Perhaps the truest line ever written about Bruce Springsteen appeared in Village Voice scribe Robert Christgau's 1975 review of Born to Run: "Springsteen may well turn out to be one of those rare self-conscious primitives who gets away with it." As Christgau implies, Springsteen isn't the sort of fellow who simply empties out his head, confident that whatever his skull contains is worthy of public display. Instead, he thinks about which topics to tackle, thinks about the best angles of attack, thinks about the ways particular works fit into his overall oeuvre, and thinks about whether they are in keeping with his reputation as the working stiff's pal, the common man's chronicler, the average Joe's defender, the bar dweller's perfect rocker. That's not to say he's entirely lacking in spontaneity. But the odds are strong that, after he does something off-the-cuff, he wonders what the hell he could have been thinking.
With The Rising, a meditation on the World Trade Center attacks and their aftermath, Springsteen multiplies these characteristics by a power of 9/11. He's among the few major performers who could release such a disc and not be charged with exploitation, and he's probably the only one who could garner so much mainstream media attention for taking on the challenge. If Ted Koppel had asked ABC to let him assemble an extended-length Nightline centering on, say, an exclusive interview with Ariel Sharon, the network's chieftains probably would have reacted by restarting negotiations with David Letterman but they were happy to stretch out the program when the Boss came calling.
Still, Springsteen's determination to assist in the nation's healing process, laudable though it is, proves too much for even a musician of his prodigious gifts. Several of the tracks here are as moving as anything he's written, but many others are plodding, and sometimes even a bit banal more Oprah-atic than operatic. Part of the problem is Brendan O'Brien's production, which is smooth, safe and so Triple-A-radio friendly that it practically embalms the E Street Band, back on a Springsteen studio album for the first time since 1984's Born in the U.S.A. "Mary's Place," the most nostalgic new creation, is intended as a showcase for Clarence Clemons' wailing saxophone, the guitars of Nils Lofgren and Steven Van Zandt, the keyboarding of Roy Bittan and Danny Federici, and the rhythm section of Garry Tallent and Max Weinberg. And, to a modest degree, it turns out that way. But aside from a couplet that pays unintentional tribute to Pink ("We're gonna have a party/Tell me how do we get this thing started"), the number feels labored and lacking in immediacy: E Street under glass.
More troubling, however, is Springsteen's lyrical tendency to dilute the horror and sadness of his subject matter with knee-jerk infusions of standard-issue uplift. "Lonesome Day" contains frequent repetitions of the reassuring phrase "It's all right." "Into the Fire" is loaded down with familiar axioms ("May your strength give us strength/May your faith give us faith"). "Waitin' on a Sunny Day," "Countin' on a Miracle" and "Let's Be Friends (Skin to Skin)" sport titles that make clear their elevating intentions, and "Worlds Apart," an attempt at cultural détente that co-stars Asif Ali Khan, recalls the recent work of Sting, which is never good. These efforts can't be described as complete washouts, but neither do they transcend the obvious.
"The Rising" earns a better fate mainly because of its sheer catchiness, attained via a quasi-gospel arrangement that makes the most of its churchy prose ("May their precious blood bind me, Lord, as I stand before your fiery light"). And while "My City of Ruins" employs very similar imagery (inspired by the deterioration of Asbury Park, New Jersey), its prayerful melody, initially heard by the masses as part of the telethon America: A Tribute to Heroes, imbues his words with grandeur. The finest composition, however, may be the smallest. "You're Missing" is little more than a catalogue of everyday items shirts in the closet, shoes in the hall that can be found in their usual places. But when Springsteen punctuates this simple roster by mentioning the one thing that's gone (the man of the house), the effect is emotionally devastating.
As "You're Missing" demonstrates, Springsteen still can hit tremendous heights, and, throughout his latest recording, he emerges as serious, sincere and empathetic. But with a handful of notable exceptions, The Rising likely will be remembered more for its good intentions than for its artistic achievements. Next time around, Springsteen would be well advised not to have too much to think.
Get the ICYMI: Today's Top Stories Newsletter Our daily newsletter delivers quick clicks to keep you in the know
Catch up on the day's news and stay informed with our daily digest of the most popular news, music, food and arts stories in Phoenix, delivered to your inbox Monday through Friday.