Long before he started smoking brisket, pork butt, ribs, and half-chickens in Cave Creek, Bryan Dooley studied at the Culinary Institute of America in Hyde Park, New York. Before he developed a tomato-based sauce with cider vinegar tang to cut the richness of brisket, he cooked for 13 years at the Fairmont Scottsdale Princess. Dooley knows classical technique and fine dining. And with his culinary chops, Dooley has chosen to make a living smoking meat — to barbecue.
“I’m not a pit boss,” Dooley insists. “I’m a chef who specializes in barbecue.”
His mastery of technique comes in on the edges. It shapes the outer flavors of Bryan’s Black Mountain Barbecue: the sauces, the sides, the non-barbecue dishes that depend on the likes of preserved lemon tartar sauce (for frog legs) or smoked tomato remoulade (for a fried artichoke po’ boy).
More distantly, Dooley's experience informs the core of what he does: smoke meat. It shapes his ‘cue on a faint and intangible level, giving him a feeling-based general competency that can't be reduced to specific culinary maneuvers or decisions.
“Barbecue is about smoking meat with fire,” Dooley says. “We don’t want to mess with that so much.”
Like his grandfather, an Alabaman who barbecued in a pit of “cement blocks and metal grates,” Dooley keeps ‘cue simple. He has to. Though he has sauced and sauteed, when the smoker gets hot, all Dooley has to work with is three elements: “meat, fire, and wood.”
He makes skillful use of this smoky trinity.
Dooley’s brisket has, sinking a half-inch below its bark, a florid crimson tinge. You can ask for brisket lean or fatty, and you’d be nuts not to mash down the pedal here. The fatty brisket has the usual butter-like dissolve of expertly slow-smoked meat. What sets this brisket apart is the delicate flavor of the fat. It tastes like beef but also has a nutty perfume and fleeting caramel and toasted notes.
Like Oren Hartmen of NakedQ in Scottsdale, Dooley aims for mild smoke that will let meat’s flavors sing. Dooley achieves this smoke by plugging pecan wood, always sourced from the same vendor, into the basic “meat, fire, and wood” equation.
Aaron Franklin, whose Franklin Barbecue (Austin, Texas) is considered one of the nation's best, waxes about wood in his book Franklin Barbecue. He makes a good point: “Wood is important for two functions: providing heat and supplying smoke.” The kind and age of wood will, given the simplicity of barbecue’s basic elements, have an outsize influence on brisket’s eventual taste. Smoke is a strange heat source. It isn’t the steady blue flame of a gas stove or an oven set to 350. Smoke cooks and flavors food. Franklin advises barbecue acolytes to “approach your wood pile like a chef approaches his spice rack.”
That isn’t much of a leap for Dooley, fine dining vet, to make.
Dooley prefers pecan wood’s “nice soft smoke.” He finds hickory and mesquite too powerful. Mesquite produces the most pungent smoke of all the commonly used woods, nut tree woods and oak the least. Peach, apple, and other fruit woods impart, Franklin writes, “a gentle, rounded sweetness.”
It’s 100% pecan wood for Dooley. He gets cords from a supplier who sources from Native American land near the Salt River and down near Tucson. Arizona is known for its pecan wood. Pima County is one of the three largest pecan-producing counties in America.
The benefits of pecan wood can be tasted in Dooley's burnt ends.
Burnt ends are tougher bites from where the brisket tapers to awkward shapes and doesn’t allow for neat long slices. Dooley’s are as black as the space between two stars. Gnawing in, you expect the bitter explosion that comes with such a char. There is none.
Same with the pulled pork, smoked to heavy darkness. The bark yields to the tooth with a sticky, taffy-like chew with some crisp. Rocking especially hard are the single morsels with both bark and pink shreds of melting inner pork, which has a sweet, nutty flavor. The near-translucence of pecan smoke allows for these nuances.
Dooley smokes brisket and pork butts for 12 to 14 hours. As the smoker hums in the kitchen, John Wayne and western actors bluster on a projector screen in the dining room. Bryan’s seats 150 people. The joint is on Cave Creek Road, the western town’s main drag.
Two of the edges where Dooley’s training most shapes his 'cue are his rub and sauce. He uses one rub for his meat. It mixes more than 15 spices, including salt, pepper, garlic, chile powder, thyme, and ginger. His sauce is huge on tomato and tang. It's obscenely delicious, borderline drinkable, but his meat is better without.
Lamb shank and the occasional run of alligator spareribs are as fancy as his ‘cue gets. His style is less classical chef sieving sauces the same way chefs have for centuries and more simplified, in easy tune with a cooking method that stretches back millennia.
Cooking with smoke defies recipe. Pecan wood chopped a few days ago burns differently from wood laid away last year, and smokers have hot and cold spots just like grills. As Dooley’s approach hints, barbecue is more of an instinctive, go-by-feel-type, Jedi style of cooking.
Asked to define “barbecue,” Dooley locates the definition in pure feeling.
“To me, barbecue is a feeling,” he says. “The feeling you get when you’re eating it. Barbecue comes in may different styles, but they all give you that same comfort feeling. That’s what we’re trying to pursue. It’s bigger than just throwing some meat over some coals, or over some wood.”
Barbecue Joint: Bryan's Black Mountain Barbecue
Smoke Master: Bryan Dooley
Highlight: Fatty brisket
Staples: Brisket, pulled pork, St. Louis ribs, chicken (whole halves or pulled)
Notable Specials: Smoked lamb shank with ginger barbecue sauce (spring); specials for the courageous eater that (now) rotate four times a year.
Ordering Quirks: Dooley's 'cue is served with a trace of sauce; you can (and should) ask for it naked. If ordering brisket, you can choose to opt for fatty, lean, or burnt ends.
Bryan's Black Mountain Barbecue. 6130 East Cave Creek Road, Cave Creek; 480-575-7155
Tuesday through Saturday 11 a.m. to 8 p.m.; closed Sunday and Monday.
*Starting on October 15, Bryan's will be open on Sunday as well.
Keep Phoenix New Times Free... Since we started Phoenix New Times, it has been defined as the free, independent voice of Phoenix, and we would like to keep it that way. Offering our readers free access to incisive coverage of local news, food and culture. Producing stories on everything from political scandals to the hottest new bands, with gutsy reporting, stylish writing, and staffers who've won everything from the Society of Professional Journalists' Sigma Delta Chi feature-writing award to the Casey Medal for Meritorious Journalism. But with local journalism's existence under siege and advertising revenue setbacks having a larger impact, it is important now more than ever for us to rally support behind funding our local journalism. You can help by participating in our "I Support" membership program, allowing us to keep covering Phoenix with no paywalls.