MakeUp Eraser, the company founded by Republican Senate candidate Daniel McCarthy, pledged last year to move all of its manufacturing to the United States by January 2019.
But as recently as September, MakeUp Eraser continued to import makeup removal cloths and other products from Chinese suppliers, according to customs data collected and released by the trade intelligence firm Panjiva.
On top of the company's failure to meet its domestic production pledge, MakeUp Eraser last year reached a civil settlement in California over a claim that a cosmetic bag sold by the business contained a chemical known to cause cancer and problems with male reproductivity.
Revelations about McCarthy's business come as he faces criticism for off-kilter remarks made during his primary bid against Republican Senator Martha McSally, who he is challenging from the right.
Not long after announcing his candidacy in August, McCarthy made national headlines for proposing to annex to Mexico. A couple weeks later, he wrote a Facebook post appearing to compare himself with Jesus Christ.
Reached on Wednesday, McCarthy's Senate campaign forwarded to Phoenix New Times a statement from MakeUp Eraser that did not address its apparent failure to make all of its products domestically by 2019. Instead, the company touted its success in "giving consumers an alternative to the 1.3 billion wipes that are used daily."
The statement continued: "MakeUp Eraser is an American company, founded in Arizona, and our pledge to the consumer and the community as a whole is to continue our mission to be a pioneer in sustainable products."
Launched in 2013 by Daniel McCarthy and his wife, Elexsis McCarthy, MakeUp Eraser sells a reusable, polyester-blend cloth that removes makeup with warm water. The idea for the company came to Elexsis McCarthy when she realized that a wet robe gifted by her mother-in-law effectively removed her makeup, the married entrepreneurs have told reporters. On top of its patented makeup remover, the company's product line also includes cosmetic bags that contain sets of cloths.
In interviews, the McCarthys have been open about importing goods made abroad. The couple told the Arizona Republic in 2016 that their product line included 25 items made in Asia.
But MakeUp Eraser last year announced that it would join a growing movement toward domestic manufacturing. In a blog post published on the company's website on April 17, 2018, MakeUp Eraser claimed it was on track "to be manufacturing fully in the USA by January 2019." The post also claimed that it was slated to sew its first batch of makeup removal cloths on American soil in May 2018.
The blog post no longer appears on the company's website, but a copy of the announcement was preserved by the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine. MakeUp Eraser also shared the post on its official Facebook page.
MakeUp Eraser does not appear to have met its timeline for "manufacturing fully" in the United States.
According to Panjiva data, the Glendale-based company has received at least 16 shipments totaling more than 200,000 pounds from eight Chinese manufacturers in 2019. Products shipped from Chinese suppliers to MakeUp Eraser include polyester makeup removal cloths, cosmetic bags, cotton headbands, and paper boxes.
MakeUp Eraser has received products from Chinese companies as recently as September.
According to customs data, MakeUp Eraser on September 4 received a shipment of towels totaling more than 5,000 pounds from Shijiazhuang Meienbang Import & Export Trade Company, a supplier based in Heibei Province in China. Panjiva indicates that the products were marked as "MAKEUP ERASER DELUXE SAMPLE CASE PACK 50."
Shijiazhuang Meienbang touts "20 years of professional production towel experience" on its online market page found on Alibaba, the Chinese e-commerce site that is often compared to Amazon. The page is back-dropped by a stock photo of a woman on a beach, amateurishly-altered to make the model appear as if she is holding a towel that reads "DRIVE FAST, Eat ass" in NASCAR font.
Shijiazhuang Meienbang also sells a "Makeup Remover Clean Cloth" that looks similar to MakeUp Eraser's signature pink product.
The pink cloth sold by Shijiazhuang Meienbang is available for 80 cents on Alibaba if a buyer purchases between 100 to 999 pieces. If a buyer purchases more than 1,000 at a time, the cloths sell for 60 cents a piece. Here's what the product looks like on Alibaba:
Shijiazhuang Meienbang is not the only Chinese supplier that sells a makeup removal cloth from which MakeUp Eraser has received large shipments.
Panjiva's data shows that on July 13, 2019, MakeUp Eraser received a shipment totaling more than 11,000 pounds of microfiber towels from Hebei Laibang, another towel manufacturer based in Hebei Province.
Hebei Laibang sells its cloth for between $0.19 to $1.99 with a minimum order of 500. Here's what that product looks like on Alibaba:
MakeUp Eraser has also received shipments from Chinese suppliers that sell other products similar to ones sold by the Arizona company. Xiamen Sharetrade Import and Export Company shipped to MakeUp Eraser about 1,600 pounds worth of cosmetic bags on November 18, 2018.
Among the products sold by Xiamen Sharetrade is a watermelon-themed makeup bag that it sells for $2.20 each for buyers purchasing between 500 to 4,999 pieces. Here's what the watermelon bag looks like on Alibaba:
MakeUp Eraser sells a watermelon-print version of its makeup remover, which comes in a watermelon bag that looks nearly identical to the product sold by Sharetrade. Here's what MakeUp Eraser's watermelon makeup remover looks like on Amazon:
MakeUp Eraser's makeup bags this year led to a legal settlement in California, where advocates filed complaints accusing the company of exposing consumers to di(2-ethylhexyl)phthalate (DEHP), a chemical known to cause cancer and developmental male reproductive toxicity. According to notices of violations, MakeUp Eraser's watermelon-themed bag, as well as another bag emblazoned with flamingos, contained DEHP.
The violation was settled under Proposition 65, a California law that requires companies to label products that can expose consumers to toxic chemicals. In addition to requiring MakeUp Eraser to add a warning to its cosmetic bags, MakeUp Eraser was required to pay $3,000 in penalties and attorneys' fees.
In its statement to New Times, MakeUp Eraser did not address claims that its products contain DEHP.
Keep Phoenix New Times Free... Since we started Phoenix New Times, it has been defined as the free, independent voice of Phoenix, and we would like to keep it that way. Offering our readers free access to incisive coverage of local news, food and culture. Producing stories on everything from political scandals to the hottest new bands, with gutsy reporting, stylish writing, and staffers who've won everything from the Society of Professional Journalists' Sigma Delta Chi feature-writing award to the Casey Medal for Meritorious Journalism. But with local journalism's existence under siege and advertising revenue setbacks having a larger impact, it is important now more than ever for us to rally support behind funding our local journalism. You can help by participating in our "I Support" membership program, allowing us to keep covering Phoenix with no paywalls.