Letters From the Issue of Thursday, February 1, 2007

Page 2 of 3

Patently untrue: I am writing regarding a sentence in the article "A Cancer on ASU." The sentence reads: "It is true that he's personally grossed millions of dollars over the course of his career as a result of patents."

It is a fact that Dr. Bob Pettit profited over the course of his career as a result of his many patents. However, he always lived on his professor's salary, and all the money he earned was paid to the Cancer Research Institute for laboratory supplies, researchers' salaries, and payments on the CRI's mortgage.

CRI was totally self-supportive through donors, grants, and patents. The Institute cost ASU nothing, brought ASU millions of dollars from Dr. Pettit's and his colleague's patents, and created a very favorable national and international reputation for the university.
Name withheld by request

The Hex Files

All in the family: Great story on the Cards ("The Curse," Robert Nelson, January 11)! The background/history on the team and its ties to Phoenix was right on. For 20 years, I've been wondering what each crummy season had in common. Seems like everything has changed at one time or another: front office, coaching, players. The one thing that hasn't changed are the cranky, eccentric, greedy owners.

Forget the Curse of Pottsville; the swearing should be directed at the Bidwills.
Tim Lank, via the Internet

All right, already, they suck!: In your article regarding the Arizona Cardinals, I kept seeing the word "curse." There is no such thing. The Cardinals are not cursed. They just suck.

Saying that the team has been cursed for the last several decades is actually giving an excuse as to why the team has not done well. In baseball, the Red Sox proved there is no curse in sports. Say it for what it really is: The Cardinals just flat out suck. The management sucks. The players suck. And once the Dallas Cowboys build their new stadium, then the Cardinals' new stadium will also suck.

Quit calling it a curse. There has never been any evidence pointing to any kind of curse, and simply mentioning some bad luck does not give a valid reason to say that the team is cursed. They suck!
Chriss Stott, via the Internet

We hope we're right, too: I'm a sports junkie and long-suffering Cardinals fan. My radio is usually dialed to sports talk, and I regularly devour all the local newspaper sports reports. We have a New Times rack in front of our store, and the Cardinal cover this week immediately caught my eye. I have to say that I'm surprised (although I shouldn't be, given your meticulous reporting) that New Times had the best analysis of the Cardinal situation that I've seen here in town.

I just hope you're right and the Cardinals can manage to win now despite the Bidwills' mismanagement.
Mike Banks, Samurai Comics, Phoenix

The fault, dear Bill, is not in your stars: Your recent article on the Cardinals was right on. I was a season ticketholder in St. Louis from day one until they went to Arizona. It was always about Bill Bidwill. He cared nothing for the game, the fans or the city. He was in only his own ego and his pocketbook. It's not a curse, it's a personality defect.
Mike Harcourt, Des Moines, Iowa

Well, they are possessed . . .: I was a long-suffering fan of the Cardinals in St. Louis, and I have to say that your story is the most comprehensive article I've ever read on the team and its sorry history.

I had never heard of the Pottsville Curse, but that would explain it. Ha! Because it's always been unbelievable how bad the team has always been. You had to think it was something supernatural.

But, seriously, your analysis of the Bidwill family was dead on. I never really knew the extent of their cheapness and incompetence, but now I do. It's almost a shame that they will wind up getting even more super-rich because of the new stadium in Arizona. They sure don't deserve it.

Thanks for finally setting the record straight.
Dale McClosky, St. Louis, Missouri

Don't Drink & Interview

As long as we cleared up that "Top Ramen" quote . . .: Thank you to music editor Niki D'Andrea for actually going out to concerts, and doing write-ups on 'em! For the most part, I enjoyed her recent column ("Hick Hop," Niki at Nite, December 21) about our business, Hillgrass Bluebilly Entertainment! But there are a few things I wanted to clear up!

KEEP PHOENIX NEW TIMES FREE... Since we started Phoenix New Times, it has been defined as the free, independent voice of Phoenix, and we'd like to keep it that way. With local media under siege, it's more important than ever for us to rally support behind funding our local journalism. You can help by participating in our "I Support" program, allowing us to keep offering readers access to our incisive coverage of local news, food and culture with no paywalls.