Master of Her Domain
Maricopa County schools chief Sandra Dowling has been on a power trip for 11 years, and only two groups can stop her: the Arizona Legislature or the electorate.
I hope someone is successful -- and soon. But if history is an indication, Dowling will continue on indefinitely. In her three elections for the Maricopa County Superintendent of Schools post, she's never had a strong opponent. County officials ignore her. And legislators, who could curb her power, are afraid of a political hot potato.
Most people consider the position of county schools superintendent a dubious job. You appoint people to fill a few school board vacancies, maybe review some test scores, drop by some schools. Not a lot of prestige. But most people don't realize that the county superintendent wears two hats: one as superintendent, the other as the sole board member of the Maricopa County Regional School District, which runs alternative schools.
During her time in office, Sandra Dowling has turned that second hat into a crown. She's queen of all she surveys, and her turf is not insignificant. While other school boards have at least three members, Dowling reigns supreme over dozens of employees, hundreds of students and a $14 million budget.
Political scientists should apply for grants to study this woman: She is a rare example of an autocrat thriving in American government, a Petri dish of violations of the public trust, unchecked.
A few years back, I catalogued some of Dowling's less becoming actions ("Board Games," August 28, 1997), which included nepotism, salary inequities, frivolous hirings, and her use of county funds to earn an unnecessary degree. Much of what was going on in the office was not technically illegal, but it was improper, and Dowling had sole discretion over all of it. And there were questions of legality, too: The state Attorney General's Office launched an investigation into consulting trips Dowling took at county expense.
Dowling declined a request for an interview.
Experts and observers interviewed for "Board Games" suggested that the Arizona Legislature change the law to require county school districts to have multiple-person boards.
But state Senator John Huppenthal, a Chandler Republican who chairs the Senate Education Committee, disagreed. He told me he had met with Dowling a few times, and she assured him she would survey employees, improve morale, clean up her act.
Two and a half years later, not much has changed at Dowling's shop.
The attorney general's investigation into Dowling's office is ongoing. At least one member of Dowling's family, her son Dennis, still works for the district. Last year, many district employees got a small (a couple of percentage points) raise. Yet two employees cozy with Dowling, assistant Dick Bryce (Dowling's right-hand man, often referred to as the guy who carries her purse) and personnel director Rexanne Meredith (wife of Jim, of AzScam fame), received raises of more than $10,000 each.
And last month, a national homelessness think tank released a study questioning the validity of Dowling's pet project, the Thomas J. Pappas school for the homeless.
Huppenthal says he's never seen results of the employee surveys Dowling told him she would conduct; he admits he's not sure they exist. He's spoken with state Senator Tom Smith, a Scottsdale Republican and former member of the Scottsdale School Board, about finally introducing legislation that would create a multiple-person board for the county district.
Huppenthal says he's more receptive to the idea now. Easy for him to say. He's leaving the Senate to run for Congress this fall. So the task falls to Smith, who vows to work on the legislation over the summer.
Smith says he knows of nothing Dowling has done that breaks the law, per se, but he's concerned after speaking with former district employees who catalogued possible misdeeds. "I think one person can certainly abuse their power with no problem," he says.
Any legislation Smith introduces won't be considered until January 2001. Before then, Dowling must face reelection.
So far, it looks like the typically easy road for her. Dowling's only opposition to date is Tim Redburn, who has taught in the Regional School District for more than 20 years. I spoke with Redburn from his farm in the west Valley, where he was installing an irrigation ditch during his spring break. He is earnest and has some good ideas about increasing the district's vocational education programs, but Redburn is a political and administrative novice. And he's a Democrat in a heavily Republican county. He's not even sure he can get the 40,000 signatures required to get on the ballot.
He's also unwilling to criticize Dowling -- at all -- making it difficult to expect voters to choose him over the experienced incumbent.
"I don't get into ups and downs and fights and ins and outs," Redburn says, although he admits, "I know some of the things that she's done because I've been there for so long."
All he'll say is: "She's unchallenged over the years and I want to challenge that office, and I think I can do the job."
Admirable? Yes. Promising? No.
The woman who should be challenging Dowling isn't. Her name is Althie Wood and she worked for the Regional School District for six years.
Still under 30, Wood looks like she could be a student. But she's accomplished for any age. She taught at the Pappas school for a year, then spent another year at one of the district's high schools before being asked to help create a middle school. She did that, then served as principal.
Wood is not afraid to talk about her experience at the district. Much of it was good, she says. In a more structured, traditional environment, she never would have been given such opportunities so young. But she's critical of the way Dowling runs the district, and she's no fan of the Pappas school.
Wood was hired in 1992 as Pappas' only high school teacher. She began with half a dozen students in a single room; by Christmas, she had 65 students in a single room.
"When I said, 'Well, what am I supposed to teach if I'm the only teacher?' I was told, 'Well, you're certified in English, so teach that. And history's kinda close to English -- teach that.'"
Wood recalls, "It was fine at first, because I researched and did my own curriculum.... But it got complicated when, at Christmastime, I had kids put in who only needed a half credit to graduate, so they only needed economics, so I'd pull an economics curriculum from somewhere. And then someone needed geometry -- so it got pretty difficult."
One of the most frustrating aspects of the job, she says, was the constant interruption by Dowling, who seemed to have more of an interest in getting good press than educating kids.
"The teachers were told that the week prior to Christmas needed to be blocked off, and there could not be instruction, because that week was the week that corporate sponsors were coming in and business people were coming in to give donations and there had to be parties.... My high school students could not afford a week" without instruction.
Similar interruptions went on throughout the year. "As well-intended as everyone is, it was a constant disruption to learning."
Wood left the district when she was told she would be reassigned to Pappas -- this time as principal. She wanted to stick with high school kids, and Pappas focuses mainly on elementary education.
She found a job as assistant principal at Saguaro High School in Scottsdale. Wood says she misses working with disadvantaged kids, but does not miss the Regional District's bureaucracy. She actually took out an election packet, planning to run against Dowling, but changed her mind. She's finishing her Ph.D. in the fall, and an election didn't mix well with her plans.
Too bad. Wood is a Republican, and while she's never run for office, her administrative background would have given her a leg up over Redburn.
On the bright side, Redburn does support the multi-person board concept, something Dowling's pooh-poohed in the past.
"I've had thoughts on that.... It would take a good push to get that changed," Redburn says. "I've always thought that one opinion is a dictatorship."
Contact Amy Silverman at 602-229-8443 or at her online address: email@example.com
Get the Weekly Newsletter