By Ray Stern
By New Times
By Amy Silverman
By Stephen Lemons
By Stephen Lemons
By Monica Alonzo
By Chris Parker
By New Times
Now they've both published memoirs.
McCain prevailed as a candidate, and he prevails again as an author. This weekend he nudged up a spot to No. 2 on the New York Times best-seller list with Faith of My Fathers: A Family Memoir.
In contrast, I probably boosted Sargent's sales considerably when I purchased my copy of her self-published Journey Proud: Recollections of a Fifties Woman. I bought the book out of curiosity: What had Sargent been up to since the '92 campaign?
Writing this book, as it turns out.
I find it ironic that McCain and Sargent published their memoirs at the same time, since each has had a significant impact on the other's life.
The 1992 campaign was a turning point for both.
McCain was at his most vulnerable -- fresh from a starring role in the Keating Five scandal, in which he and four other senators were investigated and nationally castigated for helping a savings and loan mogul whose business ultimately would go belly up. If McCain had lost that race, his political career likely would have been over; he certainly would not be running for president today.
And thus, there would have been no reason for him to write Faith of My Fathers. McCain's motivation for telling his life story is clear: The book is more campaign ad than literary effort, focusing solely on the senator's military career and the military careers of his father and grandfather. Much of it is devoted to the youngest McCain's five-and-a-half years in Vietnamese prison camps; the book ends before his political career begins.
Even though I had read extensively of McCain's POW experience -- both from his own accounts and memoirs by his fellow POWs -- I was drawn in, as always, by the tale. He may not have had a great reason for writing the book, but there's no denying that it's a good read.
John McCain's impact on Claire Sargent's life is even more obvious. The '92 campaign is the climax of her book, certainly the most exciting thing that ever happened to her. But what I couldn't figure out, until I read the book, is why she would want to tell the story.
After all, she lost.
For a book that took almost eight years to write, Journey Proud is amazingly dull. But it's a must-read for anyone who wants to know why John McCain is where he is today.
The best thing I can say about Sargent's craftsmanship is that I couldn't find any typos. In fairness to the author, she wasn't working with the most thrilling material.
Growing up in the South, Sargent's family is not rich, but certainly not poor. (She manages to drop in a mention of her descent from the Daughters of the American Revolution.) When her father tells her there's only enough money to send her brother to college, Sargent balks. She goes, too, but has to work part-time to help pay the bills.
She moves to New York City after college, and works for an advertising firm. She marries a wealthy man. We don't learn much about Sargent's first marriage -- in fact, we don't even learn her husband's name -- but she does mention that he's a Wall Street investor. She has children. The pinnacle of her high-powered, feminist career comes when she lands a job as a travel agent.
Sargent divorces, then leaves her children in New York to move to Phoenix and marry Henry Sargent, a childhood friend and executive with Arizona Public Service. He leaves his wife for her.
Sargent laments about how boring Phoenix is for this vibrant city girl. She looks for work; she claims she must bring in money, even though her new husband is a high-powered executive. When she can't find a job, she gets a master's degree at the American School of International Management.
She still can't find work that suits her, so Sargent dabbles in politics. She's Terry Goddard's office manager during his first run for Phoenix mayor. She runs for the Legislature in 1984, and loses. She joins some committees, puts up some signs.
And then Sargent decides to challenge John McCain.
It's at that point, more than 200 pages in, that I realized why Sargent wrote this book: She's not done blaming the people she holds responsible for her 1992 loss.
The truth is that Claire Sargent is to blame. She was unqualified, she got in way too late, she ran a lousy race. As you'll recall, 1992 was the Year of the Woman in American politics, and although it helped her defeat another no-name in the primary, it didn't help her in the general. Sargent didn't even get the endorsement of the women's fund-raising groups EMILY's List or the Women's Campaign Fund, although her most memorable line in the campaign was, "I think it's about time we voted for senators with breasts. We've been voting for boobs long enough."
Along with women, Arizona Democrats hit a high point in '92, as well, winning two more seats in Congress.