TRAYS OF OUR LIVES
Palm Grove Food Court, Dial Corporate Center, 1850 North Central, Phoenix, 207-7107. Hours: Breakfast and Lunch, Monday through Friday, 6:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m. Eating out hasn't always been my occupation. In my former life, in fact, eating out was how I escaped from the rigors of work. I always looked forward to letting somebody else make my meal. Especially at lunch. Even when I had trouble scraping two nickels together, I couldn't bear to bring a sack lunch to work. It was just too depressing. It was depressing to shop Sunday night, hunting barren supermarket shelves for a week's worth of lunch ingredients. It was depressing to make lunch in the morning before I left. It was depressing to think about lunch during the morning. It was depressing to actually eat it. And it was depressing to realize that I'd be repeating the same routine the next day. So I'd go to a cafeteria, about the cheapest lunchtime option around. The food may not have been particularly compelling, and I really couldn't spare the 20 bucks a week to support my habit. But the hour away from my desk restored my sanity, cheered me up and gave me the courage to go back to work in the afternoon. If you work in downtown Phoenix and resist packing a sack lunch, you could probably use some cheering up, too. Unless you have access to a company credit card, lunchtime is not apt to be the high point of your day. So I checked out some neighborhood cafeterias to see if something other than the 5 o'clock bell could give meaning to a Monday-to-Friday office existence. Lunch at Palm Grove certainly does. It gives hungry workers more than a noontime break. It's even good enough to make them enthusiastic about getting up and going to work in the first place. Without a doubt, this is the king of Valley cafeterias.
Forget your mental picture of a typical cafeteria: a bleak warehouse atmosphere, chairs that make your back ache and a food line staffed by women in hairnets, stirring scary-looking caldrons bubbling with who knows what. This is the first cafeteria in which I've ever felt underdressed. That's because the Dial Corporation proprietors have spent big bucks making it look better than 90 percent of this town's full-service restaurants. The experience starts the moment you step out of the elevator. You stroll down a marble-floored hallway, lined with thick wallpaper and gilt-framed art. The dining room features lots of dark wood and well-padded captain's chairs. (There's also a shaded outdoor pavilion, where the smokers congregate.) The employees are equally classy. They inform customers about daily specials, remind them to validate their parking ticket and unfailingly call everyone "Sir" or "Ma'am." I was so bewitched, I half-expected someone to refold my napkin when I went to the rest room. And the food casts the same kind of spell. Take the chicken gumbo soup. The kitchen obviously used more than a can opener to fashion this wonderful broth, thick with chicken, sausage and okra. Or check out the caesar salad. In most Valley restaurants, you're as likely to meet a genuine caesar salad as you are to meet Caesar himself. But Palm Grove's counter help is constantly whipping up fresh batches of the real thing, right down to the homemade croutons and anchovies. This is a cafeteria? You'd hardly know it from the first-rate tortellini, topped with a simple marinara sauce loaded with a robust tomato punch. Mostaccioli Bolognese is another substantial pasta option good enough to be brought to your table by a server. And it comes with freshly baked garlic-cheese toast that hasn't been sitting around under a tanning lamp since the midmorning break. Sandwiches exhibit similar quality. The turkey in the turkey- provolone hero is honest-to-God turkey breast, not some processed fowl. Even the basic tuna sandwich could lift your spirits. Like everything else, the pizza sports a right-out-of-the-oven freshness. The slices are huge, the crust chewy, and toppings like salami and banana peppers hit the target. There's nothing institutional about desserts, either. The cranapple pie here is the same one served in Gabriel's, the Dial Corporation's swanky restaurant down the corridor from the cafeteria. Chocolate mousse pie has a real chocolate bite, with none of that waxy texture that betrays other cafeteria versions. Sure, Palm Grove is just a cafeteria. But it's tray chic.
Plaza View, APS Building, 400 North Fifth Street, Phoenix, 250-3380. Hours: Breakfast, Monday through Friday, 6:45 to 8:30 a.m.; Lunch, Monday through Friday, 11 a.m. to 1 p.m.
If Palm Grove is king of cafeterias, Plaza View could be the crown prince. This APS facility is hardly what I expected. I've always thought that what APS does best is siphon unconscionable amounts of cash each month from my checking account. Now I'm not sure. Maybe the company ought to consider converting the Palo Verde nuclear plant to a lunch spot. I've even come up with a slogan: "Get it while it's hot." The company cafeteria is spiffy clean, in an institutional way. High ceilings and walls of windows on three sides make the place airy and light. There's a soothing view of a big, grassy lawn and the tops of palm trees in Arizona Center's garden complex. Comfortable, cushioned black-metal-frame chairs make lingering a plausible plan of inaction. Lunchers who enjoy controlling their own portions have plenty of opportunity. The serviceable, 18-cents-an-ounce salad bar with all the usual greenery suspects even contains one surprise: white asparagus. That means you could load up on a pound of this wonderful vegetable for $2.88. My advice: Take some home. The ladle-it-yourself soup-in-a-vat turned up another surprise--an excellent, thickly stocked, homemade-tasting three-bean soup. Plaza View's offerings don't match the variety of Palm Grove's, but you shouldn't have trouble taking what it dishes out. One entree special, priced under four bucks, is featured daily. My noontime visit coincided with a hearty Mongolian firepot, a big mound of noodles topped with bok choy, strips of red, green and yellow pepper, onions, celery, carrots and substantial chunks of grilled, white-meat chicken. There's a daily broiler special, too. Ours was a tasty chicken parmigiana, a grilled breast on toasted sourdough, gilded with bacon, cheese and marinara sauce. A 12-ounce soft drink comes along as part of a very reasonable $2.99 tag.
Choose carefully at the slow-moving sandwich counter (an extra worker wouldn't be a bad idea) and you can do quite well for yourself. Forget the nondescript luncheon meats and ask for the vegetarian: thin slices of saut‚ed eggplant, squash and peppers, served in a fresh, whole wheat loaf. Even an old standby like the tuna melt on grilled sourdough has genuine appeal. But don't bother with the burger, a rubbery disk. It's clear that nobody spent the morning grinding up beef and forming it into patties. The frozen French fries also aren't worth the calories. And you can confidently skip the caesar salad. It's pretty pathetic, especially compared to Palm Grove's artful creation. The greenery sits wrapped in plastic, with a container of blah caesar dressing nestled alongside. Desperate for something sweet? Carrot cake and chocolate cake will give you a sugar boost, but little else. Have an M&M-studded chocolate chip cookie instead. Plaza View has persuaded me to modify my view of APS. Now let's see the company get rid of its monthly "meter reading" charge, a rip-off of $15, and I can experience a complete change of heart. Sutton's, Superior Court, 101 West Jefferson, Phoenix, 254-0727. Hours: Breakfast and Lunch, Monday through Friday, 6:30 a.m. to 4 p.m.
Order in this court? Not on your life. Having trouble remembering why you used to hate your high school cafeteria? Take a trip to Sutton's and relive the bad old days. First, the look. The place is completely charmless--bare walls, plastic stacking chairs, linoleum floor and cheap tables with fake wood tops. It looks like the setting for a James Cagney prison movie. It's not much of a stretch to picture the place filled with rows of inmates in leg irons, banging away with tin cups, protesting the awful fare. Actually, you may learn more about leg irons during an hour here than you ever wanted to know. That's because you're lunching in the company of court personnel: attorneys, jurors, witnesses, law enforcement officers. I got to hear sheriff's deputies at the next table having a spirited conversation about the pros and cons of chaining inmates. Leg irons are much too good for whoever is responsible for the contents of the chafing trays here. This is the first cafeteria I've ever eaten in that may be violating the Geneva Convention. Exhibit A: soups. A gelatinous cream of chicken wins this year's pullet surprise. Chicken soup is supposed to cure whatever ails you. This model just scares germs to death. Tomato rice soup, a watery, tasteless broth, should stay locked behind bars. Sutton's has given me a great idea for a terrifying Halloween outfit. Next year, I'm going to dress up as the turkey teriyaki. It's frightening cubes of processed meat, paired with broccoli and canned green beans steamed to the point of disintegration. You don't need much in the way of teeth to eat this, just courage. The enchiladas make fasting a noontime option worth considering. They're a cheese-glopped mess, served with mortarlike refried beans and tortillas that taste like they rode along with Pancho Villa. The grilled pastrami and Swiss sandwich looks harmless enough. But it's got enough sodium to be a salt lick. Order this and you'll be chained to the water cooler all afternoon. The Ortega burger is not named after our former chief of police. Still, he might be called in to investigate. Anyone finding evidence of beefy taste or juices inside this bun should probably be working for Robert Shapiro. After that feat, discovering an alibi for O.J. ought to be a cinch. Instead of prison, Superior Court judges might consider sending convicts to Sutton's. That's what I call a deterrent.
Get the Dining Newsletter
The week's top local food news and events, plus interviews with chefs and restaurant owners, dining tips, and a peek at our print review.