the safety of the community. And under Joe Arpaio's watch, that seldom was the case with sex crimes.

Levalya Beyart, a social worker and single mother who wanted her name used in this article, remembers the horror she felt when she opened the front door of her modest home in a gated community in El Mirage on July 11, 2007.

Her mentally challenged 13-year-old daughter, who had been home alone, was "walking around in a daze," she told New Times.

The girl was naked from the waist down, and her body was scratched and bruised.

The living room was "torn up," says Beyart. "You could tell there had been some kind of struggle."

At first, she thought her daughter might have suffered a "flashback" to sexual abuse by a family member more than a year earlier.

But after Beyart got the girl to calm down, her daughter told a story that "sounded believable" to the mother.

Beyart's daughter said a stranger had come to the door in the afternoon, begging to use the phone because his car had broken down. She let him in, and he attacked and raped her.

Beyart phoned police and reported the incident, records show. She says an El Mirage officer showed up at her home and drove the mother and daughter to a crisis center in Glendale, where a nurse conducted a forensic exam.

Some blood was found on the girl's genitals, but the nurse believed it was possibly because the teen was beginning her first period. Only the theory wasn't correct, because the girl didn't start menstruating until months later.

A few days passed, and Beyart became concerned that nobody was taking the case seriously.

She was right.

Records show that it quickly was assigned to detectives from the MCSO sex-crimes unit — who never even bothered to interview Beyart's daughter.

Beyart was given an MCSO detective's number to call. She doesn't remember his name. But she'll never forget what he told her.

The detective promised to follow up on the case but added, "This [is] not a priority," according to Beyart.

In fact, records show, there was no follow-up. Beyart remains angry and disillusioned over the treatment that she and her daughter received from Joe Arpaio's office.

"I don't know," she tells New Times. "I was really hurt. I'm not sure if it's because we are people of color. They majorly dropped the ball."

If her daughter told the truth — and Beyart believes she did — a rapist probably still is on the loose.

The lack of a criminal investigation was concerning, but Beyart's priority was her daughter. Beyart enrolled her in more therapy sessions. In the months that followed the rape, the daughter's mental state deteriorated. She "had her days and nights mixed up. She would stay in the shower for hours. She wasn't as social as she used to be. There was weight gain, depression."

Beyart cringes every time she hears another news story — and there have been many — about how Arpaio's office failed to properly investigate sex crimes.

"He allowed this to happen," Beyart says of the sheriff. "Nobody's disciplined. They're trying to cover their behinds."


Joe Arpaio, the elected head of a police agency with a $270 million budget in 2011, is responsible for the poor or nonexistent investigation of hundreds of sex crimes — and for the children and adults re-victimized by their abusers.

The sheriff admits he's to blame.

His new chief deputy, Jerry Sheridan, told the public as much during a heated Board of Supervisors meeting on January 31.

"The Sheriff's Office and the sheriff have accepted responsibility," Sheridan said of the sex-abuse cases that went by the wayside.

The admission of blame through an aide was meant to assuage an outraged public. Arpaio, who's been sheriff since 1992, has defiantly resisted calls from critics and Democratic politicians to resign over the scandal.

Negative media coverage of the failure to properly investigate the sex crimes is "really hurting us as a law enforcement agency," Sheridan told the county's five Supervisors.

The irony is, three of the Supervisors had been targeted in trumped-up and now-discredited criminal investigations by Arpaio's office.

Arpaio must wonder whether the debacle will hit him where it would hurt most: at the polls this November, when voters will decide whether he gets a sixth four-year term.

The story of the bad investigations first was revealed in an article published on July 12, 2008, by the East Valley Tribune. As part of a series that would go on to win a Pulitzer Prize, the story revealed that at least 200 sex-crime cases reported to the Sheriff's Office were getting reopened after problems with the way they were handled were discovered.

The Tribune series focused on how Arpaio's enthusiasm for busting illegal immigrants was one of the prime distractions.

In December 2007, Mike Frazier, then-El Mirage police chief, sent a letter to Arpaio outlining how the failures had affected his town. Frazier, a respected Phoenix Police Department veteran, became chief in October 2007, after the end of the two-year period in which the MCSO handled the town's law enforcement duties.

Frazier wrote that a review of 51 reports of crimes assigned to Arpaio's sex-crimes division in 2006 and 2007 showed that 43 "had not been worked at all or had minimal follow-up conducted."

Frazier's letter noted that more than 90 percent of these cases had "workable leads."

A summary of the rape and molestation cases shows that most involved children or teens.

The problem with sex-crimes cases wasn't limited to El Mirage. And the problem of poorly investigated cases in El Mirage was not limited to sex crimes.

Arpaio's priorities affected crimes reported in county islands and in the seven towns served under contract by the Sheriff's Office, including Fountain Hills, Guadalupe, Gila Bend, and Cave Creek.

Media reports have shown that bad investigations occurred for aggravated assaults, armed robberies, and other violent crimes. Frazier, now police chief in Surprise, tells New Times that at least two homicides in El Mirage also were investigated poorly.

The bad police work hardly can be dismissed as a fluke.

Instead of investigating crimes and going after tens of thousands of active warrants in the county, Arpaio's troops were ordered, research shows, to spend their time busting undocumented Hispanics, training police officers in Honduras, and working on investigations of individuals whom the sheriff considered his enemies.

The sex-crimes story went no further in the press until May 2011, when the results of a massive internal investigation into corruption by Arpaio's command staff were released, adding more details to the scandal. That investigation, performed by Arpaio's political ally, Pinal County Sheriff Paul Babeu, was sparked by a 63-page tell-all memo sent to Arpaio in mid-2010 by one of his commanders, Deputy Chief Frank Munnell.

(The Babeu report, generated after months of looking into the Munnell memo, was the focus of New Times' May 26 "Joe Knew" article, about Arpaio's role in the unethical and potentially illegal tactics used against those he perceived as enemies.)

At the time, news outlets published details from the report showing how Arpaio's office reopened 432 sex-crime cases, plus other criminal cases, across Maricopa County because of worries that they hadn't been investigated sufficiently.

Babeu's probe also confirmed that Arpaio's office had stopped its own investigation into the problems out of concern that it would damage the reputation of a sex-crimes unit supervisor, which in turn might have hurt a lawsuit over a high-profile alleged public-corruption case that the MCSO had mishandled.

Still, the public didn't become inflamed over the sex-crimes cases until the nationwide publication of a December 4, 2011, article on them by Jacques Billeaud of the Associated Press.

Since then, Arizona's two U.S. senators have expressed concern about the failure, and a chorus of critics have called for Arpaio to resign. The January 31 hearing before the Board of Supervisors was packed with Arpaio supporters and critics and was punctuated by a disruptive walk-out of the meeting by dozens of people disgusted with the apparent support of the sheriff by the board and County Attorney Bill Montgomery. Only the board's lone Democrat, Mary Rose Wilcox, challenged statements by Montgomery and Sheridan that downplayed the scandal.

Despite the sheriff's public acceptance of responsibility for the problem, his office decided that the best way to deflect criticism was to heap blame on lowly subordinates. Two former detectives, James Weege and Mary Ward (who left the MCSO in 2008 and now work for the Goodyear Police Department) and their former supervisor, Kim Seagraves, are among the principals named in the MCSO's internal investigation into who gets fingered.

Yet a review of how the investigative failures occurred makes it clear that Arpaio's politically motivated, headline-grabbing investigations — combined with his choice of now-ousted Chief Deputy David Hendershott as the enforcer of his will — led directly to the office's callous treatment of some of society's most vulnerable crime victims.


In 2004, Arpaio's office employed only four detectives in a sex-crimes unit assigned to investigate rapes and molestations in the MCSO's widespread jurisdiction.

The caseload was too heavy for the few detectives to perform their work properly, and the situation didn't get much better that year, when two more detectives (including Weege) were added.

Detectives Ward and Weege (whom Goodyear's police chief publicly stands behind, despite Arpaio's attempt to smear them) wrote in a nine-page letter to Sheriff Babeu in May 2011 that "it was not uncommon for detectives to [be working on] 40 to 50 cases each," in addition to new calls they received.

In 2005, Ward, who had joined the unit in 2001, was pulled out to work on an investigation into Cactus Towing, owned by Lee Watkins. The unit was told to "do the best they could" with just five detectives.

As New Times reported on November 29, 2007 ("Enemies List"), evidence showed that the Cactus Towing case was politically motivated.

Watkins had been active in Republican politics at the time, helping various candidates, including Arpaio. But in 2004, Watkins told the sheriff he was supporting W. Steven Martin instead of Arpaio in that year's campaign.

"I guess you're going to take your chances," Watkins quoted the sheriff as telling him.

A year later, on March 31, 2005, the Sheriff's Office raided the towing company, seizing computers, $25,000 in cash, and 200 boxes of records. News reports from the time show that Arpaio had assigned 10 detectives to the towing case, which involved allegations that the company had overcharged customers.

Remember: Just five detectives were working all the sex-abuse cases in Arpaio's vast jurisdiction.

The Watkins witch hunt played well in the media, giving Arpaio his desired exposure — and revenge on the businessman who had spurned him.

No charges were filed in the case, but Watkins lost so much money that he was forced to sell his towing business.

In late 2005, El Mirage brought in the Sheriff's Office to assist a police department besieged by complaints.

Records show that the MCSO's Ken Holmes and Brian Beamish were assigned to serve as acting police chief and assistant chief, respectively, to a contingent of deputies.

"[El Mirage] just needed some help in certain areas, and one of those areas had to do with sex crimes," Holmes told Babeu's investigators in January 2011. "And what we did is, we started moving many of those cases into the county system."

Soon after Arpaio's office took charge, in early 2006, detectives in his tiny sex-crimes unit were dismayed to learn that a number of open cases would be dumped on them and that they'd be on call for new El Mirage sex-abuse cases.

The detectives were refused requests for more manpower.

Arpaio had other plans for his resources. In January 2006, sex-crimes sergeants Bruce Tucker and Kim Seagraves were summoned to Chief Deputy Hendershott's office. There, they found out that they would be investigating former county School Superintendent Sandra Dowling.

The inclusion of Seagraves in the case later would affect the way Arpaio's office dealt with the sex-crimes scandal, stalling the internal probe into the matter for more than a year.

On January 25, 2006, the county's deputy budget director, Brian Hushek, told Seagraves what the county wanted: Dowling "begging on her hands and knees" to have the Board of Supervisors help her out of her legal trouble, Seagraves told Babeu's investigators.

That night, dozens of sheriff's deputies raided Dowling's home and her county offices, carting off boxes of documents that would require heavy manpower to pore over in the coming months. Arpaio's office, naturally, tipped off the news media to the raid.

Tucker told Babeu's detectives that, when the case kicked off, "I thought this was nothing more than mismanagement [that included] a beef with somebody."

But he and others assigned to the Dowling investigation were pressed to come up with evidence that could be used for charges.

Arpaio, as New Times explained in "Joe Knew," is a consummate micro-manager of high-profile cases that will get him in the news. In later public-corruption cases that would be discredited, Arpaio reviewed a search warrant personally and demanded that more headline-grabbing material be added. The sheriff sat in on numerous strategy meetings for cases involving county officials and suggested tactics to be used in investigations, according to his own command staff.

In the Dowling case, Tucker explained to Babeu's investigators, Arpaio pressured him repeatedly to come up with a case against Keith and Tim Bee, who owned school-bus company Bee Line Transportation, which had a contract with the Maricopa school district overseen at one time by Dowling. In 2006, Tim Bee was the Republican majority leader in the Arizona House of Representatives.

Tucker found absolutely no evidence of any crime, though.

Arpaio "kept asking me, 'Well, where are we? Are we going to get charges on the Bees?' And I said, 'No. I mean I'm working on it, but I don't see anything here,'" Tucker said to Babeu's office.

This clearly frustrated Arpaio, Tucker said.

"Then, kind of jokingly one day, [Arpaio] said, 'Well, if you get charges on them, I'll take you out . . . You get charges on Bee, I'll take you out to a steak dinner.'"

Tucker said this made him believe the Dowling case could be politically motivated.

Tucker and up to 10 deputies at a time toiled on the Dowling matter for months, eventually submitting charges to then-Arizona Attorney General Terry Goddard, who filed 25 felony charges against Dowling in November 2006.

No criminal allegation ever was lodged against the Bees. New Times called Tim Bee, now associate vice president for government relations at the University of Arizona, and his brother, Keith, responded. The brothers didn't have any relationship with Arpaio and couldn't imagine why the sheriff would be so intent on charging them, Keith Bee says.

"I would have real concern" if Tucker's story were true, Bee says. "That's amazing!"

It should be noted that there's no record of Arpaio's offering to buy anyone a steak dinner for solving rape and molestation cases.

The Dowling charges were trumped up. Maricopa Superior Court Judge Edward Burke, concerned with the shoddy investigation by the Sheriff's Office, ruled that 10 of the charges must be reheard by a grand jury, which hadn't received all the pertinent facts in the original grand jury hearings. None of the charges was refiled.

The 10 charges had to do with the most serious allegation — that Dowling had stolen $1.8 million in public funds.

Dowling hadn't stolen the money. Rather, the Board of Supervisors was concerned that the funds, which all went to Dowling's school district, had been transferred without its authority.

Every charge against Dowling was dropped except one, a misdemeanor: hiring a relative at the school district. She pleaded guilty to the charge.

Dowling filed the first of several lawsuits against the county in December 2008 — causing the Sheriff's Office to hold off on the internal investigation into the sex-crimes fiasco out of concern that it put Dowling investigator Seagraves' reputation on the line. The former schools superintendent and the county settled three of her lawsuits in November 2009.

She then filed another suit in December 2009, claiming that her constitutional rights had were violated by the county and Arpaio's office. The case is pending.


In early 2007, Joe Arpaio approved an agreement between his office and the Central American country of Honduras to help train police officers. That year, a few dozen deputies and commanders — including Chief Deputy Dave Hendershott — spent weeks on the country's Roatan Island, a popular scuba-diving destination. At least $180,000 in public funds was used for the trips during a time of extreme budget shortfalls.

Ward and Weege wrote in their letter to Babeu that one of their supervisors, Lieutenant Hank Brandimarte, told all the MCSO sex-crimes detectives that one of them would have to "volunteer" for duty in Honduras.

"It was pointed out to Brandimarte that the unit was being inundated with cases, that we were already short [on] detectives, and that we couldn't keep up with the caseload — and that this was a foreign country," they wrote.

Nevertheless, a detective agreed to go, which further crippled the unit's ability to work rape and molestation cases. The number of full-time detectives in the sex-crimes unit was back down to four in 2007.

Also in early 2007, Arpaio and his ally, former County Attorney Andrew Thomas, started a new task force that would handle cases similar to the one against Dowling. Lisa Allen, Arpaio's spokeswoman, coined the acronym "MACE," for Maricopa Anti-Corruption Enforcement.

The organization handled a few legitimate cases in 2007, but it mostly targeted Arpaio's political foes. And Thomas was more than willing to go along with the investigations.

Former Attorney General Goddard was an early MACE target, for a crime he didn't commit. The Sheriff's Office accused him of taking a payoff of $1.9 million from the state Treasurer's Office and transferring it to the Attorney General's Office in return for reducing charges against former Arizona Treasurer David Petersen, who had pleaded guilty in 2006 to knowingly filing a false or incomplete financial-disclosure statement, a misdemeanor.

In fact, the payment was mandated by state law, and Goddard personally didn't receive a penny. There was no evidence that Goddard had committed a crime, but Arpaio's office kept the investigation open for years. Arpaio's own command personnel told the sheriff about their doubts regarding the case. MACE Sergeant Brandon Luth later told Babeu's detectives that he believed Arpaio was using the Goddard investigation as "a way of having leverage over the AG's Office."

Petersen, whose case was investigated by MACE in April 2007, had been convicted of failing to disclose about $4,000 in earnings. But this wasn't anywhere near as egregious as an MCSO scheme to violate campaign-finance laws in 2007 and 2008:

Arpaio's two top men, Hendershott and Deputy Chief Larry Black, conspired to raise more than $100,000 from wealthy Arpaio supporters to secretly fund a smear ad against Arpaio's 2008 opponent, Dan Saban.

There's no reason to believe Arpaio didn't know about the plan. Days before the TV ad about Saban aired, Hendershott was "like a kid in a candy shop," telling people that something big was about to happen, Lisa Allen told investigators. From the Babeu report, it appears that all the top officials in Arpaio's headquarters on the 19th floor of the Wells Fargo building in downtown Phoenix knew what was up.

Goddard's office, which had received complaints about the undercover fundraising work, conducted a criminal investigation that uncovered evidence of potential fraud, operating an illegal enterprise, and obstruction of justice. New Times detailed the case, which involved apparent corruption at both the Sheriff's Office and the state Republican Party, in an April 14 article, "Love Connection."

State Attorney General Tom Horne transferred the investigation to the U.S. Attorney's Office in early 2011. The feds have yet to charge anyone.

Under the supervision of Arpaio and Thomas, MACE plowed ahead with investigations against three county supervisors: Don Stapley, Mary Rose Wilcox, and Andy Kunasek.

The bogus charges of failing to disclose financial information against Stapley and Wilcox later were dismissed. No charges were filed against Kunasek, who was accused of wasting $14,000 in county funds to sweep for bugs believed to have been illegally planted by Arpaio's office in its war against county officials.

It appears that Thomas' underling, Deputy County Attorney Lisa Aubuchon, tried to extort Kunasek.

Thomas left office in 2009 after his unsuccessful run for state attorney general, and Aubuchon — a transcript of an interview with Kunasek shows — suggested to the supervisor that the criminal case against him would be dropped if he would agree to help pick a new county attorney acceptable to Thomas.

The State Bar of Arizona, whose disciplinary panel scrutinized Thomas and Aubuchon's role in MACE cases, is considering whether they should be disbarred.

Arpaio, Thomas, and their former employees remain under investigation by federal authorities on allegations of abuse of power, most of which have to do with their conduct as the heads of MACE.

Before MACE, Thomas and Arpaio didn't always see eye to eye, especially on illegal immigration.

Thomas had campaigned on the issue before getting elected in 2004. But in August 2005, following the passage of an Arizona law that made it a state crime to smuggle immigrants, Arpaio told the Arizona Republic, "I want the authority to lock up smugglers, but I am not going to lock up illegals hanging around street corners. I'm not going to waste my resources going after a guy in a truck when he picks up five illegals to go trim palm trees."

However, seeing that Thomas had public support for his anti-illegal-immigrant ideas, Arpaio changed his stance. Thomas interpreted the 2005 law to mean that average illegal immigrants — not just smugglers — could be charged with conspiracy to smuggle themselves into the country.

Arpaio allied with Thomas and began hunting all undocumented Mexicans. By mid-2006, Arpaio was using hundreds of deputies and volunteer posse members to arrest illegal immigrants, who then would be charged with conspiracy by Thomas.

No other Arizona county sheriff or county attorney felt this tack was appropriate. (New County Attorney Bill Montgomery has continued to accept such cases.)

In July 2007, Arpaio set up a hotline that citizens could use to tattle on illegal immigrants.

By then, Arpaio had diverted a massive amount of his office's resources toward busting illegal immigrants.

In another far cry from the four or five detectives assigned to investigate sex crimes countywide, Arpaio's office ultimately put 100 deputies through weeks of training to become cross-certified federal immigration agents. The deputies then proceeded to do exactly what Arpaio said in 2005 he wouldn't do — bust average migrants.

Undocumented housecleaners and landscapers driving pickups with cracked windshields became a priority. In September 2007, dozens of deputies and detectives were assigned to a sting that resulted in the arrest of 18 undocumented street-corner tamale vendors.

In the same month, Arpaio began the first of his immigrant roundups, which he called "crime sweeps." That October, just before the contract between El Mirage and the Sheriff's Office ended, Arpaio sent 100 deputies and posse members to the town for a sweep that netted eight illegal immigrants.

Also around that time, Arpaio dedicated numerous deputies and about $300,000 in public funds for a three-episode reality show called Smile . . . You're Under Arrest, starring him and his agency.

Meanwhile, hundreds of rape and child-molestation cases got scant attention from Arpaio's handful of sex-crimes deputies.


About two years after the Sheriff's Office took over in El Mirage, the town decided to "take back" the police department.

The idea was to have the MCSO relinquish control by late spring 2008. But hearing that his services no longer were wanted in El Mirage, Arpaio pulled the plug on the cooperative agreement in October 2007.

Following that, during a sex-crimes unit staff meeting, Lieutenant Hank Brandimarte told Sergeant Kim Seagraves that all El Mirage cases would be returned to the town, whether they were finished or not, according to Mary Ward and James Weege's letter.

The sex-crimes detectives were given a "short time frame" in which to summarize what had been done on the outstanding cases and what still needed to be done.

"After the cases were [put together for transfer back], they sat on a conference table at MCSO for about a month, with no one working them," Ward and Weege wrote.

Finally, the boxes of reports were driven to El Mirage.

A few weeks later, Arpaio's executive chief, Scott Freeman, got a call from Mike Frazier, who'd been hired as the new police chief in the West Valley town.

"Hey, what I got was a bunch of crap," Freeman recalled Frazier saying, according to the Babeu report.

As Frazier remembers it, his language was even more colorful. He and his staff were stunned when they reviewed the cases.

"You could look at them and tell no work had been done," he says.

MCSO Captain Steve Whitney, Brandimarte's supervisor, offered to take back the poorly investigated cases, but Frazier declined, preferring to have his own office review them. Frazier and his department soon realized that though some of the cases weren't solid, many others were.

"A lot of people had continued to be victims," Frazier says.

Frazier sent a written complaint to Arpaio.

MCSO officials soon realized they had a major situation on their hands.

At first, Brandimarte was told to check on the problem.

But Seagraves and Ward didn't want Brandimarte investigating the sex-crimes unit because (it later was affirmed) he had sexually harassed them. The women filed a complaint against him, and the inquiry into the sex-crimes unit — and the sex-crimes cases themselves — stalled for months.

Two investigations eventually came about: The first was a "remedial" probe intended to fix outstanding cases and solve problems that resulted in minimal police work. The second was the internal inquiry aimed at assigning blame for the situation.

Neither investigation actually began until mid-May 2008, more than six months after Frazier's complaint.

One consequence was that the sex-crimes unit fell even further behind on its work from the end of the El Mirage contract until late summer 2008.

As Weege and Ward describe it, their captain informed the unit that it would be required to help with an audit of older cases but it still would be responsible for ongoing cases and call-outs on new crimes.

With the unit still minimally staffed, another supervisor said some of the detectives would be tasked with an important new assignment. This was soon after then-Phoenix Mayor Phil Gordon had criticized Arpaio's sweeps and accused the Sheriff's Office of racial profiling.

A young political opponent of Gordon's, Jarrett Maupin, told the MCSO that Gordon had been involved in a sexual relationship with a man. The allegation proved to be false, but the MCSO made the investigation a priority.

The unit was informed that its members would get overtime pay to work the case.

"Detectives expressed their concerns that this appeared to be politically motivated and [that] they weren't comfortable being involved in it," Ward and Weege wrote in their letter. "Detectives made comments about the absurdity of the Gordon investigation and the irony that they could get overtime for this, but not for child interviews."

Detective Weege wrote that he refused Lugo's request to run criminal background checks on Gordon's staff for a "maybe" crime — that such activity might constitute illegal use of law enforcement computers. Lugo, according to Weege, said he would find somebody else to do it.

Maupin later pleaded guilty to a charge of false reporting.

In mid-August, because of a "hostile work environment" and stress, Ward and Weege resigned from the MCSO. They had no idea at the time that they were targeted in the internal investigation into the sex-crimes mess.

After they left, they were told by a deputy that supervisors in the office had talked of serving search warrants on their homes. Their offices at the MCSO were "taped off as if they were crime scenes," they later learned.

The Sheriff's Office — rather than admit that the debacle with the sex-abuse cases was caused by Arpaio's politically self-serving decisions on where to expend resources — decided the lowly detectives would be scapegoated.


The "remedial" investigation by the Sheriff's Office resulted in the reopening of 432 cases considered potentially problematic. It's unclear how many of these are El Mirage cases.

"They went back, reopened cases, re-did interviews, re-did search warrants, made arrests, " MCSO Executive Chief Freeman told Babeu's investigators, adding that he transferred five or six detectives into the sex-crimes unit to help.

But the extra manpower came too late for many abuse victims.

In at least one case reviewed by New Times, it's clear that crimes occurred after an initial report was sent to MCSO detectives.

After a father was accused of beating his 12-year-old boy in late 2005, sheriff's detectives received the case but did not investigate. State Child Protective Services contacted the Sheriff's Office about the case the following year, forwarding tape-recorded interviews as evidence. One of the tapes contained an allegation that an 8-year-old girl in the same household had been sexually abused, but, again, no follow-up was done.

A report on the case, forwarded in April 2006 by CPS, details an allegation that both of the boy's parents had threatened to kill him, holding a knife to his throat and beating him with a stick. CPS noted that an examination of the boy's shoulder blade showed an unhealed fracture.

The sex-crimes unit gave back the file to El Mirage police in August 2007, "with apparently no work having been done." The case still is active.

In other cases, it's possible that more abuse occurred after the MCSO took a case — or, at the least, that swift investigation would have led to arrests.

One example: A mom took her three girls, ages 4 to 10, to a medical center in June 2007 after they'd complained of vaginal burning. "The victims reported that their live-in step-grandfather — identity known — had touched their vaginas and inserted his fingers on multiple occasions," a police report states.

By December 2007, the case still hadn't been worked.

A few months later, Bruce Tucker, the former Dowling investigator, was assigned the internal sex-crimes probe. Then, after working on it for more than a year, he was assigned by MCSO Chief Deputy Hendershott to work with the sheriff's private lawyer, Dennis Wilenchik, on the defense against Dowling's lawsuits.

As Tucker and Hendershott drove from Wilenchik's office on July 31, the chief deputy told Tucker he didn't want anything to interfere with work on the Dowling suits. Since Sergeant Seagraves was a principal in Tucker's probe into the sex-crimes unit, Tucker was ordered to stop work on it.

It's unclear what Sheriff Arpaio knew about the stalled investigation, but he and Hendershott had near-daily briefings.

The investigation into who gets blamed for the sex-crimes debacle might have been put off forever. But in September 2010, Deputy Chief Frank Munnell, interviewed by the Attorney General's Office for its criminal investigation into the aforementioned campaign-finance scandal, dropped his bombshell memo.

The Munnell memo and the resulting investigation by Paul Babeu's office provided many new details on how Arpaio's office had messed up the sex-crimes cases. In addition, a staggering amount of corruption in the MCSO was revealed. The sheriff had no choice but to fire two of his most trusted aides, Hendershott and Deputy Chief Larry Black, for a raft of well-publicized ethical and potentially criminal violations.

Famously, he claimed he had been "duped" by Hendershott.

Now, Arpaio claims he was duped by his sex-crimes unit, which supposedly should have worked harder despite the minuscule resources he'd provided.

The Sheriff's Office has yet to reveal details of its investigation into the sex-crimes debacle, but the public soon should learn more about the scandal. Because of the Munnell memo, the internal investigation was restarted sometime in 2011.

At the January 31 hearing before the Board of Supervisors, Deputy Chief Sheridan said at least 10,000 pages of material from the long-running probe were under review by the County Attorney's Office.

Sheridan downplayed the enormity of the problem, claiming that only 15 sex-crimes cases countywide — not including the El Mirage cases — hadn't been investigated.

It's difficult to believe Sheridan's figure, considering the scope of the scandal in just El Mirage, where serious problems were noted with 43 of 51 cases assigned to the sex-crimes unit.

Whatever the real story, efforts supposedly are under way by both the Sheriff's Office and the El Mirage Police Department to shore up badly investigated cases. So far, officials say, 19 reopened cases have resulted in prosecutions, though they haven't divulged which cases they are.

Sheridan claims that new policies and training procedures have been put in place "so the problem does not surface again."

But Arpaio and the public have not heard the last of the sex-crimes mess.

In December, the U.S. Department of Justice issued findings in a long-running civil investigation of the MCSO, claiming that Arpaio's department has discriminated against Hispanics and committed the "most egregious case" of racial profiling in U.S. law enforcement history. A report on the findings says the Justice Department still is examining whether the failure to investigate sex crimes was because of Arpaio's "culture of bias" against Hispanics.

The Justice Department also still is probing criminal allegations that Arpaio abused his power.

Now, with all his baggage, Arpaio has entered campaign mode, hoping to ride out the criticism and — at 80 years old — get re-elected to another four-year term.


"I've been praying for a phone call like this," a woman in Chicago tells New Times.

The woman is the mother of a 13-year-old girl who claimed that she'd been molested repeatedly by her father in 2006.

When the girl was 8, she was sent to California to live with her grandmother during the contentious divorce of her El Mirage parents. There, she said her "daddy did something bad to her," her grandmother told authorities. The grandmother called El Mirage police in August 2006, reporting that the girl said she had been sexually abused for about two years.

The case was forwarded to Arpaio's Special Victims Unit. A week later, a caseworker from California CPS phoned MCSO Detective Chad Brackman to say she had "useful information" about the matter after talking to the grandmother. MCSO sex-crimes Detective John Felbab was assigned the case, "but very little was done," El Mirage police later wrote in a report. "[Felbab] conducted a minimal amount of follow-up."

The last action the Sheriff Office took was to interview the girl in February 2007.

It would have been easy to find the suspect — he was convicted in November 2006 of robbery and was serving a three-year sentence in an Arizona prison. But the man never was interviewed about the crime.

El Mirage police wrote that no explanation exists for why the case wasn't worked or submitted to the County Attorney's Office. "This was clearly a prosecutable case," El Mirage police wrote.

In November 2007, El Mirage detectives could not locate the victim, her mother, or the grandmother. They contacted Arizona CPS and "obtained nothing to go on." The case is considered active.

The girl's mother says she can't comprehend why police dropped the case. The girl was interviewed by experts several times, and they concluded she was telling the truth. But she says a Sheriff's Office detective told her that the case never would stand up in court, "that it was my daughter's word against [her assailant's]. They said they didn't want to put her through it."

Yet the girl and mother still are ready to testify, the woman tells New Times. The woman's phone number was passed along to El Mirage police at her request.

Asked whether she thought it was possible that her ex-husband could commit a similar crime, she replied, "If he did it to his own daughter, why couldn't he do it to somebody else?"

Pursuing such a sex-abuse investigation — after 5 1/2 years of inactivity — won't win Arpaio the kind of headlines he craves.

Which could explain why a teenage girl in Chicago still is seeking justice.

Show Pages
 
My Voice Nation Help
160 comments
Richard1980
Richard1980

I can see why a non-profit organization would sidle up to Joe, it would get them media coverage they need for donations, but Joe sidling up to them is just for his gain and is wrong. yes, they need help and wont turn any away, and for that i honestly cant really blame them. but Joe has had a track record of using things or people for his gain and discarding them. i dont think anybody should turn them away, because they are a good cause, but Joe using them the way he is, and after the whole El Mirage deal, just proves how bent that sick old man really is. the day after the election he wont give them another thought. so in a way, i agree that the article shouldnt make them out as evil, but i have no problem with them stating that Joe is http://www.protopage.com/buy-neurontin-online http://www.protopage.com/order-cipro-online http://www.protopage.com/order-lasix-online http://www.protopage.com/buy-keflex-online http://www.protopage.com/buy-clomid-online http://www.protopage.com/buy-lipitor-usa

Robert
Robert

Rape and death are normal in Mexico, Central America and South America.
Native women are often raped by relatives and non relatives. Very few escape this crime against humanity. Same in the middle east and muslim control.
Women do not have any standing in society in many, many places throughtout the world. Especially if you are a different race.

Oregonpapa
Oregonpapa

And if illegal immigration was under control in Arizona, the sex crimes would plummet over night.

alison hicks
alison hicks

Sheriff Joe Arpaio and Lisa Allen his head Publicist are out for anyone, anything or whatever will make the news. Power, money and control: you wonder how people lie so much and won't go on a public appearance unless it is in their favor. Arpaio has so much money and pays lisa off to control his power along with the media. Who the F....is this guy and why does he scare off so many people. Money can pay people off??? SICK PEOPLE THAT TAKE THAT MONEY LIKE LISA ALLEN. She is not going to be good looking in my movie BackSPIN. Just like the inside looks don't matter she is. I'm doing the casting on her. This will make my movie making her outside look like her inside lies and catch up with the thing she protrays. I WOULD HATE TO BE LIKE HER OR JOE. I LOVE TO LIVE HONEST. THESE PEOPLE KILL FAMILIES LIVES AND NEED TO BE EXPLOITED.

Troybunch
Troybunch

I wonder how many rapes and sex trafficking is going on this week with your Backpage ads? which is owned and operated by New Times owners Larkin and Lacey. Just google "village voice pimps", owners of New Times to find out all about their sex trafficking.

sherrdbw
sherrdbw

I guess that Arpaio was too busy investigating President Obama's birth certificate instead of dealing with issues in his own county. Isn't it about time that he retires.

Alabama

Ddesertdawg
Ddesertdawg

Looks like everyone needs to avoid the town of El Mirage with all the perverts who live there,is it the water?

IzzyKiddnya
IzzyKiddnya

Sheriff Joe was to busy! The "Big Bust" was reported in the UK!
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/new...

He managed to prevent a conspiracy which would have seksually abused a German Sheppard dog! He got all three of the malefactors!

I guess when you elect your law enforcement leaders, you get the kind of priorities you really want

Olga Aros
Olga Aros

eLatinaVoices received a copy of the sex crimes audit that identified the 432 crimes not investigated by MCSO. On January 31, Deputy Sheridan reported to the County Board of Supervisors that there were only 15 uninvestigated cases. We made a public comment to the Board and to Deputy Sheridan and County Attorney Montgomery, challenging the reported 15 uninvestigated crime report and contacted the MCSO Sex Crimes Unit for clarification. We have yet to receive a response. Of the 432 sex crime cases, we learned that El Mirage had 32, Guadalupe had 19, Litchfield had less than 10. We are still awaiting reports from the other contracted cities. On behalf of the sex crime victims, we thank you for bringing this to light. A change in leadership at the MCSO is critical for the safety of our children.

Jerri Pastor
Jerri Pastor

Please take time to read - this is only one example of the work that Maricopa County Sheriffs office neglected in El Mirage.

Mark
Mark

This situation disgusts me. One of the most moving things I've ever been a part of in Phoenix was the vigil for victims of abuse who were ignored by Joe Arpaio after this story first broke, down at Occupy Phoenix. The vigil may not have "done" anything, but it was great coming together and being mournful... right before discussing how to get this motherf***er out. Serious issues here-- can anyone deny this is BAD for Phoenix and Arizona in general? Geeze!
http://youtu.be/w32QbhFQfQA

azdriver
azdriver

I see Phoenix New Times as quite a biased publication. Still, Ray Stern's article certainly shows there are serious issues with MCSO. Of course that's if the facts presented are accurate of which I am always somewhat suspicious no matter the media outlet. If El Mirage had an influential residents, I'm sure MCSO would have been there in a flash and in force. Isn't it time to get some "new blood" as Sheriff? I think so.

Jesus Cristo de Nogales
Jesus Cristo de Nogales

Help end the illegal Mexican occupation of the United States of America. Vote for candidates that support deportation and not pathway to citizenship. It is the only way to prevent the total destructiom of the US.

Pat
Pat

who cares about arpaio, did you hear what is going on in paul babeu's county? LOL

wpnz96
wpnz96

It seems to me tht really the only thing Sherrif Joe cares about is deporting all of the mexicans and arresting people for DUI. Any other crime doesn't seem too important for this guy. Oh and don't forget he always has to have his face on TV.

Broski Love
Broski Love

Sheriff Joe is a greasy fat bastard thats coated in teflon. He owns too many people and Obama wont touch Murrica's favorite Sheriff with an election so close.

Church lady
Church lady

It's not uncle Joe's fault. He assigned them to Babeu.

Haley Fivestar
Haley Fivestar

there are far too, too many sexual abuse cases within the phoenix area and it seems that none are behind bars being held accountable for their crimes. Just running a search on sex offenders will pull up what seems to be hundreds all over central phoenix alone. Now, the state protects them due to harsh environments should they go to prison. To the public from an ex-con, you need to push for these cases to make sentencing to prison. they do pay for these crimes there. They deserve whatever they get and should not be protected by the law. innocent people are sentenced to hard time everyday, and also not so innocent, none the less, they still receive very harsh sentences, while these sick predators are left free to roam the street and prey on our children. Then society and the law wonder why individuals take law upon themselves. If maricopa county was'nt using these offenders as street informants for petty investigations like small time hustling, then maybe we wouldnt live in fear for our children. Voters need to push for sentencing changes. I myself find that a child predator is far worse than a simple drug dealer trying to survive, and I believe should be taken to much more extreme during sentencing process. In fact, there is no cure for sexual predator's, they will never think differently. If you ask me, they are the ones who should receive death sentences. I commend the men doing time who clean up by ridding us all of these individuals. Children are angels of god and should not be harmed. Anyone who hurts an innocent child should meet severe consequences.......

Slugman2000
Slugman2000

Wasn't this covered by abc15 9months ago, and then the national media 3 months ago? The man is Teflon, he will never see justice

azwayne
azwayne

I see more problem with morals of the complainers than the sherriff department. When you're this perverted who do you expect to help?? You think they turn in relatives, adn dog like friends??? Who would allow any of this perversion to occur, whpo with a brain??/

Jesus Christo de Nogales
Jesus Christo de Nogales

Leave it to the Phoenix "New" Times news to post any and all stories that take attention away from the most serious destruction of the American way of life. We should all be concentrating on how we end the illegal Mexican occupation of America and return the occupiers back to Mexico!

Usgovfail
Usgovfail

I would rather the sheriff focus on apprehending illegal aliens as they cause so many problems for the USA. They steal identities, don't pay state or federal income tax, take jobs citizens could be doing, and drain taxpayers since we have to pay for the birth of their anchor babies. Illegals also get in state tuition which they shouldn't.

Let police and cps work on the sex abuse cases. Why aren't they under fire for not focusing on these cases?

This rag and azlibtardcentral are going after arpaio because you like illegal alien penis, don't you? Cheap sex from dirty south of the border trannys? You are some sick people.

Bill
Bill

There is no one at the (yellow rag ) like the new times that could run the SHERIFF Dept.But you are the first to scream about things that you know nothing about.The victims didnot help the sheriff with there complaints because most of them included family members and boy friends that they never pushed for helped some were ILLegal and did not get sent back to Mexico .It now becomes something to complain about to the yellow news paper who will blow it out of portion just to hurt the Sheriff dept This is just to hurt the only dept.that trying to keep
this state out of Mexican control and you people are not smart enough to see it.YOU WILL WHEN ITS TO LATE>
.

Lastrealindian
Lastrealindian

I am 100% PRO JOE ARPIO and I friggn damn tired of these ratty ass ILLEGALS coming here and stealing our jobs, money, raping and murdering our American Citizens! I would like to line all of them up and go gung ho 'firing squad' on their asses! Too bad that will never happen becuse of all the WEAK ASS WHITE PEOPLE!!!

Albert2010
Albert2010

Since you obviously left your brain in the toilet bowl, I would suggest you retrive it and at least start it up BEFORE you get online. BTW, while you are in there, don't forget to put your Hitler Youth shorts back on your butt. COMPRENDE, BRO ??

sarum
sarum

Oh yes, let us all march in lockstep goosestep to the Soros funded Hispanic Nazi agenda. Let us all break the borders for the globalists and let the NWO begin because we Hispanics think our lot will be better and we have been given secret promises to that effect. So what if Jesus is hispanic? We know that having a different idea is not tolerated in the community so that is why we have to come here anonymously - so fuck you for putting that on him and me and anybody else. Hispanic does not mean to think one way only means that you are disloyal to your race. That kind of thinking makes you a willing tool, rhymes with fool.

sarum
sarum

Readers may be ignorant as to how the various social strata of Mexico handle sexuality issues and what is commonplace and accepted in their culture as well as their law. To view Sheriff Joe's choices through a narrow prism of US law is to self-servingly forget that in many legal cases here in the US laws of other nations (like Sharia) has trumped US domestic law and that cultural insensitivity has become a prosecutable crime. The "Mexican" population needs to decide if they want to live by US law and US culture or Mexican law and Mexican culture. To expect any law enforcement officer to determine on a case by case basis which cases are prosecutable and which cases are culturally acceptable to this population is expecting too much or you could ask Georgy Porgy to fund that initiative too. So drop the La Raza Reconquista Macho Mexico shit or go back there. You can't have it both ways and pick and choose which parts of US law you want the protection of and then make out that other parts of US law is persecuting you just cuz you chose to break it or cuz you chose NOT to learn la linqua franca so you couldn't know. It would be delicious to prosecute all of the sex perps regardless of whether their culture of origin allows their behavior or not and lock them all up and throw away the key but then this article would either never happen or the "Shurf" would be getting prosecuted for cultural insensitivity - oh wait, he already is. Meanwhile those who embrace US law and custom and culture first are called "bad Mexicans" and receive great prejudice from the Reconquista Brown Power ones. So just sign me BAD MEXICAN.

sarum
sarum

AZ has always been pathetic regarding help for rape victims. At one time the so-called rape crisis center had a 6 month backlog for counseling related to the crime. That really helps when you are in crisis now having been raped yesterday. Oh yeah, just put all your resultant disfunctionality on hold for 6 months before you get help. And then be reminded that these organizations are generally run by lesbians who want to turn your brain towards their political agenda rather than help you re-adjust to a bi-sexual (as in 2 sexes) society - nope, they would just as soon turn you towards a women only community. So Joe has gone with the flow on this one. AZ has always sucked on this issue.

Joe Friday
Joe Friday

How can people sacrafice innocent children because a criminal wraps himself in the flag creating the illusion of safety. Joe Arpaio is closer to John Wayne Gacey not the Duke. It is time for Americans and Arizonans to stand for right.

rosalia136
rosalia136

Someone that knows what he's talking about!

sherrdbw
sherrdbw

And here I thought that Florida had all of the pervs.

Alabama

minnie trout
minnie trout

Is this you Joe? Sounds like Joe. Distraction is not going to work anymore.

rosalia136
rosalia136

This is kind of the subject but, still is relevant. and it is relevant because the Phoenix you times wrote a story on it, LOL nobody wants to hear from the the idiot running against the Sheriff.
http://blogs.phoenixnewtimes.c...

Bnbk
Bnbk

Me thinks that subconsiously,it is YOU that craves a big brown piece of Latino man meat. You're projecting you perverted, closeted fantasies.

Follower_of_the_ONE
Follower_of_the_ONE

I don't think I've read or heard of anybody working for this yellow rag offering to run for the office and make the claim they could run the office. No, those are Arpiao's claims and he has failed miserably at meeting those claims. So really you think Arpiao is going to ride his shiny white ass in and save you against the mexican horde? LMAO1

LD19 Resident
LD19 Resident

This state was PART of Mexico before we "won" (read:stole) it from our southern neighbor in 1848.

Arpaio is NOT a police officer. He is not even AZPOST certified.

Get a clue and the facts before you post.

LD19 Resident
LD19 Resident

This isn't Nazi Germany or the Soviet Union under Josef Stalin buddy.

"I friggn damn tired of these ratty ass ILLEGALS coming here and stealing our jobs, money, raping and murdering our American Citizens! I would like to line all of them up and go gung ho 'firing squad' on their asses!"

Good for you for being pro-Joe. I am not and I very strongly disagree with his policies, which is why Arpaio is in scalding hot water with the DOJ as I type.

I don't think you even read the article. I also think you need to stop drinking the Arpaio/Pearce Kool-Aid.

Arpaio and his office essentially spit in the eyes of crime victims, all of whom are American citizens, just because they are poor and/or are Hispanic. That is disgusting and inexcusable.

You need to get the facts before you post, buddy.

Dogbiter
Dogbiter

you're a dumb sack of shit. self-deport to europe, mofo!

rosalia136
rosalia136

Joe Arpaio Opponent Mike Stauffer Suddenly Uninvited to Candidate Forum
Less than 24 hours away from a candidate forum in Sun City West that was supposed to host both ​Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio and his opponent Mike Stauffer, the Stauffer campaign tells New Times that he's been officially uninvited.

Usgovfail
Usgovfail

Countries are stolen all the time. Its called war you fool. Strong survive, weak perish. Mexico was weak (still is) that's why they lost this land.

Get the fuck out of the USA if you are going to talk shit about a country whose founders fought and died so trash like you could have free speech.

This nation is one of the greatest on the planet because of Europeans. If this land was still Mexico it would just be more poverty and filth owned by drug cartel.

Mexican citizens are weak people with no integrity.

Usgovfail
Usgovfail

Fuck you and your illegal alien roaches.

Lastrealindian
Lastrealindian

First I am not your buddy. Second, you are one of the Illegal Alien pity party people. I am not. YOU are one of the friggn "Occupy" rats! You are against OUR own laws! Go to hell

Richard9397
Richard9397

Crawl back into your hole. Daylight does not serve you well. COMRENDE ???

LD19 Resident
LD19 Resident

"Countries are stolen all the time."

Really? Name the last time a country was stolen since the Spanish-American War of 1898.

Um, I fought to protect and defend the Constitution from all enemies, foreign and domestic. I have no intention of leaving the United States.

This nation is the greatest on Earth because of immigrants, including Hispanics. I know and am friends with several Hispanics.

"Mexican citizens are weak people with no integrity."

Describes yourself perfectly.

Bnbk
Bnbk

Yea,this coming from someone who has constantly spewed his anti-US goverment diatribe.

WhoKnows
WhoKnows

Third, if you still support Arpaio, you have the brain of a turnip!

Shadowlokon
Shadowlokon

I am half mexican/white, born in North Dakota raised in Az. Ive never seen such ignorant white and mexican people. I am proud fuckin American. I exercise all my rights. But because my skin is brown, idiot white people like u set this country back to slavery. You obviously lost or never had the consept of what being American is!

LD19 Resident
LD19 Resident

A few thoughts:

1) I do not now, nor have I ever supported illegal immigration. However, no one seems interested in resolving this issue. Arpaio and Pearce have not resolved the issue, nor is it within the state's purview to do so.

2) I am in no way, shape or form associated with the Occupy movement.

3) I stand for the rule of law. I very strongly disagree with the MCSO shurf because he is not providing law-enforcement services. Rather, he is campaigning and getting his face on TV. This is why the DOJ is here: Doing the job the Flaccid Failure won't do.

4) If you live in Maricopa County, Arizona, and I do, you are already in hell.

 
Loading...