Tom Horne's Complaint Against Mark Brnovich's Judge Wife Rejected

Keep New Times Free
I Support
  • Local
  • Community
  • Journalism
  • logo

Support the independent voice of Phoenix and help keep the future of New Times free.

Arizona Attorney General Tom Horne has a fierce following among certain women. In fact, the guy's got a whole cadre of gals willing to do his bidding, a veritable Praetorian Guard of political hatchet-ladies.

Kathleen Winn, Horne's outreach director and co-defendant in his campaign finance case, comes to mind. A die-hard Horne loyalist, I guess you could say she's the captain of Horne's Praetorian Guard.

One Horne partisan from Pinal County is Teresa Ottesen Binder, whom I met at a cocktail-party/fundraiser for the AG that I crashed back in May.

Binder struck me as a nice enough person, though like most in Horne's ever-dwindling camp, she seemed completely incapable of explaining her support for a sleaze like Horne.

Susan Brnovich's appearance in this campaign video for her hubby Mark is a-okay, according to AZ's Commission on Judicial Conduct

Binder was on the host committee for a May fundraiser for Horne, and in 2013, when Horne held a press conference, backing legislation allowing select educators to pack pistols in public schools, Binder, a substitute teacher, was there to support the proposal.

See also: -Mark Brnovich's Wife, Judge Susan Brnovich: Did She Pull a Lester Pearce?

I didn't know when I met her that Binder had used a piece I'd written in February to lodge a complaint against the wife of Horne's primary rival Mark Brnovich.

Read the Arizona Commission on Judicial Conduct's decision on Mark Brnovich's wife, Judge Susan Brnovich.

See, Susan Brnovich is a Maricopa County Superior Court Judge, and she has appeared in a YouTube video for the campaign, wherein she discusses what a great guy her husband is, natch.

Pretty tame stuff, but there was a legitimate question about whether Judge Brnovich was allowed to do this under Arizona's Code of Judicial Conduct, which bars judges from campaigning for anyone but themselves.

Former Justice of the Peace Lester Pearce famously fell afoul of this code while stumping for his brother, recalled ex-state Senator Russell Pearce.

As a result, Lester Pearce was censured and fined by Arizona's Commission on Judicial Conduct, though Lester had already left the bench to run unsuccessfully for county supervisor.

My article examined the issue and presented both sides. Binder sent along a copy of that blog item with her form complaint to the commission .

The commission rendered a judgment on the issue on May 19, in an order written by commission chair Louis Frank Dominguez.

According to this order, the commission was already looking into the matter when Binder submitted her complaint.

Essentially, the commission found that Judge Brnovich's actions were inside the line because, unlike in the Lester Pearce case, Brnovich did not identify herself as a judge and neither did the video. Rather, she was presented as Brnovich's devoted spouse.

Dominguez wrote:

With regard to the campaign video at issue, the judge did not appear in the campaign video in her capacity as a judge and did not identify herself as a judge. The video, similarly, did not identify the judge's office or position in any way. Further, Judge Brnovich did not state or imply that her position as a judge should persuade voters to support her husband.

The responsibility of the Commission on Judicial Conduct is to impartially determine if the judge engaged in conduct that violated the provisions of Article 6.1 of the Arizona Constitution or the Code of Judicial Conduct and, if so, to take appropriate disciplinary action. The purpose and authority of the commission is limited to this mission. The commission particularly notes that the Code explicitly states that its rules are "rules of reason" and that members are directed to consider a variety of factors and circumstances in determining whether a judge's conduct violates the Code in a particular situation.

After review of all relevant materials, facts, and circumstances, the commission found no evidence of ethical misconduct and concluded that Judge Brnovich did not violate the Code in this case.

While Rule 4.1(A)(3) prohibits a judicial officer from publicly endorsing another candidate for public office, and there is no "family exception" to this rule, the extension of the prohibition to a circumstance where the judge does not identify herself as a judge or even imply she is a judge is not consistent with the directive that the rules be applied as rules of reason. Based on the facts and circumstances specific to this case, the commission finds the judge did not violate Rule 4.1(A)(3).

Attorney Tom Ryan, the Irish wolfhound of Arizona election law and the guy representing Horne-accuser, former AG employee Sarah Beattie, was critical of Judge Brnovich's appearance in the video, when I initially wrote about it.

He was equally critical of commission's findings.

"Well, it's the parent's rule of `Because I say so,'" he commented via e-mail. "In rhetoric I studied the concept of logic fallacies. This is a logic fallacy best expressed by the Latin phrase `ipse dixit,' which literally means `he himself said it.' It is an unsupported statement that rests solely on the authority of the individual who makes it. There is no authority cited for this `rule of reason' the only proof we have of its existence is that this person said it."

Ryan is a purist in such matters, and admirably so. Though I personally find Susan Brnovich's appearance in this video to be small potatoes compared to, say, the transgressions of Lester Pearce.

I also contacted Binder to see if Horne put her up to the complaint or if she did it of her own accord.

She declined to make any statements for the record.

By contrast, Mark Brnovich's campaign manager Ryan Anderson practically oozed contempt when I asked for a comment.

"We always knew this graceless and false complaint filed by Ms. Binder on behalf of the Horne campaign would be quickly dismissed," he told me, via e-mail.

"Mark and Susan Brnovich have been happily and faithfully married for over 17 years," he continued. "No one is more qualified to speak about the values of her husband. Clearly Mark's family values are something that struck a nerve with Mr. Horne and we welcome the involvement of any of the other attorney general candidate spouses to appear in future commercials."

Horne's wife of more than 40 years, Marty, tends to stay out of the limelight. So Horne may not take up Anderson's challenge anytime soon.

On the other hand, can Mark Brnovich boast a Horne-like Praetorian Guard of gals ready to play torpedo?

Gotta admit, the AG's got him there.

Got a tip for The Bastard? Send it to: Stephen Lemons.

Follow Valley Fever on Twitter at @ValleyFeverPHX. Follow Stephen Lemons on Twitter at @StephenLemons.

Keep Phoenix New Times Free... Since we started Phoenix New Times, it has been defined as the free, independent voice of Phoenix, and we would like to keep it that way. Offering our readers free access to incisive coverage of local news, food and culture. Producing stories on everything from political scandals to the hottest new bands, with gutsy reporting, stylish writing, and staffers who've won everything from the Society of Professional Journalists' Sigma Delta Chi feature-writing award to the Casey Medal for Meritorious Journalism. But with local journalism's existence under siege and advertising revenue setbacks having a larger impact, it is important now more than ever for us to rally support behind funding our local journalism. You can help by participating in our "I Support" membership program, allowing us to keep covering Phoenix with no paywalls.

We use cookies to collect and analyze information on site performance and usage, and to enhance and customize content and advertisements. By clicking 'X' or continuing to use the site, you agree to allow cookies to be placed. To find out more, visit our cookies policy and our privacy policy.


Join the New Times community and help support independent local journalism in Phoenix.


Join the New Times community and help support independent local journalism in Phoenix.