When Will Pinetop Native Zella Day Get The Break She Needs to Become a Star?

“Jameson,” the ninth track of Zella Day’s 2015 album, Kicker, stands out like a grassy meadow in a metropolis. Sparse in its vulnerability and despair, the song is just Day finger-picking acoustic chords as some gentle guitar lines float through the background. Day was just 18 when she wrote the song; it’s about her turbulent connection with a man 11 years her elder whom she loved madly. He was in a successful rock band that she declines to name, and seemed to want to drag her into his booze- and drug-heavy lifestyle. The song’s about refusing to go down those rabbit holes with him.

“I’m not a follower, and I won’t follow you,” she cries during each verse. 

The lyrics are the tears of a rebuffed intervention. On an album surrounded by heavily produced modern pop tracks, some of which feature a live orchestra, “Jameson” is the most poignant and stripped-down, and it’s Day’s favorite. She calls it “a perfect display and example of what I do” — just her and a guitar, writing songs about love and life. 

Yet she finds her young career heading in a completely different direction. 

Today, Zella Day is a 21-year-old budding pop starlet. She’s a Los Angeles resident who lives in the hippest part of the city, and she’s becoming a regular in magazines like InStyle and Teen Vogue that hone in on her unique style, a carefully crafted combination of California and Arizona. She’s one record into a three-album deal with Hollywood Records, and she’s a veteran of Coachella and Bonnaroo, as well as the late-night shows of Seth Meyers and Conan O’Brien. She’s been developing her songwriting skills with professionals in Nashville and LA since before she could drive. Her 18-year-old sister is an aspiring model in New York City who just appeared in W Magazine. Spotify users have listened to her songs almost 100 million times.

She’s also an Arizona native who spent her formative years on a ranch near Pinetop, a town of 4,200 that hugs Highway 260 in a sleepy part of the White Mountains. Named after a miner’s wife who lived in Jerome, the name Zella has roots in Arizona history. She’s a former high-school soccer player who at age 9 first performed at open mics at her grandmother’s coffee shop. 

Those close to her music career call her an “old soul.” People who knew teenage Zella remember her laser focus and ability to excel in anything she chose. She’s a polished media presence, speaking about her music in sound bites honed through the hundreds of interviews she’s done since being welcomed to the machine of a major-label deal just a few years ago.

She’s also fiercely self-assured in the clarity of her vision and determined to run her career on her terms. At 13, her talent convinced a neighbor to cover the costs of recording her debut album. That album didn’t make a splash outside her MySpace page, but it would get her in the door of J.P. Williams, the owner of Parallel Entertainment and the former manager of comedians like Jeff Foxworthy, Larry the Cable Guy, Jamie Foxx, and some of the Wayans brothers. She impressed Williams so much that he signed her on the spot, and now, years later, she remains the only musician he personally manages. 

But Day now stands at a career crossroads. One year after the release of her debut album, she still can’t seem to get enough radio play to truly reach the mainstream listening public’s ears. She’s taken the hard route to secure creative control of her music, but now she must decide whether to embrace the roots of her isolated upbringing among classic rock records, or to immerse herself in the modern pop that defines LA and the global market beyond. 

Day, whose birth name is Zella Day Kerr, moved to Long Beach, California, when she was 16, and she’s lived in Silver Lake, the so-called “Brooklyn of Los Angeles,” for about two years. When choosing the location of an interview, she opts for Cafe Stella, which serves as a salon of sorts for the neighborhood’s hipsters, actors, and artists. 

Day is slender and athletic, her oval face framing strikingly blue, almond-shaped eyes that grow rounder when she talks about something that excites her. She arrives wearing a white crop top and white pants that loosely cling to her legs. Light-brown hair curls slightly before stopping to rest just under her shoulder blades. Her outfit certainly fits the hippie-chic look you see at music festivals like Coachella, but is tempered with a Southwestern flair, at this moment visible in the turquoise stones set in the four silver rings on her fingers, and in the single brown feather that sits atop her flat-brimmed white hat. 

Her connection to the Golden State runs deeper than the six years or so she’s lived there, as her mom’s family is from Long Beach. “Growing up, [I felt] like I was such a California girl, and I needed to get out of Arizona,” Day says. “The grass is always greener, right?” 

She quickly realized being a mountain girl set her apart from the multitudes of LA transplants, and it didn’t take long for her to embrace her upbringing.

“What makes me different and unique is the fact that I grew up in a very small town in Arizona,” she says. “And I think my perspective is one to listen to and be heard because I have something different to say.” 

While Day was born in Phoenix, her parents initially moved to Pinetop when she was young to help start a backcountry snowboarding operation in nearby Greer that was converted into a luxury guest ranch called Hidden Meadow in 2002. Hidden Meadow became quite successful — Conde Nast’s luxury travel mag Johansens named it the “most excellent” ranch in the United States in 2011 — and Day spent her childhood riding horses and exploring the valleys and forests of the Pinetop area.

Visiting Pinetop, it’s not hard to understand why an ambitious teenager would want out. The northeastern Arizona town, officially called Pinetop-Lakeside after it merged with a nearby municipality in the ’80s, is flanked by the Apache Reservation and the Apache-Sitgreaves National Forest. Calling it isolated is an understatement. The nearest university is 150 miles away in Flagstaff, and nearby Show Low hosts the closest community college, Northern Pioneer College, which employs fewer people than the town’s Home Depot. With its picturesque lakes and easy access to mountain recreation, Pinetop is a popular destination for vacation homes and seasonal tourism. As a result, swaths of homes sit unoccupied for much of the year, and opportunities are limited for the 200 or so graduates that come out of Blue Ridge High School, the town’s lone public high school, every year. 

Day’s mother, Ana Kerr, operated a crafts studio called Art Smarts that shared a wall with a coffee shop, Mor Mor Coffee, run by Day’s maternal grandmother. Kerr noticed her daughter’s affinity for music at a young age — as a toddler she could sing parts of Disney songs by heart — and at age 9, her grandma bought her a guitar. Pinetop offered limited arts opportunities for elementary schoolgirls, but her grandmother hosted a weekly open mic that attracted a core group of guys playing acoustic guitar covers. This exposure to live music inspired Day, and it didn’t take her long to stage her first performance — acoustic covers of “Blowin’ In The Wind” and “Hound Dog,” along with an original song of her own, a tribute to her first-grade crush.

“The song was about how boys just don’t get it,” she says, throwing back her head and laughing. “That was my message I wanted to put out as a 9-year-old.”

In school, Day’s sixth-grade teacher, Gretchen Polkinghorne, remembers her as a “brilliant,” hard-working, and well-liked student who starred in the class’ production of Twelfth Night. She was mature for her age as well, with many older friends.

“Sixth grade is such a drama year for kids. She didn’t really have any of that,” says Polkinghorne, who now teaches sixth grade in Minnesota. “She was kind of in the middle of things, but never really got any of that angsty middle-school drama.”

As Day grew older, she drifted towards soccer, where she played with the boys’ team in Pinetop and considered vying for an athletic scholarship at nearby Northern Arizona University. 

“Everything she did was all the way,” says her mom. “She took herself very seriously.”

Possessing an uncanny focus and a mother willing to push her to develop her talents, Day began taking guitar lessons in Phoenix, with her mother regularly making the eight-hour round trip. 

“I have to give a lot of credit to her as a mother,” Day says of her mom. “[She was] pushy, but in the right ways.”

Always, Day was writing songs. She had songs about everything, from appreciating what you have to how she doesn’t “feel groovy until I put my red pants on.” Moreover, she was enough of a sensation in Pinetop that a neighbor, Neil DuCharme, offered up $20,000 so she could record an album. The CD, Powered By Love, came out in 2008, when Day was 13.

“Some people donate money to scholarships,” Kerr says. “He gave to Zella.”

Powered By Love didn’t make Day a star, however. Her next big break came from MTV. While signing up for a School of Rock-style summer camp for teens, Day noticed a link soliciting campers to be filmed for an MTV reality show, something akin to the True Life series. She signed up, and on the first day of camp, she woke up to cameras in her face. After an argument with an older girl named Rebecca, she ended up in middle of some unanticipated reality TV faux-drama. 

“There was a shock factor to having this experience at camp and having it be so positive, and then watching it on MTV, and being like, ‘Wow, they really manipulated this into a dramatic episode,’” she recalls.

MTV ended up running the episode just once, but the exposure caused the traffic to Day’s MySpace page to explode overnight. Encouraged, she and her mother asked around Pinetop, and once again, fortune smiled upon them. A family friend’s brother-in-law knew someone in Los Angeles, and the CD ended up in the hands of a guy working for Tom Werner, chairman of the Boston Red Sox and the producer of The Cosby Show. The rep said she needed a manager, and made the introduction to the man who would help guide her career to where it is today.

KEEP PHOENIX NEW TIMES FREE... Since we started Phoenix New Times, it has been defined as the free, independent voice of Phoenix, and we'd like to keep it that way. With local media under siege, it's more important than ever for us to rally support behind funding our local journalism. You can help by participating in our "I Support" program, allowing us to keep offering readers access to our incisive coverage of local news, food and culture with no paywalls.
David Accomazzo is a music wrangler, award-winning reporter, critic, and editor with more than a decade in the business.
Contact: David Accomazzo