Phoenix New Times, LLC
Jay Bennett

She & Him: Volume 2

Jay Bennett | March 23, 2010 | 12:35pm
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • email
  • Print Article
AA

Artist: She & Him

Title: Volume 2
Release date: March 23
Label: Merge

My editor has claimed this project a triumph for no other reason than I've chosen the new over the old -- sort of. See, I told Martin Cizmar a while back that I wanted to review tonight's Ray Davies concert. I love the Kinks. They're one of my all-time favorite bands and I've never seen the Davies perform in person.

But about two weeks ago, I told Martin that I didn't want to go Ray Davies anymore because I'd rather go see Pierced Arrows tonight at the Sail Inn. Martin was astounded that I'd chosen a "new" band (P.A.'s core members are actually older than the Kinks frontman) over hearing a rock 'n' roll dinosaur sing "Waterloo Sunset" for the billionth time. He declared the decision a major breakthrough for me.
There may have been a couple of factors in my decision, but no one needs to tell Martin that. Actually, he may be correct, to some extent. Because in the past, I might've said, "No way. I'm not missing Ray Davies." Anyway, if you go to see Ray tonight, let me know tomorrow about the show, k?

It hasn't happened often so far this year, but it happened with today's entry in the Nothing Not New canon. I really expected the 43 minutes it would take to listen to the new She & Him record to be full of wincing and eye-rolling on my part. I was wrong. It's 43 minutes of some of the most likable music I've heard this year.

In case you didn't know, She & Him is the collaboration between indie-music star M. Ward and actress Zooey Deschanel, who has a made career out of playing Manic Pixie Dream Girls. New Times contributor Craig Outhier made a pretty compelling case for her viability as a musical act. Still, I expected this musical project to be an extension of her typically annoying onscreen persona. But for the most part, it's not.

The best part about it? It's not indie pop. To call it that would be an insult. It's pure pop. You know, the kind of pop that now people like. It's got real melodies, real songcraft, real structure, and is a real good time. 

She & Him is a latter-day Captain & Tennille or Carpenters (and I mean that in a good way). I'm not saying Deschanel is as good a singer as either Toni Tennille or Karen Carpenter. She's not, but I do like her voice, and it has that sunny, 1970s lite-rock quality. It's remarkably unaffected, as so many indie-rock singers' voices are.

M. Ward is clearly having the time of his life writing, arranging, performing, and producing these songs. I dig his strong grasp of 1970s California folk-pop and country-pop. And She & Him is no wink-and-a-nudge exercise in musical irony. It's earnestly but seemingly effortlessly put together. I look forward to Volume 3.

Best song: "In the Sun" and "Home." But most of the songs are good.
Rotation: Heavy
Deja vu: Well-dressed white people smiling and lip-synching happy songs on any given 1970s TV variety show.
I'd rather listen to: Lee Hazlewood and Nancy Sinatra
Grade: A-


Wanna hear some of the music I've been listening to this year? Check out the first Nothing Not New podcast.

"Nothing Not New" is a yearlong project in which New Times editorial operations manager Jay Bennett, a 40-year-old music fan and musician, will listen only to music released in 2010. Each Monday through Friday, he will listen to one new record (no best ofs, reissues, or concert recordings) and write about it. Why? Because in the words of his editor, Martin Cizmar, he suffers from "aesthetic atrophy," a wasting away of one's ability to embrace new and different music as one ages. Read more about this all-too-common ailment here.

The "Nothing Not New" Archives

March 22 -- Broken Bells: Broken Bells (C+)

March 19 -- Locksley: Be In Love (B)
March 18 -- jj: jj no. 3 (C-)
March 17 -- Xiu Xiu: Dear God, I Hate Myself (D+)
March 16 -- Drive By Truckers: The Big To-Do (B-)
March 15 -- April Smith and the Great Picture Show: Songs for a Sinking Ship (C)

March 12 -- The Morning Benders: Big Echo (C+)
March 11 -- Black Rebel Motorcycle Club: Beat the Devil's Tattoos (B)
March 10 -- Acrassicauda: Only the Dead See the End of War (C-)
March 9 -- Titus Andronicus: The Monitor (B+)
March 8 -- Ted Leo and the Pharmacists: The Brutalist Bricks (A)

March 5 -- Liars: Sisterworld (A-)
March 4 -- Gorillaz: Plastic Beach (A-)
March 3 -- Johnny Cash: American VI: Ain't No Grave (B+)
March 2 -- High on Fire: Snakes for the Divine (C)
March 1 -- Joanna Newsom: Have One on Me (C)

Feb. 26 -- Freeway & Jake One: The Stimulus Package (D)
Feb. 25 -- Past Lives: Tapestry of Webs (B-)
Feb. 24 -- Shout Out Louds: Work (B)
Feb. 23 -- Brian Jonestown Massacre: Who Killed Sgt. Pepper? (B+)
Feb. 22 -- Shearwater: The Golden Archipelago (D+)

Feb. 19 -- The Strange Boys: Be Brave (B+)
Feb. 18 -- Tindersticks: Falling Down a Mountain (A)
Feb. 17 -- Lightspeed Champion: Life Is Sweet! Nice to Meet You (C-)
Feb. 16 -- Adam Green: Minor Love (B-)
Feb. 15 -- Juliana Hatfield: Peace & Love (B+)

Feb. 12 -- Massive Attack: Heligoland (C-)
Feb. 11 -- The Watson Twins: Talking to You, Talking to Me (C-)
Feb. 10 -- Hot Chip: One Life Stand (B+)
Feb. 9 -- You Say Party! We Say Die!: XXXX (B+)
Feb. 8 -- Allison Moorer: Crows (B)

Feb. 5 -- Joe Pug: Messenger (C)
Feb. 4 -- The Soft Pack: The Soft Pack (A)
Feb. 3 -- Polysics: Absolute Polysics (B-)
Feb. 2 -- Pierced Arrows: Descending Shadows (A-)
Feb. 1 -- The Brunettes: Paper Doll (B-)

Jan. 29 -- Basia Bulat: Heart of My Own (C)
Jan. 28 -- Priestess: Prior to the Fire (B)
Jan. 27 -- The Magnetic Fields: Realism (B)
Jan. 26 -- Four Tet: There Is Love in You (D)
Jan. 25 -- Delphic: Acolyte (C+)

Jan. 22 -- The Hot Rats: Turn Ons (B+)
Jan. 21 -- Los Campesinos!: Romance Is Boring (A-)
Jan. 20 -- Midlake: The Courage of Others (D-)
Jan. 19 -- Laura Veirs: July Flame (B+)
Jan. 18 -- Beach House: Teen Dream (C)

Jan. 15 -- Charlotte Gainsbourg: IRM (B)
Jan. 14 -- OK Go: Of the Blue Colour of the Sky (D)
Jan. 13 -- Eels: End Times (A-)
Jan. 12 -- Spoon: Transference (B)
Jan. 11 -- Editors: In This Light and On This Evening (D+)

Jan. 8 -- Surfer Blood: Astro Coast (B+)
Jan. 7 -- Yeasayer: Odd Blood (C-)
Jan. 6 -- Cold War Kids: Behave Yourself EP (B+)

If you like this story, consider signing up for our email newsletters.

SHOW ME HOW

X
Newsletters
All-access pass to the top stories, events and offers around town.
  • No Thanks
  • Sign Up
X

SUCCESS!

You have successfully signed up for your selected newsletter(s) - please keep an eye on your mailbox, we're movin' in!

Jan. 5 -- Vampire Weekend: Contra (D+)
Jan. 4 -- Texas Tornados: Está Bueno! (B)

Jan. 1 -- Scanners: Submarine (B-) 
  • Music
  • Music News

Use of this website constitutes acceptance of our terms of use, our cookies policy, and our privacy policy

©2019 Phoenix New Times, LLC. All rights reserved.