Critic's Notebook

will.i.am

Derivative, repetitive, insipid, insincere, and pandering, Songs About Girls also has the worst insert booklet in recent memory — seven pages of will.i.am mugging in a checkered suit. The first song, "Over," a lover's lament featuring a sample from Electric Light Orchestra (never a bad thing) isn't terrible. But with...
Carbonatix Pre-Player Loader

Audio By Carbonatix

Derivative, repetitive, insipid, insincere, and pandering, Songs About Girls also has the worst insert booklet in recent memory — seven pages of will.i.am mugging in a checkered suit. The first song, “Over,” a lover’s lament featuring a sample from Electric Light Orchestra (never a bad thing) isn’t terrible. But with the first single, “I Got It From My Mama,” the ship crashes directly into the iceberg. It’s almost a note-for-note rip-off of “My Humps,” which means, we guess, that there’s a new worst single of the millennium. On “The Donque Song,” Snoop regurgitates some of his Doggystyle rhymes over a techno beat, and then, on “One More Chance,” will vomits up this gem: “I know you want more than a dick in ya. You want a good nigga to stick with ya.” “Fantastic” contains yet another sample of The Jackson 5’s “I Want You Back,” and “S.O.S” (are we done yet?) is an anti-global warming power ballad. It’s hard to get upset about it. Perhaps the culture that produced this album deserves our fate.

This year, make your gift count – Invest in local news that matters.

Our work is funded by readers like you who make voluntary gifts because they value our work and want to see it continue. Make a contribution today to help us reach our $30,000 goal!

$30,000

GET MORE COVERAGE LIKE THIS

Sign up for the Music newsletter to get the latest stories delivered to your inbox

Loading latest posts...