How Can I Convince My Parents That My Band Isn't a Terrible Idea?

Fan,
I am in a small struggling band. We have been together for two months and we want to get our music out there and try to start booking local shows. The major problem is that we are all being kicked out of our houses soon, but we want to prove to our parents that we can make some money off of being in a band. How can we do what we love? Any suggestions?
 Stereo Type

Stereo Type,
Being in a band to prove anything to your parents beyond that you are capable of forming a band is a really bad idea. Period.

Even the coolest parents are worried about their kids in bands because music is a pursuit where the frustrations are many and the rewards can be slow-coming. Maybe they're pissed because they expected you would do something other than music. Maybe they read that Grizzly Bear article about how it has become increasingly more difficult for musicians to make a living and they are concerned that your band being a full-time pursuit will mean that you are going to live in their house forever -- as they should be. I am not telling you the following to discourage you, but rather to keep you from fighting with your parents or pursuing a dream simply because you have some bad information. In 2013, it is extremely difficult to make a living as a musician, regardless of what kind of music you make or how good you are.

It is super-hard to make money as a local band, let alone enough for an entire band to live off of. Two months is way, way too soon to even be considering how you might make money off your band. You may not get a show that pays more than $20 in your first year of regular gigging, even if your band is fronted by someone who is super-hot and/or you can get more than 12 friends to come see you play. It is very unlikely, even if your band is the second coming of Grimes, that once you divide your pay among band members that you could buy two gallons of gas and a Happy Meal and not have to dip into your own funds to pay for them.

My suggestion? You're really putting the cart before the horse. Your horse isn't even a horse yet; it is like a newborn foal barely wobbling around the paddock. You should not even be trying to prove anything with this band beyond that you are capable of showing up for practice on time. Even if you write and practice every day, for hours, you probably have maybe two half-good songs. That is no slight. Thems is just facts.

Two months along is an okay time to start thinking about maybe playing a party or a new-band night at a club. It is hard not to be super-eager and want to get the ball rolling, but trying to get opening slots on decent bills before you are ready or capable of drawing, before you have the kinks worked out could do more harm than good. No one's first shows are any good, but you can avoid being a total trainwreck by giving your band time to develop and practice and be a band before you play out.

I've been in maybe a dozen bands over the years that formed just to play a party or a show in three weeks' time, wrote five songs in a week, and played. That is a valid way to do it, certainly, but the difference is that it sounds like you really want to pursue a serious, music-career minded path and not just be in a Free Kitten rip-off party band like some of us. And if that is the case, you probably want to take a few more months to finesse your songs, sound, performance -- like, rather than play the only eight songs you have, play your best eight songs.

If you want to be in a band that is maybe a steady paycheck, I would suggest being a wedding band or being a covers band and seeing if you can't scare up a regular weekend night gig at a popular bar. Start a Coldplay tribute band, perhaps. My old bass teacher plays in a blues band that plays in the hallway of the United Center during Blackhawks games. My sons' babysitter is in a rad country band that does kids' songs, and they get hired to play a lot of street fairs and city festivals in the summer. There are ways to make (some) money off being in a regular-gigging local band, but, most of the time, it involves being a jobber and not doing your original music.

So, that said, I think you should move out of your parents house ASAP, get the best crappy job you can, and practice at night and on the weekends like everyone else. And then you don't have to give a shit about what they think about your being in a band because you are supporting yourself. When your music is a hobby, it retains its value to you because you need it. Doing music full-time is a serious scramble for cash that probably invariably involves saying yes to all manner of shit you do not want to do because you have to pay the rent.

The founding of a band is the best-worst time. Have you ever read any rock tell-all where the person doesn't regard that time as the pinnacle of their life? They are always so miserable when they get to the part with the private jet. So, yes, sure, fantasize all you want about your rock star future, but don't forget to be here in this anxious moment, enjoying this awful time with your band. 
Best of luck,
Fan

• Music News