The Mother of a Molestation Victim Cries Foul Over Plea Deal for Chris Simcox

Michelle Lynch has a suitcase full of disturbing stories to tell about accused child molester and former minuteman leader Chris Simcox.

Some are really creepy, especially in hindsight.

Simcox had "tons" of little girls in his apartment playing with his two young daughters, according to Lynch, who lived in the same apartment building in an upper-middle-class complex near the border of Scottsdale and Phoenix.

Bill Montgomery once supported Chris Simcox's minuteman movement; now his prosecutor wants to cut Simcox a sweet deal.
Dennis Gilman
Bill Montgomery once supported Chris Simcox's minuteman movement; now his prosecutor wants to cut Simcox a sweet deal.
Bill Montgomery once supported Chris Simcox's minuteman movement; now his prosecutor wants to cut Simcox a sweet deal.
Dennis Gilman
Bill Montgomery once supported Chris Simcox's minuteman movement; now his prosecutor wants to cut Simcox a sweet deal.

"I remember six girls, [my daughter] being one of them walking to my house with Chris," she recalled during a recent sit-down at a Phoenix coffee shop. "They were all in princess clothing."

Lynch didn't know then that Simcox was the onetime face of the minuteman movement or that he had been accused of domestic violence and the molestation of his now-adult daughter when she was 14. She knew nothing of his public life.

Instead, she saw a single parent, like herself, who seemed deeply involved in the lives of his kids.

He was home-schooling his two daughters, who, like Lynch's daughter, were under age 10. And though he was never specific, he made it seem as if he was in law enforcement, work that he did not want to discuss.

Another time, Simcox came to her apartment, his two kids in tow. Neither she nor her daughter were home. Her 14-year-old son answered the door.

"Chris handed him a very large bag of Skittles," Lynch said. "I think it was a pound bag, and he says, 'Give this to [your sister] for being a good girl.'"

Lynch didn't think much of it. She had no reason to. Simcox had gained her trust, as he had the trust of other parents in the apartment complex. And the kids visited each others' apartments all the time.

But once her daughter revealed to her how Simcox had told her "secrets" and showed her explicit movies while molesting her, she remembered the Skittles.

"For him to walk up to my door with his two daughters and to hand my son candy, the candy he was giving to my daughter for her participation," she said, her voice filled with disgust, "that's a sick individual. He honestly doesn't care. He's very cocky."

So cocky that he may reject the sweet deal he's been offered by the Maricopa County Attorney's Office: 10 years, with his five class-2 felony counts of child molestation and sexual conduct with a minor busted down to attempted child molestation, and the class-4 felony charge for showing porn to a child wiped away.

Lynch's daughter is not Simcox's only alleged victim. The ex-kindergarten teacher and Republican politician also is charged with molesting one of his own children, inserting his finger into her vagina while both of his girls were showering together.

(Note: Lynch does not know Simcox's ex-wife Alena. Allegations concerning Simcox's daughter came up after the investigation began.)

And there was a third victim cited in the probable-cause statement, another little girl in the complex, who in a forensic interview conducted at the nonprofit anti-child abuse center Childhelp, told an investigator that Simcox had bribed her with candy to see her panties and her genitals. He allegedly had shown this girl "sexy" pictures on his computer, but apparently not pornographic ones.

Charges related to that girl have been dropped.

I initially approached Lynch at a court hearing that I reported on, one in which prosecutor Yigael Cohen told the judge he would make a plea offer.

Cohen didn't reveal the specifics in public, but Lynch was informed and broke down sobbing outside the courtroom. She didn't want to talk then.

Since that day, her sorrow has turned to rage. Her daughter has nightmares about what happened at Simcox's apartment and fears Simcox's returning to hurt her. She told her mother that she was molested every time she went to play with Simcox's kids.

The young girl is getting counseling, but the entire family has been affected. Lynch herself is wracked with guilt and horror. Before Simcox was arrested (it took one month from the initial report to another agency 'til Phoenix cops put Simcox in cuffs), the family lived in fear. One time, she caught her son sleeping with a knife.

At a recent meeting in Cohen's office, Lynch expressed distress. The felonies involving Simcox's alleged sexual conduct with his daughter hypothetically could land Simcox in prison for life. The other charges could bring decades in stir.

But with the plea deal, Simcox could be out in 81/2 years, as Arizona's cons have to serve 85 percent of a sentence before getting released. He would be 60 years old then and certainly capable of victimizing again.

Cohen assured Lynch he knew best, that he'd worked sex crimes for the past eight years. The plea deal was a "legal fiction," to ensure that Simcox did not walk and that he did not have to put her daughter or Simcox's daughters on the stand.

It was "an appropriate plea," Cohen told her, with all the sensitivity of Bashar al-Assad.

Plus, the MCAO never offers a plea deal on all counts: "That's just the way it is," he tutted.

Lynch told him that she didn't care about his eight years of experience, because she would have to spend the next eight years, and then some, making sure her daughter doesn't become a statistic.

1
 
2
 
All
 
Next Page »
 
My Voice Nation Help
65 comments
ConcernedCitizenAZ
ConcernedCitizenAZ topcommenter

This comment is too good to be buried in the blog:

toersbijnscSep 12, 2013

"When (in)tolerance breeds corruption then the entire system is flawed as others embrace this tacitly and quietly; this is not justice - this is a travesty of justice and a mockery of what we believe in. Please remember this election day. It's the only way you can exercise your own opinion on such matters and to protect our kids."

inkill
inkill

I know where the computers went... With Carmen Mercer when her crew of bigots took all of the kids toys and anything damning about the stupid little nationalist orgy called the minute men. Lol, that stupid name makes me smirk when taken into context and seeing how long they lasted. Wonder why the cops havent arrested Carmen Mercer for tampering with evidence... I'd like to hear an honest explanation for that. Key word is honest. 

val03
val03

Let him plea to anything he wants. The public isnt grasping that the "system" is broken. Once he walks out of "containment" he shouldnt last an hour on the street..

WhoKnows
WhoKnows topcommenter

Is part of the plea deal that Simcox will now testify in the Milke trial, as Montypoodle has now lost his only "witness"?


Funny how he's got proof against Simcox, and is willing to give him a break, and now has ZERO proof against Milke, but wants to hang her in any way possible!

mary14nx05y
mary14nx05y

I had sex with her daughter LOTS of times.  She is hardly a virgin.

DNichols
DNichols

This Story has been COVERED UP by Arpaio Controlled Local Media PERIOD.

Right Corrupt Republic, and Arpaio's Son in Law Editor?!!

Voters Deserve to Know of this Bull Shit Plea Deal with this Sick Arpaio/Montgomery Child Molesting Minute Man Buddy!!!!

And of Bill Montgomery's personal Dates/Border Patrols with Simcox!

To Honesty in Reporting the News?!!

MaskedMagician1967
MaskedMagician1967 topcommenter

If only Arizona politicians weren't Goddamn criminals....

DNichols
DNichols

Why is this Stoy not in Main Stream Media?!!!

Is Arpaio using his Media Connections to Cover Up his Child Molesting Pals Un-Godly Plea Deal?!!

This is an unh-beleivable "in JUstice" to the American Judicial System!

This Story should be Viral World Wide just like the "Phony Shoot out in the Desert was"!

All Arizona Voters need to See this Bull Shit, right Montgomery.

dennis20
dennis20 topcommenter

The fact is that if Chris Simcox were an undocumented dishwasher there would be no plea deal.  It's time to wake up. 

serpico1000
serpico1000

I second the comments seen in this Page, and more but what can you expect when Ulterior motives override your comments and, maybe, actions? for the polls are the best places to get rid of Vermin found in the government offices!!!! DO VOTE THE NEXT TIME YOU SEE ANY OF THESE VERMIN in the voting ballots!!!! 

DNichols
DNichols

Simcox is a Sick Bastard Montgomery, and You are a Worthless Peice of Human Trash granting Your Sick Buddy "Amnesty"!!!

Lets "Enforce Our Laws!"

"No Amnesty"!

Isn't that what you Preach for Hispanic' Mothers of our own Citizen Children Montgomery?!

You should Resign you Garbage!

Eleanor_Holguin
Eleanor_Holguin

I've learned not to expect much when it comes to the choices Bill Montgomery makes. His lack of ethics says a lot about the guy.

A plea deal will let this guy walk way too soon. There is no cure for pedophilia just death. 

If he takes a plea his record will only reflect that not the truth about the atrocities this man committed against little girls. 

Unfortunately in Arizona there are too many unethical, dishonorable people in power who allow their friends "passes" on many things bad.

It's so sad for these children to now have to handle this in their life. It isn't easy if you remember it or if you don't remember it. Your subconscious always knows what happened and interactions with others difficult or not always appropriate. That is speaking from experience.

ConcernedCitizenAZ
ConcernedCitizenAZ topcommenter

Shameful and disgusting plea bargain. This predator belongs in prison for life!

Plea bargain and Sentencing disparity in Maricopa County?

Those who go to trial are innocent or they wouldn't dare go to trial. Those who are guilty, get a plea like this, while those who were convicted at trial got decades behind bars? A Maricopa County, male, non-violent, first offender sentenced to 75 years -- a de-facto life sentence - for non-sexual "touching" in a public swimming pool? 

In Maricopa County, some men took a plea and were sentenced to a minimum of 10 years.

In Maricopa County, over 430 predators raped or molested children from 2005 and the cases were never investigated and / or were cleared by MCSO Arpaio or MCAO. 

In Maricopa County, a female, with a single incident, took a plea and was sentenced to 10 years and two life-times on the Sex Offender Registry. 

At the very least, MCAO should give the same harsh sentences they have to the many sitting in prison for decades and we're talking about non-violent, first offenders.

toersbijnsc
toersbijnsc

When tolerance breeds corruption then the entire system is flawed as others embrace this tacitly and quietly; this is not justice - this is a travesty of justice and a mockery of what we believe in. Please remember this election day. It's the only way you can exercise your own opinion on such matters and to protect our kids.

robert_graham
robert_graham

How about listening to please from mothers who's children have been victimized by illegal aliens?

royalphoenix
royalphoenix

That is a long time to wait for a public document.

david_saint01
david_saint01 topcommenter

thats the biggest load of shit ive heard/read from a prosecutors mouth...theyre making Mike Nifong look glorious here. Whats that, a politician cutting a deal so his buddy cant drag him down with him? say it aint so..pft

dennis20
dennis20 topcommenter

@WhoKnows  "s part of the plea deal that Simcox will now testify in the Milke trial, as Montypoodle has now lost his only "witness"?"

That is the funniest thing I've read in a long time. 

inkill
inkill

@mary14nx05y And what's your address so I can do to you what the MCA won't?


boomie99
boomie99

@mary14nx05y Whose daughter are you referring to?  I am hoping that you are not referring to Ms. Lynch's daughter.

WhoKnows
WhoKnows topcommenter

@mary14nx05y So, you are an admitted pedophile.  That must be why you like Arpaio so much, as you know he will ignore your crime.

ConcernedCitizenAZ
ConcernedCitizenAZ topcommenter

@MaskedMagician1967  Any informed citizen would agree with you. Grandstanders 'using" the taxpayers for their personal agenda. Arpaio and his cronies led the way for this criminal culture?

ConcernedCitizenAZ
ConcernedCitizenAZ topcommenter

@DNichols  People need to write the Arizona Republic, Michael Kiefer, the "go-to" reporter for the prosecutors and the publishers:

opinions@arizonarepublic.com 

arpaio's son-in-law is Editors of the Editors. How is that supposed to work in a 'big city" paper, #5 in the nation?


ConcernedCitizenAZ
ConcernedCitizenAZ topcommenter

@dennis20  ... Struts to the podium, for the usual grandstanding, like a "little big man". The "Napoleon" complex?

ConcernedCitizenAZ
ConcernedCitizenAZ topcommenter

@dennis20  Right. He would be held NON-bondable, no questions asked. What happened to MCAO Montgomery's "shoot first, ask later" SOP that he uses for anyone else?

ConcernedCitizenAZ
ConcernedCitizenAZ topcommenter

@serpico1000  Vote in the GOP Primary. These candidates get selected with a minimal vote.  

ConcernedCitizenAZ
ConcernedCitizenAZ topcommenter

@Eleanor_Holguin

Eleanor, Do you think MCAO Montgomery is following the West Point Cadet Code, where he attended? Is this what he's bringing to the Maricopa County Attorney's office or following the decades long well entrenched injustice at MCAO?

The U.S. Military Academy at West Point

West Point's Cadet Honor Code reads simply that

"A cadet will not lie, cheat, steal, or tolerate those who do."

Cadets accused of violating the Honor Code face a standardized investigative and hearing process

([1]). First they are tried by a jury of their peers. If they are found guilty, the case will go up to the Commandant of the Academy who will give his recommendation, then to the Superintendent of the Academy, who has the discretion to either impose sanctions or recommend that the Secretary of the Army expel the cadet from the Academy."

ConcernedCitizenAZ
ConcernedCitizenAZ topcommenter

What took so long to arrest, when others have a SWAT team surround their home, get arrested without an arrest warrant, get taken to jail and held NON-bondable

danzigsdaddy
danzigsdaddy topcommenter

@robert_graham why are you not disturbed or outraged about pedophiles Robert? why do you always try to divert attention away from sexual crimes and most especially those committed against children? the way you deny them and divert attention away from them, its almost as if you have something vested in covering them up. sexual crimes are among the sickest of all crimes, and those committed against children ARE the sickest of all crimes. i think more manpower, money and resources should be devoted to the prosecution of perpertrators of those crimes, yet you who claim to be about enforcing all laws are constantly trying to deny these crimes have happened, are happening or are worthy of any attention. even when it comes to illegal immigrants, you are never concerned with the sexual predator aspect, you are only concerned with immigration status...............why? all i want from you is a simple answer of why you are always trying to downplay sexual crimes and most especially sexual crimes against children. Why Robert, why?

robert_graham
robert_graham

@toersbijnsc Let me tell you what a mockery and travesty of justice is.  It's the political pandering to illegal aliens and opposing enforcement of immigration laws. 

danzigsdaddy
danzigsdaddy topcommenter

@robert_graham  how about immigrants children who were assualted by citizens? sex crimes are not race specific for either the victim or the violator

MaskedMagician1967
MaskedMagician1967 topcommenter

Robert, why is everything about race and immigration status with you?

I know why. It's all you have. You don't have anything of real substance to add to the conversation so you whine and complain about race and immigration status.

ConcernedCitizenAZ
ConcernedCitizenAZ topcommenter

@robert_graham  Raises the question of who was protected? White predators or Hispanic children?

Sheriff Arpaio's over 430 un-investigated child sex crimes cases, a murder and more. Read the book.


"IF THERE WERE ANY VICTIMS..?" by Bill Louis, retired police chief, author
http://www.iftherewereanyvictims.com/

sindrumz
sindrumz

@robert_graham  why you sittin here typin dummy, make a run for the border and i mean quickly, cause theres probably tons of illegal aliens linen up to meet you and yours!!! while youre at the border protectin us, get one of those minutemen  (minute lol) to watch your kids for you

lydia_guzman
lydia_guzman

@robert_graham  How about listening to pleas from migrant parents who's children were victims of sexual predators and sexual assault and your sheriff ignored  those crimes?

MaskedMagician1967
MaskedMagician1967 topcommenter

David, I researched Mike Nifong last night.

Amazing to me how much he and Candy Andy Thomas have in common....

boomie99
boomie99

@WhoKnows I certainly hope she is not speaking of Ms. Lynch's daughter. 

MaskedMagician1967
MaskedMagician1967 topcommenter

Danzig, you'll have better luck talking to a brick wall than Robert.

I personally fault the narcissistic old man and Candy Andy Thomas for the sex crimes debacle. MontyPug isn't at fault for those.

MontyPug is a war veteran. He served in the Army so I do award him credit for his service to the country.

danzigsdaddy
danzigsdaddy topcommenter

@robert_graham  do you want to know how to get Joe absolute adoration from everyone? have him stop his bullshit birth certificate investigation, stop his useless immigration/employer sanction sweeps and devote some of that money and manpower into stopping pedophiles and sexual offenders. children are the hope and future of this country, he should be protecting them. if i saw him even devote some of the resources he has into bullshit attention grabbing media ploys into stopping the abuse of our most precious resource..............i would probably support him.................but since he wont, he is just as bad as he criminals he ignores (or at least ignored over 420 different times) ..............but what is your motivation for wanting these crimes ignored? why do you vehemently deny they happened or are happening? why do you find the corruption of a childs body and mind to be so inconsequential? why do you find rape of any type to be something to be easily dismissed? what is your story that you are either in complete denial as to these crimes or that is your reasoning for finding these crimes or charges to be so trivial as to be so easily dismissed?

danzigsdaddy
danzigsdaddy topcommenter

@robert_graham wrong. travesty of justice would be going full tilt after a woman whos conviction was based on the testimony of a proven liar, then trying to back a law that prevents evidence coming forward that could possibly establish her innocence so you dont look incompetent. and while all that is happening, offering a fellow supporter of your cause a sweet plea bargain for also committing crimes against children. so according to Monty, Milke is to be denied justice (i dont know if she did it or not, but she deserves a fair trial), but Simcox is to denied a true shot at possible justice also (dont know if he did it or not, but he deserves to be sat in front of a jury)

DNichols
DNichols

@ Peice of Sh""t RobertGraham:

Immigration has nothing to do with your Sick Pal Simcox sticking his finger in his own Child Daughters Vagina!

Please Rot away with your Racist Child Molesting Buddies?!

You defebnding this Sick Bastard makes you Sick as well.

MaskedMagician1967
MaskedMagician1967 topcommenter

Robert, if you want to complain about political pandering to the undocumented and opposing enforcement of immigration laws, get a seance table and contact President Ronald Reagan and President Ulysses S. Grant and complain to them about the amnesty both men granted.

Grant signed the Amnesty Act of 1872. It forgave the Confederates for the Civil War. It should be noted that Grant was a Republican.

Reagan's Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 granted amnesty to any illegal immigrant in the United States prior to January 1, 1982 and is the basis for the current immigration proposal in Congress. It should be noted that Reagan was a Republican.

No Democratic President since the party's founding in 1792 has supported amnesty.

I know facts are a hard pill for you to swallow but get used to it.

toersbijnsc
toersbijnsc

@robert_graham @toersbijnsc Yes Robert I agree, there is too much political pandering and corruptive thinking on the part of politicians and lawmakers sworn to uphold the law; Although it is another subject I will elaborate on this -

Since 1986, nothing constructive has been done and now we are overwhelmed with a problem that is not easily dismissed by law and needs 3 things to come together - rule of law - incremental discretionary steps to allow permanency to those law biding - a probationary period after legalizing those without criminal records and proceed to allow citizenship once they complete their visa status satisfactorily.

No amnesty and everything according to the law but that won't happen because the DOJ is changing the rules daily to suit the political climate making it harder for law enforcement to do its job. Those that do not meet criteria should be deported and made to re-apply accordingly and start fresh.... just like the law says they can. Felonies excluded. If that is not acceptable, then change the laws.

ConcernedCitizenAZ
ConcernedCitizenAZ topcommenter

@MaskedMagician1967  With that background in convictions, why would Chris Simcox been given a "pass". There's more going on here that needs to be investigated, in "high" places, not the ordinary.

 
Phoenix Concert Tickets
Loading...