Cult Expert Must Pay

Rick Ross, the Phoenix-based cult and militia expert, sat in U.S. Bankruptcy Court last week, listening as a judge revisited the facts in a 1990 Washington state "deprogramming."

In that incident, Ross had watched while three men grabbed 18-year-old Jason Scott, handcuffed him, put duct tape over his mouth and stuffed him into a van. They then drove for more than two hours to an expensive beach house that had been rented for the deprogramming.

Scott was taken into the house and held against his will for days as Ross tried to convince him that the Christian fundamentalist sect he belonged to was a destructive cult. Eventually, Scott escaped, and criminal charges were brought by the Greys Harbor County attorney against Ross and the three "security" men.

A jury acquitted Ross. But in a civil suit Scott filed against Ross, the security men and the Chicago-based Cult Awareness Network, a Seattle jury agreed that Scott's religious civil rights had been violated, and awarded him $5 million. Ross' share is $3.4 million.

Ross filed for bankruptcy, hoping to discharge the debt, but Scott's attorney asked Judge George Nielsen to rule that Ross' debt was a result of "willful and malicious injury" to Scott, and therefore nondischargeable.

After reviewing the facts, Nielsen agreed with Scott and ruled that Ross could not discharge the debt.

It appeared to be a straightforward conclusion to a straightforward case. But as New Times reported last fall, the Rick Ross/Jason Scott case is not a simple one ("Hush, Hush, Sweet Charlatans," November 30, 1995).

Sitting behind Ross, a woman named Kathy Tonkin waited patiently to testify before Judge Nielsen. But she didn't get the chance.

Although it was Tonkin who hired Ross to deprogram Scott, she was neither charged criminally nor was she named in Scott's lawsuit. Yet Tonkin not only paid Ross for the deprogramming, she rented the beach house, she was present when the kidnaping took place, and remained present during the days Scott was held.

Kathy Tonkin is also Jason Scott's mother.
Six years after the botched deprogramming, she still supports Ross, calling him "a professional" who helped her save two younger sons from Life Tabernacle in Bellevue, Washington. Tonkin had asked her entire family to join Life Tabernacle, but when she later left the church, complaining of its oppressiveness, she says the church encouraged her sons to spurn her.

Tonkin says she turned to Ross in desperation, and was encouraged when he successfully convinced her two younger sons to leave the church. While being held in their grandmother's house--legally, since they were minors and their mother was present--Tonkin's two younger boys waged spiritual war with Ross, who is well-versed in the Bible and specializes in Bible-based cults. Ross doggedly asked the boys about Life Tabernacle, a branch of the United Pentecostal Church International, which mainstream Christian organizations consider "heretical." Ross told the boys how certain preachers twist Scripture to keep members fearful and compliant. And he challenged them with questions about their pastor, who required his flock to live in near poverty while enjoying an expensive lifestyle himself.

Eventually, the boys lowered their guard and started showing affection for the mother they had earlier condemned as a "backslider."

Tonkin had hoped the same treatment would work on her oldest son, but, as an 18-year-old, Jason Scott couldn't by law be held against his will. Nationally, deprogrammers say that such kidnapings are rare, and Ross says that he had attempted only a handful in the 300 or so deprogrammings he has undertaken. After the Jason Scott ordeal, Ross says he no longer attempts such kidnapings.

Today, Scott is no longer a member of Life Tabernacle, but relations between Scott and his mother remain rocky.

Since the 1990 kidnaping, however, Tonkin has never been accused of wrongdoing. Tonkin and Ross claim that's because the criminal and civil cases against Ross have had less to do with mistreatment of Scott than an attempt by a powerful church to shut down Ross, one of its hated enemies.

Jason Scott wasn't present at last week's bankruptcy hearing. He was represented instead by his California attorney, Kendrick Moxon.

Moxon also happens to be a Scientologist who has represented the Church of Scientology in many of its most high-profile legal battles. (One such battle occurred after Time magazine branded Scientology a "ruthless global scam.")

It was Moxon and other Scientologists, Tonkin says, who convinced her son to pursue the criminal and civil cases against Ross. Moxon denies the charge, and has told New Times that Scott had come to him for advice.

But a former Scientology operative, testifying in an unrelated case, backs up Tonkin's accusations. The former operative, Gary Scarff, testified that he had been assigned to accompany Jason Scott to rallies and press conferences, and that Scientology picked up the tab. Scarff said Scott told him of his recruitment by the church: "Jason and I discussed . . . the persistent and unwanted pressure he was receiving from Scientology officials wanting him to demand Greys Harbor County prosecutors to reinstate criminal charges against Rick Ross.

KEEP PHOENIX NEW TIMES FREE... Since we started Phoenix New Times, it has been defined as the free, independent voice of Phoenix, and we'd like to keep it that way. With local media under siege, it's more important than ever for us to rally support behind funding our local journalism. You can help by participating in our "I Support" program, allowing us to keep offering readers access to our incisive coverage of local news, food and culture with no paywalls.
Tony Ortega
Contact: Tony Ortega