Monday Night Martha: Pumpkin Pie

Is it ever too early for pie? Yes, it's barely October but some Valley stores already have Christmas decorations up, which means like it or not, the holiday season is here. We happen to love the period between October and January and will take any excuse under the sun to...
Carbonatix Pre-Player Loader

Audio By Carbonatix

Independent Journalism in Phoenix Needs You

We need to raise $15,000 by August 9 to support the reporting our community depends on. Reader support keeps us independent and is playing a larger role in funding local journalism and shaping what comes next. If you believe independent local journalism matters, make a contribution today.

$15,000

Is it ever too early for pie? Yes, it’s barely October but some Valley stores already have Christmas decorations up, which means like it or not, the holiday season is here. We happen to love the period between October and January and will take any excuse under the sun to make seasonal pie. That’s why we dug up this wingding recipe from good ol’ Paula Deen.

If we were really hardcore, we’d give you a lovely write-up about the glories of using real pumpkins instead of canned, but that’s not how we roll. Deen’s recipe is relatively traditional. It’s rich, as is her style, with butter and half-and-half and a package of cream cheese.

Deen’s recipe leaves you more than enough filling for one pie. You could probably even stretch and make two with it. With our leftovers, we filled a few ramekins and baked them separately. The other thing to bear in mind is that Deen calls for the pie to cook for 50 minutes. We baked our pie for an hour and five minutes and could still have left the pie in the oven longer.

Our dining newsletter is a tasty treat

Sign up now for free updates on openings, closings and all the food news that matters.

Loading latest posts...