Gray was brimming with apologies for her critical letter to local high school sophomore Ana Garcia. In fact, she's hoping to visit Garcia's school next week to apologize in person.
You see, Gray learned after sending the letter that Garcia was a special needs student. That sort of explains why Garcia's writing skills are not as polished as a typical 9th grader's. Whoops!
"I have certainly regretted my comment to the student," Gray says.
She's also sorry about the poor writing in her own letter -- she answers her own e-mails personally and wrote that one hastily, she says.
After she wrote the letter to Ana, the girl replied:
Dear Mrs, Gray I'm sorry about my writing, I'm in a read180 class and wow you kids did go through this i mean school. Look I'm sorry about my questions many things do happen. Well i just wanted to right back i really hope you don't cut our budget thank you.
That was soon followed by a letter from Ana's PE teacher:
I am a PE teacher in the Glendale Union High Scool District. One of my
students recently wrote you a letter, her name was Ana Garcia. She
showed me the way you responded to her concerns about budget cuts. I
know Ana may not have articulated her thoughts clearly, but she works
hard in her classes everyday and is a very sweet girl. She often will
help me out with cleaning up equipment or motivating her friends to
participate-she means well. Just because she may not have a high IQ,
and she has a low reading level gives you no right to speak to her in
such a demeaning way. I was horrified that an adult in public office
would write that to a student who is trying to make a difference. Ana
has never tried to make a difference in politics until she was motivated
to write to a legislator. Your response to her was completely
deflating. She actually felt a need to apologize to you for not being
smart. I understand that you may be under pressure as the public is not
thrilled with our state's budget, but that gives you no right to hurt a
9th grade student's heart. I have a feeling your daughter, as a
teacher, would be embarrassed if you ever spoke to one of her students
that way. As a public official, you may be taking a lot of heat right
now, I can understand your frustration, but so you know for the future,
that is not an appropriate way to respond to anyone.
Several folks upset at Gray's reply sent the senator e-mails, too, including this one:
Dear Senator Gray,
My name is Andrew Page, and I am one of your constituents.
I recently read your response to an email sent to you by a fifteen year old high school student, and I was appalled. The tone of your email was condescending and completely inappropriate.
I have read Ana Garcia's email, and I have read your response. I noticed you opened your email by answering the student's questions. I am glad that you took the time to do so, but you were not thankful or gracious for the student's concern.
However, that was not the most troublesome.
You expressed your concern for the student's ability to pass the AIMS language test and pointed out incorrect punctuation. In your email you stated, "Why didn't you take TO time to write an email with the proper punctuation?" What does "take to time to write" mean? I am assuming you meant "take THE time to write" or maybe "take YOUR time to write." Perhaps in your hasty, emotional response, you made a mistake.
Once again, that was not the most troublesome either.
While the fifteen year old high school student's email did have punctuation and grammatical errors, your email shows a LACK OF CHARACTER and RESPECT. I have a higher standard for a publicly elected state Senator than I do for a high school freshman.
What do you think is more important in our culture today, a properly written email or character and respect?
Thank you for your valuable time.
Alumni from the Glendale UHSD
Gray sent them apolegetic replies.
So, whatever possessed Gray to send such a harsh letter to Ana in the first place? Who knows -- but we're pretty sure it won't happen again.
Keep Phoenix New Times Free... Since we started Phoenix New Times, it has been defined as the free, independent voice of Phoenix, and we would like to keep it that way. Offering our readers free access to incisive coverage of local news, food and culture. Producing stories on everything from political scandals to the hottest new bands, with gutsy reporting, stylish writing, and staffers who've won everything from the Society of Professional Journalists' Sigma Delta Chi feature-writing award to the Casey Medal for Meritorious Journalism. But with local journalism's existence under siege and advertising revenue setbacks having a larger impact, it is important now more than ever for us to rally support behind funding our local journalism. You can help by participating in our "I Support" membership program, allowing us to keep covering Phoenix with no paywalls.