10 Metro Phoenix Desserts to Pre-Order for Thanksgiving

Keep New Times Free
I Support
  • Local
  • Community
  • Journalism
  • logo

Support the independent voice of Phoenix and help keep the future of New Times free.

Turkey, stuffing, countless side dishes, dinner rolls -- you have enough on your plate to make for Thanksgiving. By ordering dessert from an expert baker, you free up some time to relax on the holiday, are ensured that the final course won't leave a bad taste in anyone's mouth, and save yourself from disappointment when half the crowd is too stuffed to enjoy the homemade creation you slaved over. Plus, you get to support local businesses, and who doesn't like to do that?

See also: - Chow Bella's Thanksgiving Dining Guide: Where to Dine Out in Metro Phoenix - Don't Want to Spend Thanksgiving Day in the Kitchen? Where to Buy Ready-Made Dishes

Shelley Au's Sweet Buttermilk Pie

Southerners craving a taste of home will weep with joy after sampling this buttermilk pie ($15). This perfectly balanced pie is a dessert that everyone can fall in love with at first bite. The filling, with a generous helping of sugar and butter, tastes rich without being as heavy as a crème brûlée. Served with warm caramel sauce, this pie is so good it might make your relatives forget all about the pumpkin or pecan -- which you can also pick up from Shelley's Specialty Desserts in downtown Glendale if you want to serve a classic Thanksgiving selection.

Roasted Pear Brown Sugar Shortbread from Urban Cookies Bakeshop

There's one in every family: the person who claims not to like sweets, who chooses plain shortbread over chocolate chip cookies. Wow them -- and everyone else too -- with this seasonal baked bar ($31.89/dozen). It's rich with buttery flavor, has hints of deep caramel, and is topped with thinly sliced roasted pears. They're a more manageable size than a slice of pie, and it'll be lighter on your already-full stomach too. In case pear isn't your thing, we also recommend the holiday ginger molasses bread ($10.74). Both are available through December 31; call 602-451-4335 to order.

Tracy Dempsey's Red Hot Chile Pepita Cranberry Brittle

If your family isn't that into dessert -- or is so into dessert that you put out sweets to snack on while prepping the big meal -- this unique brittle is a must-have. It packs some heat thanks to the chile flakes, but the cranberries (and what's Thanksgiving without cranberries?) will offset the heat with tart sweetness. Afraid of the spice? Try her bacon-pecan brittle instead. Tracy Dempsey Originals products can be found at Smeeks, Arcadia Farms, Wedge & Bottle, and Changing Hands Bookstore, and orders can be placed by calling 602-376-9021.

Caramel Cream Macarons from Essence Bakery Café

Essence Bakery is known for its macarons, and the most popular flavor is the caramel cream. They're tiny size means that anyone who filled up at dinner can get a taste of dessert without wasting a bunch of pie, and the classic caramel flavor will be a hit with the whole crowd. If you want to opt for a more traditional Thanksgiving flavor, Essence also has a pumpkin macaron, spiced with nutmeg, cinnamon, and ginger. Small macarons are $16.80 for a dozen or $33.60 for two dozen. Large macarons are $3.25 each.

Tammie Coe's Traditional Pumpkin Pie

What would a Thanksgiving dessert list be without pumpkin pie? A shame, that's what. If you want a simple and simply amazing traditional pumpkin pie for your table, Tammie Coe will bake the perfect one just for you ($24). Her version, which is topped with caramel whipped cream, certainly pleased the crowd at the Third Annual Pie Social. For Thanksgiving, Tammie Coe is also making a special sweet potato and butterscotch mousse cake ($36 small, $60 large). Order by Saturday, November 17, for pick-up on Wednesday, November 21.

Pumpkin Cheesecake from Bertha's Café

This dessert, a welcome mix between cheesecake and pumpkin pie, is fluffy and light with just enough pumpkin flavor and spice. If you want a dessert that's seasonal but not too rich, this is a nice alternative to pumpkin pie. The cheesecake rests in a graham cracker crust that tastes remarkably like Bicoff biscuits and is topped with an ultra-thick layer of airy whipped cream, so it's appropriately indulgent to cap off a fantastic holiday meal. Pumpkin pecan cheesecake is also available. Small cheesecakes (serves 4 to 6) are $25, medium (serves 6 to 8) $35, and large (serves 10 to 15) $45. With a minimum of 48 hours' notice, call 602-955-1022 to order.

Tortilla Pudding from Ticoz Resto-Bar

It's unconventional to order a restaurant's dessert to take home, but the tortilla pudding from Ticoz is so incredible that you'll want to do it anyway. (We called to check; they will be happy to oblige.) What makes it a good fit for Thanksgiving? It's full of gooey cinnamony goodness, which is typical of autumn desserts, and tortillas make it a fun option for a Southwestern celebration. As if that's not enough, it's so addictive you'll go back for seconds -- even if you had thirds of turkey and stuffing. Call 602-200-0160 to order.

Pie Snob's Green Chile Jalapeno Apple Pie

Why just get apple pie when you could be eating green chile jalapeno apple pie on Turkey Day? With fresh granny smith apples, hatch green chilies, and jalapeno honey butter cinnamon crumble, this creative twist on the all-American classic won multiple awards at the 2011 Pie Social -- but it's seasonal, and this is the only time of year it can be ordered. If you're going gourmet this holiday season, don't pass up this unique pie ($24).

Tres Leches Cake from La Tolteca

For a Mexican-American Thanksgiving -- or if you or your guests prefer cake over pie for whatever reason -- tres leches cake is a great choice. This buttery, spongy cake soaked in three types of milk (hence the name) is a real crowd-pleaser, especially when you pick one up from La Tolteca. There are two options: vanilla icing and colorful sprinkles, perfect for the kids' table, or chocolate icing with a cherry on top. Either way, the cake comes with its own milky sauce, and each bite is crumbly and moist without being soggy or overly sweet.

Pecan Pie from The Farm at South Mountain

Along with pumpkin, pecan pie is a true Thanksgiving classic. Where do you get a good one? Go straight to the source: the pecan grove. With countless pecan trees, The Farm at South Mountain is just the spot to pick up a made-from-scratch pecan pie for your family's table. Call The Farm Kitchen at 602-276-6360 to order a whole pie ($28). At least 24 hours' notice is required.

Follow Chow Bella on Facebook, Twitter, and Pinterest.

Keep Phoenix New Times Free... Since we started Phoenix New Times, it has been defined as the free, independent voice of Phoenix, and we would like to keep it that way. Offering our readers free access to incisive coverage of local news, food and culture. Producing stories on everything from political scandals to the hottest new bands, with gutsy reporting, stylish writing, and staffers who've won everything from the Society of Professional Journalists' Sigma Delta Chi feature-writing award to the Casey Medal for Meritorious Journalism. But with local journalism's existence under siege and advertising revenue setbacks having a larger impact, it is important now more than ever for us to rally support behind funding our local journalism. You can help by participating in our "I Support" membership program, allowing us to keep covering Phoenix with no paywalls.

We use cookies to collect and analyze information on site performance and usage, and to enhance and customize content and advertisements. By clicking 'X' or continuing to use the site, you agree to allow cookies to be placed. To find out more, visit our cookies policy and our privacy policy.


Join the New Times community and help support independent local journalism in Phoenix.


Join the New Times community and help support independent local journalism in Phoenix.