Two brave women, aged 16 and 20, showed up at the Mesa Police Station on October 30 with a shocking tale: They'd been sexually abused by their stepfather, Edgar Garcia, for the past 12 years.
They told of a series of rapes and molestations that began when the 20-year-old was "8 or 9," and the younger sister was 4. Garcia, now 32, would have been 20 during the first incidents. They described being forced to submit to intercourse, oral sex, and unwanted touching at various times over the years.
On Tuesday, following extensive police interviews, the 16-year-old made a "confrontation call" with Garcia, now 32. Garcia admitted to having sex with both girls, telling the teen "he was sorry and that he was being stupid," court documents say.
Mesa police arrested him on Wednesday at his home near Broadway and Sossaman roads.
We Believe Local Journalism is Critical to the Life of a City
Engaging with our readers is essential to Phoenix New Times's mission. Make a financial contribution or sign up for a newsletter, and help us keep telling Phoenix's stories with no paywalls.
Support Our Journalism
In detention and after being read his rights, Garcia confessed that he'd seen his stepdaughters as "sexually attractive to him" for about 12 years, records state. He downplayed some of his actions, but he reportedly said plenty to incriminate himself, including adding several incidents the girls hadn't mentioned.
His rebuttals sound horrifying and unbelievable, as in, "He said he did touch her vagina with his hand when she was 9 but he did not remember her covering her face with a pillow." And "he said that the blister occurred before he began rubbing on her vagina with his hand."
He also reportedly admitted to various sexual acts including receiving oral sex from the younger woman when she was 10.
Garcia was booked into jail on suspicion of 10 counts of sexual conduct with a minor under 15, one count of sexual conduct with a minor by a step-parent and four counts of sexual abuse of a minor under 15.