Film Reviews

Tamara Drewe and the Comedy of Going Plastic in a Rustic World

Comely, independent, willful young lass returns to collect family inheritance in rural England, drives the local men wild, makes several misalliances, and inadvertently precipitates a catastrophe before nature finally takes its course. Adapted from Posy Simmonds' excellent graphic novel, Tamara Drewe knowingly updates Thomas Hardy's gloomy pastoral Far From the Madding Crowd and entertainingly postscripts Hans Christian Andersen's "The Ugly Duckling."

As directed by old pro Stephen Frears (The Queen, The Grifters, Dangerous Liaisons), the film is an ensemble affair, akin to a weekend-party comedy. The country house is a working writers' retreat ("far from the madding crowd" per its classified ad), owned by a smugly successful, womanizing hack (Roger Allam) and administered by his long-suffering, cake-baking domestic muse (Tamsin Greig). Notable residents include a Hardy-specializing academic nebbish (Bill Camp) and the farm's hunky handyman (Luke Evans). The eponymous heroine, formerly burdened with a world-class honker, makes her triumphant, nose-jobbed reappearance in the near-perfect form of Bond girl Gemma Arterton. The guys are smitten from the moment she bounds over the fence in tank top and cut-offs, although she confounds them by taking up with a sullen rock star on sabbatical (Dominic Cooper).

The dramatis personae are rounded out by a dissolute pair of local teens (Charlotte Christie and Jessica Barden) who worship the rocker, resent Tamara, and loathe the smooth and doughy hack. Commenting on the action as a rude Greek chorus even while providing the plot's deus ex machina, the schoolgirls are the movie's funniest characters; Tamara, whom they call "Plastic," is the most complex. Despite the evident pleasure that this adventurous, super-confident creature takes in her newly acquired powers (she's a newspaper columnist as well as a beauty), her anatomy is still her destiny: Tamara's dealings with men are as consistently unfortunate as those of her less attractive sisters, the hack's matronly wife and the rocker's adolescent admirers.

Tamara Drewe is self-consciously rustic (cut to shot of urinating cows) and broadly played, particularly by comparison to Simmonds' darker, more nuanced novel, in which the characters are less cuddly and the denouement not so tidy. Frears might have accelerated the comic pacing, but the story is a good one and events come nicely to boil. There have been far worse literary chick-flicks. Still, Woody Allen, to name one worker in the field, would doubtless have provided funnier one-liners.

KEEP PHOENIX NEW TIMES FREE... Since we started Phoenix New Times, it has been defined as the free, independent voice of Phoenix, and we'd like to keep it that way. With local media under siege, it's more important than ever for us to rally support behind funding our local journalism. You can help by participating in our "I Support" program, allowing us to keep offering readers access to our incisive coverage of local news, food and culture with no paywalls.
J. Hoberman
Contact: J. Hoberman