Matt & Kim's Place Among Other Too-Happy Rockers
If you watch the music video for Matt & Kim's indie-dance hit "Daylight" but know nothing else about the band, here's exactly what you'll think:
"Good gracious. Those are very happy-looking people."
Frolicking through their Brooklyn 'hood, humorously crammed into refrigerators, dumpsters, and other uncomfortable spaces while — wait for it! — continuously playing their instruments, vocalist/keyboardist Matt Johnson and drummer Kim Schifino never stop beaming. Ever. They're like White Stripes on brain-zapping dosages of Zoloft — and quite possibly the happiest-looking band of their generation.
Happiness is a dubious thing when it comes to musicians. Often, the hard-earned rewards of contentment, prosperity, and sobriety precede inferior work in the studio (see: Tweedy, Jeff) or rudely trigger a Bizarro-world transformation that feels wholly at odds with the host's former persona (see: Stipe, Michael).
Of course, we don't know whether Matt & Kim are actually happy. They're happy-looking, which is its own thing, a style choice. And like a careless swipe of rouge, it can be overdone and unconvincing. Let's compare and contrast the dance-punk duo with other noted big-smilers:
Louis Armstrong: Unless he had a trumpet shoved in there, the "La Vie en Rose" crooner always had a smile on his gob. Coupled with the wistful and bittersweet themes of his music, Armstrong's indomitable good cheer had a sad, peculiar edge — the kind of consoling, world-weary happiness that a kindly uncle might evince while breaking tragic news. Hey, if you have to hear that your dog got sucked into a jet turbine, you might as well hear it from Satchmo.
Mick Jagger: Invariably, the Rolling Stones frontman seems very happy to be performing. But unlike Matt & Kim's brand of playful, non-threatening happiness, Jagger also projects arrogance, flamboyance, and raw, omnisexual menace. He's sexy-happy, in the manner of an all-powerful rock titan who would be doing you a favor by picking your date out of the crowd and giving 'er a nice slap-and-tickle backstage.
Ozzy Osbourne: Like fellow heavy-metal-frontman-turned-reality-TV-star Gene Simmons, Osbourne didn't just affect rock coolness on stage — he turned sadistic delight into a personal style accessory. With those wide, batshit-insane eyes and raptor grin, he was unmistakably happy — but mirthless, too. Call it evil-happy. (Interesting how both he and Simmons have found the same retirement garden — what a shtick!)
Post-Document R.E.M.: I will continue to believe that Michael Stipe's decision to come out of the closet and embrace his happy-gay essence is one of indie-rock's all-time great tragedies — he was so much more interesting and cool when he was a mumbling miserable. The worst part of it is, he encouraged the rest of R.E.M. to be happy-looking, too — an unforgivable act of mind control enshrined in the video for the band's execrable shit-anthem "Shiny Happy People." Stipe came off looking like a deranged cosmic swami: "Smile! Dance! Wear these white tennis shoes! Drink this Kool-Aid!" Scary.
Katrina and the Waves: Temperamentally, Matt & Kim have much in common with the '80s pop-rockers. It's telling that the bands' biggest hits ("Sunshine" and "Walking on Sunshine," respectively) share a strong lyrical similarity, but it goes beyond that. Like K&tW, Matt & Kim have aggressively branded themselves as always-positive, fun-loving personalities, from the endearingly hokey "Draw Matt & Kim" feature on their website to the fact that they're grinning in virtually every photograph released of them. Hence, they risk consigning themselves to a lightweight pop ghetto of their own making. But, hey, whatever makes them happy.
Get the Music Newsletter
Keep your thumb on the local music scene with music features, additional online music listings and show picks. We'll also send special ticket offers and music promotions available only to our Music Newsletter subscribers.