"No way, dude." he replied. "CDs are what my mom listens to in the car. Why would I want to do that? Also, like, a lot of the stuff I'm into isn't even available on MP3. Like I just found this record by this Japanese punk rock band called The Plastics, and there's no way to download this. It's just not out there."

Fair enough. But what about people my age, people who don't consider themselves record collectors? Are some of them suddenly returning to vinyl for nostalgic reasons? I called my pal Jim Minnick, a record collector and DJ who's been into records for as long as I have. "The upswing in DJs in clubs has a lot to do with why vinyl is making a comeback," Jim told me. "And a lot of people think vinyl has a warmer sound than digital recordings."

My friend John snorted when I repeated Jim's theory to him. "Everyone talks about clarity and warmth and how vinyl sounds better than digital," he said. "But that crackling sound of an old LP is how I used to hear music when I was first learning to listen to music. I like that sound."

Is the vinyl revival just a keen fad or the legitimate rejection of MP3s?
Is the vinyl revival just a keen fad or the legitimate rejection of MP3s?

Location Info


Record Revival

537 E. Osborn Rd.
Phoenix, AZ 85012

Category: Retail

Region: Central Phoenix

John, who's 50, doesn't feel nostalgic about record albums. He feels more committed when he listens to music on vinyl. "I have to look through a stack of LPs, choose one, and then get up and change the LP when side one is done playing," he said. "You don't get that interaction with an iPod shuffle or whatever, which goes on playing forever. I feel more connected to the music when I'm playing it on a record."

Most of John's vinyl comes, he says, from Zia Record Exchange and from thrift stores. His most recent score was a pretty clean copy of Molly Hatchet's Flirtin' with Disaster, which he had on cassette in the '70s and always wanted on vinyl. He's thinking about buying Boston's self-titled first album; it was the first LP he ever owned.

While we were talking, John's wife, Veronica, grabbed the phone. "My first-ever record was an Alpha Bits cereal box record," she said. "It was Bobby Sherman doing 'Julie Do Ya Love Me.' What was yours?"

I've known Roni since the fourth grade; I can't lie to her. "It was The Archies' Jingle Jangle album," I replied. "Summer of 1969."

"Oh," she said, and handed the phone back to John. "See?" John laughed. "Everyone remembers their first LP. Who remembers their first CD?"

Actually, I do — or at least I remember the first CD I ever saw. It was 1984, and I was managing a record store called Charts on the west side of town. A&M Records sent a CD copy of Quincy Jones' The Dude to my store. I hung it on the wall behind the register, and my staff and I made sarcastic comments about it whenever we walked past. We were outraged by the CD's list price of $18.98, more than twice the $8.98 list of new-release vinyl LPs at the time, and by its diminutive size.

"The cover art is too small," we sneered. "How are you supposed to clean your pot on that?"

"These will never catch on," we assured one another. "You have to buy a special machine to play it on."

Of course, we were wrong. Compact discs took over that year, and almost as quickly, it seems, have been eclipsed by digital downloads. CDs are going the way of the 8-track tape.

When my "special machine" died recently, I headed for one of the big-box stores for a replacement. None of the 20-ish clerks knew what I was talking about when I said I wanted to buy a new CD changer. I finally found one, tucked into a dark corner. I didn't like it — it was a Sanyo and too big to fit nicely into my record closet — but it was the only one they carried.

On my way to the checkout line, I passed a gleaming row of shiny silver turntables.

« Previous Page
My Voice Nation Help
Michael James
Michael James

Best article I've ever read on the vinyl revival. Usually they talk about how the sound is so much better on records. I'm one of those baby boomers that had to put a quarter on the arm of a BSR turntable during the 80s because the vinyl was made so poorly on every album the 1st song would skip. My first record was Partridge Family. - Family Album. I remember hearing my first CD on a $1000+ Bang & Olufson stereo at a store around 1986. It was Steve Winwood's Oh What The Night Can Do. It sounded terrible. The bass sounded tinny. (I know now the guy didn't know what he was doing.) I promised myself I would never buy a CD. I kept that promise until 1993 because they stopped making some albums on records, John Mellencamp's Whenever We Wanted was sold on CD not record. Then the CD bug hit me. It sounded great with the proper stereo system, no more pops and hisses. I now have 1500 CDs, and still have the 200+ LPs from my past and my old linear tracking turntable that sounds much better than the arm type ones. I play my turntable maybe once a year. Now my thoughts on why there's an LP revival. Baby Boomers don't remember how the sound truly was and don't remember how the album covers disintegrate. I forgot about the disintegration part until I looked at my albums recently and see the telltale circle of the cover and I even have a bunch of my albums in the audiophile plastic and it still happens. The younger generation never heard the pops and clicks. I also think the used CD stores mostly are behind it as well. Like the guy said in the article, LPs used to be $8.98 when a CD was $18.98. Guess which one made more profit? Now the new LPs are $18.98 and new CDs are $8.98. Guess which is making more profit now? When was the last time you bought a new stereo? Now people are buying turntables again, more profit.

Michael Brownlee
Michael Brownlee

This has been going on for years. Sheesh. As for why.....in my mind it's simple. Stealing music is hoarding. You can brag to the other 12 year olds on your IRC chat about the 180gb of music you have but what do you really have? I feel like the LP has always been the choice for QUALITY listening. Cd promised that but the reality is that CDs are about convenience. CD player in the car, DiscMan (remember those?) for on the go. CDs are dying because there's no allure and the true convenience is streaming/iTunes/online music stores these days. But as the CD continues to be replaced by files there's been a groundswell of individuals that seek more than portable music. So back comes the LP. Even after the labels stopped pressing them the demand was there. But since no/very little new music was being pressed it was collectors who created demand. People my age who grew up throwing entire pay checks at Zia's probably feel as I do, that portable music is great for its convenience but lacks the tactile experience we grew up on. I , for one, am happy to see the LP coming back and continue to buy new releases on vinyl. My daughter too, has caught the bug and her small but growing collection includes Lady Gaga, Imagine Dragons, Frankie Rose and Linda Ronstadt. I've tried to instill in her the magic of the record store and the magic of the LP. I'm succeeding so far. It's got nothing to do with being a Hipster, that's a cop out used by 30 year old guys who play video games 12 hours a day and live with their parents.

Pamela Stone Vozza
Pamela Stone Vozza

Matt, not everyone is a hipster poser - my 7th grader is fascinated with vinyl because it's DIFFERENT - it's not part of her experience of growing up and listening to music. She's enthralled with indie music and all things vintage / retro because they don't look or sound like anything commonplace. Nothing wrong with that! Personally, I'm happy she finds retro so appealing instead of following her age demographics and listening to talentless props like Kesha or talented singers who choose to appeal to the lowest common denominator like Miley!


I love vinyl. My only gripe is that many new releases are $30 ! Did the record industry learn nothing over the last 15 years? They price gouged us with CD's and eventually people found a better way. Now they have something in Vinyl where they can actually make money again and again they are jacking up the price. The new releases should be around $15 so more people can get into this revival.

Matthew Meyers
Matthew Meyers

metal-head have been buying and distributing vinyl since it's inception!!! this article is about hipsters (POSEURS!!!)


Long live vinyl!  I'll never give it up.

Nikki Anam Cara
Nikki Anam Cara

Still have lots of mine but no interest in pulling out the turntable. Scratches, skips and pops in my music have no appeal...and I don't need a surface to clean pot anymore. Damn I'm old.


If your vinyl is skipping and popping it would indicate the record was mistreated of created with a flaw.

I have 1000s of records and pops are not something you'll hear in my dj set.

Phoenix Concert Tickets

Concert Calendar

  • April
  • Sat
  • Sun
  • Mon
  • Tue
  • Wed
  • Thu
  • Fri