NYPD Pizza

Run by Long Island's Ziegler brothers, this place proves that your name doesn't have to end in a vowel to run a first-class pizzeria. Excellent thin-crust pizza (try the NYPD Blue, heaped with ricotta, eggplant and roasted peppers) and one of the town's best calzones. If you can handle dessert after a few oversized slices, we recommend the cannoli and kisses to push you over the edge.