On Russell Pearce's Bigot Bill, Republicans Blink: SB 1070/HB 2632 Down But Not Out
Russell Pearce, foiled for now by GOP backbenchers unwilling to toe his hate-Hispanics line
What an embarrassing day for the Republican leadership in the state House. Though House GOPers were prepared this afternoon to ram through state Senator Russell Pearce's anti-Hispanic apartheid bill SB 1070/HB 2632, to the surprise of almost everyone in the chamber, its House sponsor Rep. David Gowan suddenly moved that the bill be "retained on the calendar," leaving it limbo for the time being.
Gowan was apparently stopped short by the reluctance of some of his fellow tuskers to sign off on Pearce's dream anti-immigrant legislation.
House GOP spokesman Paul Boyer was flabbergasted, and admitted he didn't know what had happened.
"It could be back tomorrow, or next week," he stated.
Currently, the bill is not on the agenda for March 18, so next week seems likely, for now.
"Some Republicans had peeled off from it," Allen commented afterward, "and they didn't have the votes today to do it."
Rep. Daniel Patterson, a Tucson Democrat who has been vocal in his opposition to the Pearce measure, agreed with Allen's analysis.
"I suspect the Republican leadership will try to torture their members into voting for this thing," he cracked. "They'll be waterboarding whoever isn't going to vote for it. But whoever's got issues with the bill, I hope they hold firm. It's a bad bill."
Indeed, you don't have to be out there hugging immigrant babies to be against Pearce's trainwreck legislation. The bill would make it a trespassing offense to be in Arizona illegally, though such a measure would be unconstitutional, as the U.S. Constitution and the courts have long held that the federal government has plenary power over immigration.
The legislation would also force all law enforcement agencies to pursue immigration violations, without providing any funding for training. Those agencies that do not enforce immigration law to the fullest extent would be subject to devastating lawsuits, brought by any nut with an axe to grind.
In addition, cops would have broad authority to arrest without warrant anyone they believe to be removable from the country. And they and any agent of the state, or a county, a city or any other political subdivision would have to make a "reasonable effort" to determine the immigration status of anyone they come in contact with.
Get the This Week's Top Stories Newsletter
Every week we collect the latest news, music and arts stories — along with film and food reviews and the best things to do this week — so that you’ll never miss Phoenix New Times' biggest stories.