The 5 best things the Phoenix New Times food team tasted in September | Phoenix New Times

Food & Drink News

The 5 best things we ate in September

A couple of pasta dishes felt perfect for fall and a refreshing soda stood out in September.
The Peppermill is hidden in a strip mall in Tempe. But the unassuming exterior gives way to an impressive restaurant.
The Peppermill is hidden in a strip mall in Tempe. But the unassuming exterior gives way to an impressive restaurant. Tirion Boan
Share this:
A massive perk of writing about food is that in order to do so, you have to try a lot of meals. Throughout the month, the Phoenix New Times dining team visits restaurants and eateries all over the Valley, whether it be for our lists, First Tastes, Best Bites, reviews or other general research. Here are the five best things we ate in September.
click to enlarge
Big Marble Organics Proper Hibiscus soda beautifully captures the sweet-tart floral taste of the tropical plant.
Sara Crocker

Big Marble Organics Proper Hibiscus

Various locations
Big Marble Organics has been a regular nonalcoholic option or mixer at many restaurants and bars since its flagship ginger beer was created at The Breadfruit & Rum Bar. Although the Jamaican restaurant concept is shuttered for now, Big Marble owner Dwayne Allen is going full steam ahead with the beverage company, recently launching a Kickstarter campaign to expand the brand’s geographic footprint and the bubbly beverage company’s flavor portfolio. Allen has released two new flavors: Proper Lemon and Proper Hibiscus ($24.99 for 12, sold online). While both are delicious, the hibiscus soda offers a floral flavor that is true to the plant’s sweet-tart earthiness. It’s great as-is, and Allen says he also likes to add a jigger of amaro to it for a low-alcohol highball.
click to enlarge
The Creamy Mushroom Marsala pasta at Perfect Pear Bistro is a simple, comforting dish packed with flavor.
Sara Crocker

Creamy Mushroom Marsala at Perfect Pear Bistro

603 W. University Drive, Tempe
9845 S. Priest Drive, Tempe
The two locations of Perfect Pear Bistro often are bustling — and for good reason. The restaurant churns out comforting classics at reasonable prices. Take the Creamy Mushroom Marsala pasta ($14.99). A glance at the ingredients — rigatoni tossed with caramelized onions, mushrooms and roasted garlic and topped with parmesan cheese — belies the depth of the dish. The balance between the richness of the sauce, the umami of the mushrooms and the sweetness from the onions is an example of simple elegance and makes for a deeply satisfying bite.

click to enlarge
The Duck Confit Pop-Tart at the Peppermill could be an entire meal on its own.
Tirion Boan

Duck Confit Pop-Tart at the Peppermill

7660 S. McClintock Drive, #104, Tempe
We’ve seen savory pop-tarts on a couple of menus around town, but the version at the Peppermill is exemplary. When the dish ($15) arrives at the table, it looks quite simple. A large rectangle of puff pastry is folded over, drizzled with an orange and bourbon glaze and sprinkled with poppy seeds and chives. But the inside of this pop-tart is where the magic lies. Break apart the fluffy, flaky pastry to reveal a blend of goat cheese, roasted corn kernels and hearty chunks of duck confit. The pop-tart rests on a pool of fig and onion jam that when spread, melts together with the cheese to create an uber-satisfying sweet and savory flavor combination. The corn works perfectly with the sweetness of the jam and leaves you digging in for more until every last bite has been relished.
click to enlarge
Try a fresh take on elote at Vecina.
Tirion Boan

Elote at Vecina

3433 N. 56th St.
Elote comes in many forms, and Vecina on Indian School Road serves a standout interpretation. The dish ($11) is built on sweet fire-roasted corn blackened with hints of char that impart a deep, smoky flavor. That smoke is dialed up even more with chorizo butter and a sprinkling of toasted chile. On the side, a spoonful of lime and cilantro creme fraiche provides a yogurty tang that cuts through the sweet and smoky corn. Make sure to get a scoop of everything at once to experience the balance of this intentional and thoughtful dish.

click to enlarge
Pair a sophisticated pasta dish with a glass of wine or a cocktail at Caffe Boa.
Tirion Boan

Ravioli Zucca at Caffe Boa

398 S. Mill Ave., Tempe
The Ravioli Zucca ($19) at Caffe Boa in Tempe is the perfect plate for fall. Pasta pockets filled with an earthy and slightly sweet butternut squash mash come swimming in a butter sauce laden with garlic and sage. Toasted hazelnuts add crunch, and a mess of arugula tossed in a light, lemony dressing brightens the dish. Dollops of creamy goat cheese tie the whole plate together, blending the velvety textures and fresh ingredients into a perfect bite. While this dish doesn’t hop on any pumpkin or cinnamon trends, it does casually usher in the season.
KEEP NEW TIMES FREE... Since we started New Times, it has been defined as the free, independent voice of Phoenix, and we'd like to keep it that way. With local media under siege, it's more important than ever for us to rally support behind funding our local journalism. You can help by participating in our "I Support" program, allowing us to keep offering readers access to our incisive coverage of local news, food and culture with no paywalls. Make a one-time donation today for as little as $1.