Mariachis Got a Right to Sing Protest Songs

Do you agree with immigration rights activists calling Elvira Arellano, who is an illegal immigrant and a criminal, the Mexican Rosa Parks? The very idea that these people refer to her as such is deeply disturbing. Rosa Parks was a legal resident of this country and took a stand against the injustices against African-Americans and, by extension, all other minorities in this country. I cant imagine what goes through the minds of some of these people, when they made ludicrous statements comparing Arellano to Parks. I have a problem with illegal immigrants, period! I dont care where they come from on this planet, illegal is illegal.
Swing Low, Sweet Migra

Dear Gabacha:
You're right. How dare yaktivists compare Elvira Arellano (a recently deported illegal Mexican immigrant who earned national attention this year by seeking sanctuary in a Chicago church) to Rosa Parks! Besides, everyone knows the better historical counterpart is Jesus. Think about it: Like Jesús, Arellano is a brown-skinned alien who sparked equal parts rage and praise while promoting her movement. Both lived in defiance of authorities who obsessed over laws that ignored the Segundo Coming. Arellano and the Nazarene knew their ultimate martyrdom yet met grim destiny with serenity, asking followers not to react angrily but rather allow God's will. I already hear the gnashing teeth of Know Nothings — but what about the fake Social Security number? The breaking of federal law? The fact that illegal is illegal? — but let the record show that no matter how you spin it, Arellano's tale is biblical in its intentions, and she sure as hell ain't Jezebel. Only time will tell if Arellano's efforts will convert the Pharisees or cause the exile of her people to Babylon — err, Mexico.

Im African-American. At our restaurants, nobody comes to your table to sing to you. At your restaurants, this does happen, and I love it. I love picking out a song (usually something from Luis Miguels Romance II; its the best I can do with my limited "ballads en español" repertoire). I love listening to the singer and imagining how many times the group has had to play "La Bamba." Mi problema es I havent the slightest idea what I should be doing while theyre playing. Ive usually got a plate of hot food in front of me or a waiter trying to outwait the song so he could come take our order. Is it rude to sing along? Do I tip when theyre done? How much? Help me not be a clueless tourist when I want to enjoy a little "Media Vuelta" with my number four combo.
I Wanta Cantar

Dear Want to Sing Negrita:
Tips? Always. How much? Depends on how good the mariachi plays. Rude to sing along? Never. Indeed, it's a time-honored tradition among Mexicans to have the musically inclined members of la familia belt out a couple of corridos at weddings, quinceañeras, baptisms, or any other celebration (shout-outs to my tío Ezequiel and cousin Lety!). The dynamic changes a bit when mariachis perform at restaurants, but don't be afraid. Although the crowd will stare and sneer at any non-Mexicans trying to sing mariachi tunes, all you have to do is shout "Viva Mxico, cabrones!" at some point, and the wabs will go wild.

KEEP PHOENIX NEW TIMES FREE... Since we started Phoenix New Times, it has been defined as the free, independent voice of Phoenix, and we'd like to keep it that way. With local media under siege, it's more important than ever for us to rally support behind funding our local journalism. You can help by participating in our "I Support" program, allowing us to keep offering readers access to our incisive coverage of local news, food and culture with no paywalls.
Gustavo Arellano
Contact: Gustavo Arellano