A Whale of a Tale
Spouting praise: I spent an hour or so enjoying your article on whales ("Survival," David Holthouse, October 11). I want to compliment your story for being well-written and taking me to a place that I most likely will never visit. I was completely intrigued by the people in the story, their lives and the description of the characteristics of the people. They are living a life that most will never experience, and I found it to be an inspiration of human fortitude and the environmental desperation that is always present, but always hidden. I am sure that this was an adventure of a lifetime and I am grateful that such accounts can be shared.
I'm just a Bill: Steven L. Toth describes Bill Maher as "a stupid prick who thinks he has something important to say" (Letters, October 11). In all the years I've been on this planet, I cannot think of a more perfect illustration of the pot calling the kettle black. Mr. Toth, if your head wasn't so far up your ass, you'd realize that Bill Maher intended his remarks as a criticism of the previous (Clinton) administration and the military top brass, not President Bush or the men and women on the front line. You would also have noticed that many in the media, including some prominent right-wing talk-show hosts, have expressed their concern about Maher's treatment. Although many disagree with Maher's comments, all defend his right to make them; some have also wondered aloud if a media clamp-down on controversy means that they could be next.
Freedom of speech (together with a free press/media) is one of the things that makes this country great and the envy of the rest of the world. To attempt to deny others this basic right because you happen to disagree with what they say, while at the same time calling yourself a patriot, is not just ludicrous, it's completely hypocritical. I suggest you read the U.S. Constitution!
His father's son: I, too, agree with Bill Maher that it does not take a hero to launch a missile strike from 2,000 miles away. I also agree with him that no "coward" would give up his life in a suicidal mission in support of his ideological beliefs. Maher's financial contributors, however, were right in threatening to pull their support unless he apologize since they advertised for the purpose of selling goods and services. Sales would have otherwise suffered in the war hysteria being generated by the mainstream press and George W. Bush.
I will not support Mr. Bush's war. Bush's call to war lacks credibility because although he lost the popular vote, he got himself appointed as president by his daddy's and his daddy's boss's appointees to the Supreme Court. I find no moral fiber in his ascension to the presidency. I do not support his political strategy of killing and terrorizing innocent people in his plan of revenge. The Taliban may have rejoiced in the September 11 assault, but they are innocent of the decision to do it. They may support guerrilla warfare against the foreigners who now control Palestine/Israel, but there is no evidence they supported the terrorist assault of September 11. I am not ready for a good-old-boy down-home Southern lynching party, even if it is against a foreigner.
So, Mr. Maher, even though you must balance your freedom of speech against the economic interests of your advertisers, you have nonetheless given voice to the citizens among us who do not believe we should begin a global war against Baby Bush's targets.
Torrents of Arabia
Extra credit: I've never heard of Jack Shaheen, but I would like him to know he's not alone in the discussion of dis-portrayals of Arabs ("Arabian Knight," Robert Wilonsky, October 11). I was previously scheduled to speak to several junior high classes about Hispanic heritage shortly after the September 11 events took place. While discussion started on the aforementioned topic, it quickly changed gears to touch on culture and perception within the context of the September 11 events. I actually spoke to the classes about the differences between the portrayals of the Arabs in Three Kings as opposed to other movies, i.e., True Lies and others. The students were amazing! While their perceptions were strongly formed based on the numerous Hollywood portrayals, they were able to discern and speak to the differences regarding the Three Kings portrayal. We then had a good discussion on caution about forming perceptions based on the actions of a few individuals with a specific agenda versus the majority of people just trying to make a living and raise a family. I'm pleased to read about Mr. Shaheen's unwavering commitment to combating the ignorance and wish him the best of luck!
Touching news: Wow! is what I have to say in response to your cover story about my favorite rock band Jimmy Eat World ("Brave New World," Bob Mehr, September 27). I think it's the best article I have ever read about the boys. I really enjoyed how you went into detail about their past and the week you spent with them. It was truly a story with a happy ending.
I am a fellow Mesa resident and have been following the band for three years now. I do my own sort of marketing for them, trying to get my friends to listen to them and talking them up. They truly changed the way I think of, view, and listen to music. It's the first time I have ever felt the music deep inside. Sorry if this may sound weird to you, but I can't really explain in words how much their music touches me. From one fan to the next, I hope you can understand what I mean. Thank you again for sharing their story.
You're welcome: I've been waiting for someone to write a piece like that on Jimmy Eat World for a long, long time. Thank you.
Fan club: As a 30-year-old, I don't fit into the fan categories of female teens or guys who don't want to be on the football team. But I can't remember the last time I bought a new CD and listened to it over and over again, as I did with Bleed American. It's a shame that this extremely talented and independent-minded band didn't get the attention it deserved with Clarity. However, it has been pure joy to hear them on the radio, see them on television and get all the press coverage they are finally receiving. They've worked hard and deserve all the best. Okay, now I'm gushing like a teenage girl!
Jim-dandy: I just finished your cover story about Jimmy Eat World and was compelled to write. It was absolutely wonderful! By far the most revealing article on the band yet, and the best article from you I've read. New Times hasn't had a truly great music story on the cover in ages, so thanks for bringing back some former glory to the mag!
Get the Weekly Newsletter
Our weekly feature stories, movie reviews, calendar picks and more - minus the newsprint and sent directly to your inbox.